9 ms·
How San Francisco's bike-share scheme became a symbol of gentrification
- to_bpr 9y ago> A bike-sharing scheme has sparked outrage and vandalism from those who see it as designed for affluent, white professionals – not locals That this could ever be written, seriously, points toward how toxic the times we are living in have become.
- WalterSear 9y agoIt's not. It's a symbol of what is wrong with its opponents in SF, who are committed to opposing any change that doesn't benefit them directly. Mario, a San Francisco user of the bike-share program, who has a discounted membership because he qualifies for food stamps, said he was perplexed by the backlash. “It’s the cheapest transportation option we have,” said the 29-year-old, who works as an administrative assistant and asked not to use his full name, because he feared backlash from anti-gentrification activists.
- FussyZeus 9y ago> It's not. It's a symbol of what is wrong with its opponents in SF, who are committed to opposing any change that doesn't benefit them directly. Which makes them distinct from exactly no one? This is a conflict of culture not of benefits. This is a result of city planners who do not talk to the communities they plan for/in, and who arbitrarily make changes to public services and facilities without input from the people who actually live in the places they're in. I'm willing to bet money that nobody who decided where these bike stations went ever even spoke to the poor in the areas where they went. I'm also willing to bet that the people in those areas, even if it isn't true, believed that the extra parking spaces and extra traffic lanes benefitted them more than the bikes. If they didn't, they wouldn't be destroying them. I'm not saying vandalizing is the solution here, but with the wealthy tech sector utterly dictating the price of housing and consequently shoving out literally everyone else all over the Bay Area, is it really such a reach of logic to think that a shiny rack of new bicycles, no doubt transacted via some kind of app or spiffy web service, is not going to be a lightning rod for communities that are getting the shit beat out of them by a tech obsessed elite?
- zzalpha 9y agoI'm also willing to bet that the people in those areas, even if it isn't true, believed that the extra parking spaces and extra traffic lanes benefitted them more than the bikes. If they didn't, they wouldn't be destroying them. Hah, classic engineering mistake: assuming people are rational. People hate change. People really hate change they didn't choose (irrespective of whether that change is good or bad), because people want to feel in control. On top of that, given the sheer, mindless hostility that cyclists receive from non-cyclists (some deserved, most not at all), when you mix that with rage over gentrification, these bike share programs should've been seen as a target before they ever got rolled out. So I agree with you that I'll bet the roll out of this program was botched. But I very much disagree that the subsequent reaction was rational or thought out based on a cost-benefit analysis.
- scurvy 9y agoI bet that Mission residents would complain if they didn't get any bicycle stations. "Why are these only in rich neighborhoods? Why are the poor excluded? Poor people need these!" It's a classic Bay Area story. Any kind of change is met with backlash from somewhere. No place does self-righteous entitlement quite like the Bay Area.
- mrgordon 9y agoMy part of the Mission didn't get a bike station because of NIMBYs who complained it would gentrify the neighborhood and remove parking. In other words, they specifically blocked it from being an option for the poor people while the rich neighborhoods were like sure put some bikes in.
- KirinDave 9y agoIt's depressing that you point to the animosity of communities that have been traditionally on the sour end of many transit projects and claim their reaction is irrational. Given that total knowledge is costly and time-consuming to acquire and often the window for action is shorter than the time it would take to acquire a total understanding of the situation, it's only natural people take cognitive shortcuts.
- KirinDave 9y agoWhat's unfortunate is that bike sharing directly benefits many communities with lower income in many ways, as is noted in the article (and if you live in the area, you'll almost certainly encounter the discussion). I think it's entirely reasonable to be mad about a lack of community consult, but I think that this is ultimately the City's fault and not the bikeshare programs. It's unlikely that the outcome of the share point placement would have been much different, but the reduction of vandalization would have easily covered the initial cost. Sadly, San Francisco has a history of not treating certain communities fairly. They're obligated to do more to undo this bad work, in the event of a program that can be genuinely shown to help everyone.
- tmh79 9y ago> I think it's entirely reasonable to be mad about a lack of community consult There were many, many, many community meetings about the bike share program expansion and ample time for anyone to give feedback. People always cry crocodile tears no matter how much public input is put into the process. Source: I'm an advocate for these things, see it at ALL of the meetings I go to. > They're obligated to do more to undo this bad work, in the event of a program that can be genuinely shown to help everyone. The program doesn't need to help _everone_ it needs to do more good than harm. There will be a ton of people who don't benefit directly by this but that is not a reason to remove or roll them back.
