4 ms·
Well, from a completely cynical perspective I'm curious if this is what it takes to get government agencies with an operating policy completely disconnected fro
by dmix 9y ago
Well, from a completely cynical perspective I'm curious if this is what it takes to get government agencies with an operating policy completely disconnected from reality to start functioning properly.
Similar to how the competition between the CIA/FBI and the two-decade-too-late lack of connection between information systems prevented them from being able to detect 9/11 despite having multiple (disconnected) early indicators.
I've read enough War Nerd blog posts [1] to know the American Navy (and Airforce) are completely disconnected from the reality of modern warfare by still being obsessed with billion dollar aircraft carriers and expensive 'stealth' jets from a bygone era (3-4 decades ago) which would be the lowest hanging fruit in any modern war. Basically billion dollar machines that will be predictably destroyed within the early hours of any combat by a barrage of low cost missiles and highly mobile small attack boats by today's well known adversaries.
Although those are the disconnects from the highly complex real-world situations their stated mandates would put them in...whereas crashing into a commercial boats in high-traffic sea lanes seems like something that no sophisticated Navy should suffering from twice in a few months...let alone having multiple fatalities from each. So I'm not sure how to react to this honestly.
Other than having zero surprise that it's happening to one of the bigger modern governments where disfunction is the status quo and cronyism outranks tangible progress.
[1] https://pando.com/2014/05/26/the-war-nerd-iran-is-building-a-fake-aircraft-carrier-how-can-you-tell/ https://pando.com/2014/05/26/the-war-nerd-iran-is-building-a...
- forapurpose 9y ago> I've read enough War Nerd blog posts [1] to know ... The War Nerd is stimulating and entertaining, but the author, John Dolan, is a sometime English professor with no military expertise or experience. Per Wikipedia, his "PhD thesis on the literary works of the Marquis de Sade." Apparently, he did geek out on military hardware books when he was young, so there's that. On the other hand, as I said, it's a fun, stimulating read. If you like Dolan, I recommend his old publication (where the War Nerd originally appeared, AFAIK), The Exile, if you can find it. I've never read anything like it.
- warcher 9y agoThat was quite the ad hominem right there.
- mr_overalls 9y agoThere are different levels of ad hominem. Recognizing that a claimant lacks experience or education to make a highly technical/scientific claim is a useful first filter in considering whether to devote the time to evaluate an argument. For example, if Richard Feynman had published a paper claiming to have invented a prototype anti-gravity machine, his claim would have been taken much more seriously than if an uneducated TV repairman from eastern Omaha had claimed the same thing. Perhaps that's an ad hominem against the repairman, but in the real world, it's also a useful heuristic. Our time and attention are constrained quantities - doubly so in the age of the Internet where anyone can claim anything.
- jabl 9y agoSure, time is limited and the internet provides an endless supply of cranks in all categories. That being said, while I'm not familiar with the other writings of this Dolan person, he's hardly the first to argue that carrier battle groups are, if not outright obsolete, at least pretty poor choices on a bang per buck basis in a fight against a technologically advanced adversary. Are they all cranks? You make a comparison to science, but I do think it's slightly different. A military is by its nature a strongly hierarchical organization, and there's something in such organizations that makes them hard to turn around when circumstances change. A scientist, OTOH, if he manages to upend the status quo, fame and fortune (eh, maybe lets forget that fortune part, but still) awaits him. So maybe military leaders would be well advised to consider outside opinions in order to not be led astray by institutional inertia?
- warcher 9y agoI would argue that the readership of that blog would merit at least a discussion of his argument, which you will not even attempt. Like it or not, people know who he is and they read what he writes. If he's wrong, it's doubly important that you address his point of view, because a lot of people are reading it. Going ad hominem just gives credence to his unspoken assertion that the US military is an old-boys club clinging to their preconceived notions in the absence of an actual war to fight. I would further argue that someone being wholly ignorant whereof they speak would make it very easy to dismantle their position. I've seen it happen pretty often on the internet.