4 ms·
> Both how to deflect them (peacefully) Curious about your parenthesized addition. How do you deflect an asteroid non-peacefully?
by ars 9y ago
> Both how to deflect them (peacefully)
Curious about your parenthesized addition. How do you deflect an asteroid non-peacefully?
- thatcherc 9y agoThe ability to deflect asteroids away from Earth also means you can deflect them toward Earth and even aim them at your enemies! You could sneakily aim a meteor strike at anywhere on Earth and make it look like a natural event. Technically this is something that could be done today with gravity tractor [0] or an ion beam deflection [1] system, both of which are being developed by NASA. [0] - https://www.nasa.gov/content/asteroid-grand-challenge/mitigate/gravity-tractor https://www.nasa.gov/content/asteroid-grand-challenge/mitiga... [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ion_Beam_Shepherd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ion_Beam_Shepherd
- ars 9y ago> You could sneakily aim a meteor strike at anywhere on Earth Can you? Are you sure? My understanding is that it's not possible to predict the trajectory at less than the size of a continent. Much less actually control it.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoWell it just so happens that the 3 countries where this would be seen as favorable attack vector against the others happen to be the size of continents. Mainly China, Russia, and The USA.
- mikeash 9y agoIn principle it's no different from predicting the path of a spaceship, which can be done with great accuracy. The error comes from imprecision in knowledge of the meteor's location and velocity, which would improve greatly once you start pushing it around.
- ars 9y agoAnd in fact, the path of an unguided spaceship can not be predicted. Go look for old news stories of satellites crash landing - they can only give general areas, not exact. For example: http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2011/09/falling-satellite-dead-satellite-nasa.html http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2011/09/falling-s...
- mikeash 9y agoThat's a completely different scenario. Satellites in decaying orbits are descending due to atmospheric drag. Atmospheric drag is difficult to predict because it depends on the precise shape of the satellite, the precise orientation, and atmospheric conditions at each moment. If you're dropping an interplanetary asteroid on an enemy, it won't be in a slowly decaying orbit. It'll spend a few seconds within the atmosphere, which won't mess up predictions that much. It occurs to me that we just had a great example of the ability to predict where big rocks will be in space long in advance. People were able to predict that the Moon's shadow would cross from Oregon to South Carolina decades ago, and of course the predictions were spot on.
- ars 9y agoYou underestimate the difficulty. For example the asteroid could break up, which would move the trajectory. If the asteroid is not round it will tumble and shift. Uneven heating would cause a "jet" of hot air to act like a rocket and move the asteroid. Don't forget that it's very unlikely you will be able to guide an asteroid perpendicular to the earth (which would give you the most accuracy, and the most velocity, which also helps with accuracy). Most of the asteroids obit more or less in the same plane as the earth, so you will have to settle for a more shallow impact, which will magnify atmospheric effects. > example ... moon We have had thousands of years to precisely record the orbits of the moon and earth [sun]. That is the only reason we are able to predict it. And despite that, past a few hundred years accuracy goes down, and past 1 thousand or so it's mostly impossible to predict eclipses. And that's for bodies we have very accurate data on, and who have no atmospheric drag. The inaccuracy for eclipses is because we can't predict how fast the earth will turn (to an accuracy of a ppm) more than a few months out, and because of tidal effects changing the orbit of the moon.
- gshubert17 9y agoSmall asteroids have a very small escape velocity, on the order of a few meters per second. I think a mass driver which broke off small chunks of asteroid and hurled them to escape would not take too much power and be able to disassemble the asteroid in less than one orbit. (Advanced detection would be a plus here.) If we aimed the ejecta, to get a momentum change in a given direction, we would not have to completely disassemble the asteroid, because its orbit would change and eventually miss Earth. Complete disassembly would be safer, because small chunks would burn up in Earth's atmosphere.