4 ms·
> "I think Python is a stupid language and nobody should use it," And if you say "there can be downsides to using Python, here's an article describing them" an
by smsm42 9y ago
> "I think Python is a stupid language and nobody should use it,"
And if you say "there can be downsides to using Python, here's an article describing them" and the response is "you're fired, you infidel, how dare you to question The Sacredness!" then I probably don't want to work in that company.
- geofft 9y agoI agree, but I'm not sure how that's relevant.
- smsm42 9y agoThat's pretty much what happened to nodejs, as far as I can see - somebody said that CoC and speech codes may have downsides, people freaked out and demanded that either he's booted out or they leave.
- geofft 9y agoI am not a Node community member so my knowledge is limited, but that seems like an oversimplification for two reasons: one, he is on the team charged with upholding the CoC, and two, he apologized for the work his teammates did to uphold the CoC.
- smsm42 9y agoWhat is wrong with considering downsides of CoC while enforcing it? I'd say that exactly what person charged with enforcing it should be doing, and if they refuse to even admit the thought there might be any and haven't discussed them before, they may not be ready to enforce it properly. Reevaluating the premises and ensuring that upsides of the current rules exceed downsides, and challenging them if they do not, is the part of a healthy governance process, and flipping out at the mere thought of it is not a sign of a healthy one. Imagine a judge that is sure there's never downsides and unintended consequences of any law, and never admits a thought that the application of law can be unjust or hurt somebody. Wouldn't you be scared of such Judge Dredd?
- geofft 9y ago> What is wrong with considering downsides of CoC while enforcing it? I'd say that exactly what person charged with enforcing it should be doing, and if they refuse to even admit the thought there might be any and haven't discussed them before, they may not be ready to enforce it properly. Reevaluating the premises and ensuring that upsides of the current rules exceed downsides, and challenging them if they do not, is the part of a healthy governance process, and flipping out at the mere thought of it is not a sign of a healthy one. I agree. I think that's not what happened here: https://twitter.com/rvagg/status/887652116524707841 https://twitter.com/rvagg/status/887652116524707841 It's not an article about CoCs, and it repeats a claim that's been both debunked before and is pretty scientifically inaccurate about people with autism/Asperger's syndrome. This is more like a judge who tweets, "If you haven't thought about the problems with gold-fringed flags in courtrooms, here's a good place to start," and links to some freemen-on-the-land piece. We don't want that judge either. A judge who uncritically links to such an article isn't actually participating in serious discussion or challenges of the American legal system.
- smsm42 9y ago> It's not an article about CoCs It's not. But it contains thoughts relevant to the topic. Surprisingly, you are allowed to support your points with articles on common relevant topics, not just with ones that repeat your point verbatim. > it repeats a claim that's been both debunked before Irrelevant. The fact that somebody somewhere said "nah, it's not so" means nothing. For mostly everything you can find "debunking" if you look hard enough. That doesn't mean that automatically the side you're on wins because there are people on internet that agree with you (oh no, surely it does mean that?) > is pretty scientifically inaccurate about people with autism/Asperger's syndrome. I imagine you are speaking as a seasoned researcher on the topic, far outmatching the original author, a mere psychology professor. I respect your credentials on this, but regret to inform you this is also irrelevant - it is not a scientific paper, and neither original author not the tweet author was not asking for a scientific peer review. If anybody that ever recommended scientifically iffy article on twitter would be banned, we'd have nobody unbanned left. The fact is the attack had nothing to do with scientific merits of the article (which nobody even discussed) and everything to do with the outrageous crime of sacrilege by questioning the sanctity of the CoC.