- mrgordon 9y agoI think the "lack of community consult" is fictitious to be honest. It is easy to say someone should have reached out to the community more with no facts. https://missionlocal.org/2017/07/neighborhood-group-rejects-bike-share-expansion-to-24th-street/ https://missionlocal.org/2017/07/neighborhood-group-rejects-... ~~~~~ “We really want this to be seen as an asset to all communities around the city,” said Simon. But Arguello said that his group will not negotiate. “We told them no, and there will be opposition,” he said. Simon said that the company has done rigorous community outreach, including more than 30 town hall meetings with residents, to gauge approval and need in the city’s neighborhoods. ~~~~~ Also, hey Dave!
- 9y ago
- olleromam91 9y ago|Any change that doesn't benefit them directly a.k.a. gentrification
- WalterSear 9y agoGentrification isn't that. Gentrification is other people's gain impinging on a community. However, healthy forms of transit are valued by the out class, and new forms of business are associated with them. Protesting a low-cost, low-impact community transit option is as transparent an announcement of prejudice as you can expect.
- spurcell93 9y agoAs a probably gentrifier in NYC, I can relate to both sides of this issue. I have friends who grew up in Brooklyn who are so incensed by gentrification that they throw garbage all over the street, in order to deter "more fucking billionaires from moving into their high rises". Feelings aren't always rational, nor are our reactions to them. I applaud outreach groups who are trying to find common ground here. As Mario says, “It’s the cheapest transportation option we have.” And everyone should be onboard with that, especially because it also helps solve congestion that makes quality of life worse for all residents (travel time, air quality, noise...)
- paganel 9y ago> in order to deter "more fucking billionaires from moving into their high rises" They're most probably fighting a losing battle. The only thing that can now stop the NYC real-estate bubble from inflating even further would be a severe financial crisis, in which case your friends' neighborhood gentrification will be the last of their problems.
- adammck 9y agoI wonder if your friend is also incensed by all the low- and middle-income families moving into those high-rises, or just by the "billionaires" who make that feasible.
- tbrock 9y agoThis article is one of the most rediculous thing I've ever read. San Francisco needs those bikes for people to get around because the public transportation in SF is downright awful. The "subway" is composed of cars from many lines that travel through a single tube and then go on the street and become subject to the traffic. I walk faster than many bus lines. If anything, the bikes make life easier for everyone here and that is a good thing.
- KirinDave 9y agoThat's sort of besides the point, as the article points out. Many people realize these are in fact an economic boon. But since the rollout was handled poorly (particularly by the city) it's unsurprising that folks objected to parking and space being displaced without any clear explanation of the value proposition.
- tbrock 9y agoDoes the value proposition of bikes for rent at lower cost than provided by existing bike rentals needs to be explained? A single rack might displace 2 parking spaces at the most.
- KirinDave 9y ago> Does the value proposition of bikes for rent at lower cost than provided by existing bike rentals needs to be explained? The cost of it, its availability, and eligibility certainly needs to be explained. How would anyone know them otherwise? I've seen multiple stations and the signage explaining the program did not answer my questions, but rather referred me to a website. That's not an option for everyone, nor were the signs I saw in a diversity of languages to improve comprehension. Maybe the stations I saw lacked these features and others have them, so I will accept correction there.
- mrgordon 9y agoYou might be right here that the stations could do a better job of explaining different options, but it seems like people will tell their friends about it and learn about it that way if its useful. To be honest though, almost every major city has a bike share now so I am a little perplexed that we need to reexplain its value from first principles.
- scurvy 9y agoHaters gonna hate...everything. Anyone who mutilates a bicycle like this has deep seated psychological issues that go way beyond planning and any gentrification issues.
- jstepka 9y agoamen
- ienjoythebeach 9y ago> Bike lanes have often become proxies in urban conflicts over gentrification, seen as a street design geared to young professionals, techies and hipsters and a pathway to trendy coffee shops, high-end retail and luxury apartments. Strong disagree. Bike lanes are a necessary part of any city's infrastructure, providing a safe way for all cyclists to move from one point, to another. To anchor bike lanes to groups of people like techies and hipsters is absurd.
- rhallie11 9y agoI think another way it could have been put: no one cared enough about bike riders to put in bike lanes until wealthier riders moved in. Like, yeah, totally agree that bike lanes are an important part of any city's street planning. The more absurd thing is that there have been people riding bikes through the streets of SF for decades, and it wasn't until parts of the city began to gentrify, and bike shares became popular amongst the wealthier residents, that anyone cared enough to fix the problem.
