3 ms·
Buy something that is globally diversified. If the global economy is on a 20 year downturn you probably have more serious problems than your investments.
by adrianN 9y ago
Buy something that is globally diversified. If the global economy is on a 20 year downturn you probably have more serious problems than your investments.
- paganel 9y ago> Buy something that is globally diversified. That's the thing, can ETFs do that? I.e., can they make active investment decisions (like, how do you diversify globally)? By the current definition I think the answer is "no", but it's interesting how things will evolve, though.
- adrianN 9y agoWhat? Why can't ETFs do that? Buy some combination of MSCI World and something for "emerging markets" and you're halfway there.
- paganel 9y ago> Buy some combination of MSCI World and something for "emerging markets" and you're halfway there. During the last crisis (2007-2011) the stock indexes fell almost in unison around the world (including MSCI World). Had you "diversified" into it in February 2008 (just as Bear Sterns was imploding) you wouldn't have made your money back until 2013-2014 (I took the data from here: http://www.stockq.org/index_en/MS001.php http://www.stockq.org/index_en/MS001.php). Correlation can hit you pretty damn hard. But there were active investors who made lots of money during that same time-frame. Later edit: Plus, switching from a ETF focused on US stocks to one focused on MSCI World (let's say) looks like active investing to me, i.e. you have to take an action based on what you think the future will bring (in this case you think MSCI World will be more stable than US stocks). I was responding more to the OP when he was saying about how he/she would like to put his/her money in an ETF and forget about it.
- kspaans 9y agoAnd most of those stock indexes recovered within 1-2 years. If you didn't panic sell your paper loses would have gone away pretty quickly. Not to mention almost no one's cost basis would be the peak price from 2007, most people would have an average cost basis of lower than that do to periodic investments from previous years. If your doing a long-term buy & hold strategy, you really don't need to worry about temporary dips in your portfolio. That's why the ETF-and-forget-it long-term strategy is nice. If you're investing and you don't have a long time horizon or you're scared of a dip in your portfolio, you don't belong in the stock market anyway (stick to bonds and other conservative investments).
- warrenm 9y ago>Had you "diversified" into it in February 2008 (just as Bear Sterns was imploding) you wouldn't have made your money back until 2013-2014 That's paper losses - unless you panic sold If you kept investing throughout that time, you'd be substantially further ahead than otherwise
- hervature 9y agoI think it is still possible to have a 20 year "downturn" and the world doesn't deteriorate. Essentially a complete reversal of what caused growth in many different industries. I'll just go through a couple of industries. Banking - Governments around the world decide to break up big banks. This allows for the return of small local co-ops that aren't listed on the stock market. Now the market is super competitive and so the big banks stock go into decline (the hypothetical value of the co-ops increase but you can't capitalize on that). Mining - Recycling gets so advanced we no longer need to mine stuff. Mining industry is no a shadow of its former self. New industry isn't as valuable as before as the barrier to entry into recycling is much lower. Healthcare - US government decides to take over the industry because a cultural shift. Industry collapses. Now, we live in a world with no Wall St, environmentally stable, and everyone has access to healthcare. But the people who went into ETF's essentially have no money. Obviously, this world would require much reform (more taxes), but one that I don't think is entirely unobtainable.