- dionidium 9y agoPeople who agitate for change are more likely to get change. Wealthy residents advocated for bike lanes. The previous residents didn't. How else could the world possibly work?
- ncallaway 9y agoAre you sure the previous residents didn't advocate for change? You don't think there's a small chance the previous residents _did_ advocate for change, but their advocacy wasn't effective because it wasn't backed by wealth?
- mc32 9y agoIt's not that simple. For many poor and middle class people bikes were a sign you were poor and could not afford a car. So some people in the middle would avoid biking so as not to look poor. Upper middle class, having some security and wealth didn't care about "looking poor". They could ride $5000 bikes to display wealth or could ride $50 used bikes, interchangeably. They already had status so bikes were neutral or even positive (I'm active, I'm pro environment, etc.)
- francisofascii 9y agoI would think historically and perhaps globally, travelling by car was a symbol of wealth, and bikes were for the masses and the poor. So the attacks are more likely directed at a culture that embraces bikes rather than directed at gentrification.
- gaius 9y agoNot anymore. Not owning a car is the symbol of wealth now, it says "to me the cost of Uber and Deliveroo is nothing".
- habosa 9y agoThere are comments about how communities were not consulted before installing these bikes. I found it so refreshing to actually see something happen in SF. No endless community town hall meetings, pilot programs, bond measures, and political grandstanding. Instead a bunch of cheap and publicly accessible bikes appeared overnight. No of course the program is not perfect, but if the city had asked every single person if they were OK with it we would have ended up with nothing.
- DarkKomunalec 9y agoThe proportion of whites in San Francisco is steadily falling [0], yet the interviewees are upset that rich white people are moving in. Whites went from 92% in 1940, to 42% in 2010, and still there's too many? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_San_Francisco#Race_and_ethnicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_San_Francisco#...
- CryptoFascist 9y agoExplicit prejudice against whites is accepted in the Bay Area, and many Bay Area companies. Downvotes, eh? The article itself contains a complaint about "seeing more affluent white people come into neighbourhoods".
- DarkKomunalec 9y ago> Explicit prejudice against whites is accepted in the Bay Area, and many Bay Area companies. I'm sure that, as the US becomes more diverse, things will turn around.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CryptoFascist 9y agoSo how long until SF and the Bay Area's anti-development, anti-improvement ethos causes some other place (Austin/Denver)? to replace Silicon Valley. For me, I'm only here for the money I get to keep after expenses. Once somewhere else matches that and without the crazy whining about gentrification and privilege, and the extreme NIMBYism, I'm gone. I suspect the same is true for many others.
- santaclaus 9y ago> So how long until SF and the Bay Area's anti-development, anti-improvement ethos causes some other place (Austin/Denver)? to replace Silicon Valley. > For me, I'm only here for the money I get to keep after expenses. Once somewhere else matches that and without the crazy whining about gentrification and privilege, and the extreme NIMBYism, I'm gone. I suspect the same is true for many others. Can't comment on Austin, but having lived in the Bay and Denver, there is just as much gnashing of teeth and nativism in Denver (let alone Boulder, my god). Same goes for Portland, Seattle, hell, even NYC. Locales like to act like they are the only city in the states undergoing demographic shifts.
- visarga 9y agoAll cities change, can't stop time from flowing. It's not just the LA culture that is under threat of change. I don't see a good side or a bad side to this process. It just is.
- mundo 9y ago> Supporters of the program said it could help people struggling to make ends meet and claimed it is one of the most accessible in the country, with a $5 annual membership for low-income people and options to sign up without a credit or debit card. This is the most enraging part of the article. The people who administer this program spent time and money to make it more accessible to the poor, and they're still vilified as gentrifiers. Will they bother to do that next time? Isn't the lesson here, "don't bother to sit down and listen to the activists and incorporate their feedback, it won't help"?
- mattpratt 9y ago> “Overnight, they just came and set this up. They had no respect for this community.” A common narrative amongst opponents of the program is the lack of community outreach. Not mentioned in the article is that Motivate, the company that runs the bike share program, reached out to communities and collected feedback for 2+ years before rolling the program out. Outreach report from February: https://s3.amazonaws.com/babs-www-assets/FordGoBikeInterim+Outreach+Report-February2017.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/babs-www-assets/FordGoBikeInterim+O...
- mrgordon 9y agoYeah its amazing the opponents can just lie and say it happened overnight. I knew where the stations were going for a LONG time and there were over 30 community meetings. Meanwhile the critics say they "will not negotiate" with the bike share program. Never a good sign.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoThe privilege of being a non-white professional in San Francisco is getting to join a housing development protest to check out details on the new trendy building I want to consider living. I hope they put up a bike station near it too.
- tmh79 9y agoI live in the neighborhood in question. The "nextdoor" group for the neighborhood has a healthy mix of "new comers" and "long timers/latinos". There is a poll in the neighborhood asking "should the bike share stations be allowed in the mission", and right now it has about 75% "yes", 20% "no" and 5% "I don't know". IMO, this poll is clearly not scientific, but it does show broad based support for the bikes, and my view is that those who are virulently against the bikes are a distinct, loud minority of residents in the neighborhood.
- mrgordon 9y agoYea its probably mostly Calle 24 to be honest
- choward 9y agoI would like to know more about the Ford sponsorship. First of all, why would they sponsor it? How much are they paying? Is there another bike share program that doesn't require me to be a moving Ford advertisement?
- mrgordon 9y agoCitibike, Ford, Barclays... most the major bike shares have corporate sponsors. They sponsor it because they get highly visible advertising and they collect mobility data about where people move between.
- mitabaston 9y agoIt's easy to slash bike tires, it's hard to move into a high paying job in SF when you're not already on the right track. I'm one of the people doing my fair share of displacing low income people. And that's because I happen to be able to afford the huge rent. Do I like seeing that kind of money going to my landlord? No way! Would I be interested in seeing more political initiatives designed to increase the housing supply? Yes! Am I worried about who will be able to afford to live here and teach my kids or police the streets? Yes again! What about the chronic nimbyism that plagues the area? People that already own houses here are desperate not to see any devaluation to their properties. It pains me to see the murals in the Mission portraying tech people as the bad guys, when to me it's more like we're just the visible newcomers that are getting most of the blame. At least for now we get to share some of the attention with the bike sharing system.
- forapurpose 9y agoIn my city, bike sharing stations are in wealthy / hip neighborhoods, and bike lanes connect those neighborhoods with each other and with the places such people go. The bike stations are not in neighborhoods of people who need inexpensive transportation, and the bike lanes do not connect, for example, poor and working class people with their jobs. For example, bike lanes connecting poor immigrant communities with the restaurants where many of the residents work would be great. Requiring a credit card also limits access (though I don't know if that's still true). Bike sharing is designed by the young, upwardly mobile urban, for the young, upwardly mobile urban - maybe that's done unconsciously, but that's the outcome I see in my town.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIt costs money to provide bicycles, and bicycles are easy to steal and break. There most likely exists a funding and expense problem in poor immigrant communities that makes it unfeasible to offer bicycles, the local government does not collect enough tax and the losses from theft and damage to bicycles too high. Requiring a credit card with a sufficient amount of credit limit fixes this issue.
- forapurpose 9y ago> There most likely exists a funding and expense problem in poor immigrant communities that makes it unfeasible to offer bicycles The funding for the wealthy and poor communities all comes from the same city treasury. > Requiring a credit card with a sufficient amount of credit limit fixes this issue. So much for opportunity, democracy, and equality under the law. Only the few who qualify get the real benefits of citizenship. Billy Bragg once sang (referring to Ronald Reagan's "Morning in America"): It's morning in America And you can be your best If you have a major credit card And can pass a urine test
- mrgordon 9y agoWithout knowing what city you're talking about, it could be like SF where the poor neighborborhoods blocked bikes. Here they say the bikes are too expensive for poor people even though its $5/year if you qualify for discounted public transit.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoIt's the alt-left vs the moderate left (of which I'm a part of, I think bike lanes and bike sharing are great ideas). Just goes to show you that the crazies aren't just in the Republican party.
- saosebastiao 9y agoSan Francisco's brand of liberalism has jumped the shark. It's like they live in opposite world. It's bad enough that they believe that way to lower housing costs is to never build anything at all and to impose rent control in a market that is all too willing to convert to condos and sell. But now they are arguing that the lowest cost form of urban transportation should be stripped of its infrastructure in order to protect against gentrification. It's crazy, and they should be ashamed of their inability to critically think about anything at all.
- mrgordon 9y agoOne of the most ridiculous facts that gets overlooked in all this is that the bike share wanted to offer cheaper day passes to use the bikes. The bike rental shops pushed back and said it would harm their business so the bike share couldn't offer a cheap daily pass and had to push people to either a very short rental (say 30-45 minutes) or a long term membership. Now everyone blames the bike share for not having a reasonable pass to bike for a few hours or the whole day even though it was their competition that made it that way!