7 ms·
Is the Stuff You Buy Over 20 Years Worth 40,000 Hours of Time?
- 0xf8 9y ago[vipassana] = [answer]
- etplayer 9y agoI agree in part. Meditating (using vipassana) has helped me examine assumptions I made about my life, what it is, and what value it has, and the impermanence of our posessions and indeed our own bodies. I'd recommend it, even to the skepetical reader.
- jimrandomh 9y agoThe usual way of thinking about this (if you think about it at all) is to think on the margin: was the marginal hour worth the marginal purchase? That is, if you cut the hours you'd most like to cut, and cut purchases until the budget balances again, is that better? If you compare all of the work to all of the stuff, then there's no way to notice (within that framework) if the best answer was to work part-time, or slightly less overtime, or slightly more overtime.
- cfmcdonald 9y agoThat assumes that one can arbitrarily exchange free hours and money. Most workers do not have that choice.
- x1798DE 9y agoI'm not sure it does make that assumption - if you could arbitrarily exchange hours for money, then you could calculate out how man fewer hours to work and do that, but otherwise you just have a benefit function with discontinuities in it (e.g. you lose your job if you try to work 35 hours per week, incurring large job switching costs), but I'm fairly certain you can still work out in the abstract which side of the discontinuity you're better off on.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoAssuming that you retire, you most definitely can. Each dollar you don't spend today can be saved for retirement, at which point the invested dollar can be "spent" by retiring marginally earlier.
- ikeyany 9y ago> Assuming that you retire Thus proving most workers (as in >90%) do not have that choice.
- etplayer 9y agoI think it's rather funny that the economic theory of marginalism has even managed to invade our thought processes to make such calculations "usual". I wonder if anyone still thinks in terms of labour hours and use value versus exchange value.
- drtillberg 9y agoBecause it is not possible to conserve life, I think the equation is more accurately: [Life] = ( [Stuff] || [NoStuff] ) That is because sometimes NoStuff is what we use life to enjoy.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoI think so. The term 'Stuff' is super complicated. I buy stuff as life enhancers. It keeps my mind stimulated or body healthy when I get a new macbook or a mountain bike. I also try to buy durable stuff BIFL type stuff. So that the value is massive, and will possibly be passed on after I'm dead. I think it's less about the abstract term 'stuff' and more about the idea of 'value' that 40000 hours of your life provides to yourself and your family/friends. The goal of just accumulating 'stuff' is consumerism...the goal of accumulating 'value' in your life if a better pursuit imo.
- TKDPenguin4390 9y agoPersonally, I like to use this as a way to prevent myself from impulse buys. For Example (Easy numbers used for math): Stupid Random Thing I want to Impulse Buy is $400.00 At $10/hour, this object costs me 40 hours. Is it worth a week's work to have Random Thing I want to Impulse buy? If 40 hours of work = Object's value to me, then buy Else, pass- and save money for future endeavor
- xupybd 9y agoI do something similar. But I like to factor in my overheads. 40 hours work may pay for that thing. But to work 40 hours I also need to live for a week. So that's a week's rent, food, power and so on. So that thing is probably going to cost me a week and a half of my working life.
- bgirard 9y agoIdeally you should be budgeting for discretionary monthly spending. If I want to buy a Nintendo Switch then it might be, say, a full month of discretionary spending.
- icanhackit 9y agoThere are some simple rules my partner and I live by: buy implements/tools that make life easier/save time/produce good results, avoid items used only or largely for signalling or which lack utility, buy quality so that the item will last as long as possible and will be a pleasure to use. I'd say the easiest hack would be: stop signalling. You're not your fucking Babushka dolls or Banksy print. You're not the coffee style you drink or the coffee shop you drink it in. No one gets you by seeing what clothing you're wearing, and anyone who is attracted to you because of those things will be toxic company.
- taurath 9y agoThis works as long as you don't wish to attract people, or have such a strong personality that it signals more than anything else. Yes, being in a particular place is a signal. But if you wear a Tommy Bahama shirt and khakis to a BDSM party you are probably not going to get attention. Home decor is another point - if you want it to be a comfortable home and nothing else, great! Do whatever you like. But if you want the space to act as an occasional community center for you and your social group, signals help. There aren't many fancy 50 year old wine parties in basement apartments.
- libertine 9y agoSignalling is part of who we are, it's a trait of our species - long before LV and Cartier, there was feathers, bones, fur. Things that would define positions in society, wealth, or simply to please others. We are social beings, and we have a lot of unconscious decisions made via interpretation of such signs. You can't just say someone who noticed you because you had some cool Vans shoes, is toxic because that someone used his senses and made a judgment - that maybe you are a cool approachable dude. No one likes you because of what you buy - that's not how it works.
- icanhackit 9y ago> No one likes you because of what you buy - that's not how it works. Some people really are that vapid. Anecdotes aren't worth much in this space but a lot of people I know are recreational shoppers and the extent of their conversational capacity is places they've dined at, things they have and shit they like. Now, maybe most people don't mind that sort of person. I don't think it would be uncharitable to call me a misanthropic arsehole. But I enjoy people who can think creatively, have even just an interest - not necessarily foundational knowledge - in science, history, politics, economics, engineering, and technology. To know whether someone is interested in these things does require some knowledge signalling - but that's not what we're talking about here. We're talking about stuff you buy, and I was suggesting that anything used almost exclusively for signalling which lacks utility should be toned down if you don't want to be a slave to your possessions. Someone interested in astronomy might have a reflector telescope in their living room - it has utility and indirectly signals what they like, which is fine. Someone who likes eating but has never cooked a meal in their life and surrounds themselves with celebrity cookware and stylised kitchen appliances should consider just saving money for eating out - the return on investment will be greater.
- fwn 9y agoThe authors definition of stuff is very different from the common definition of stuff (as he includes experiences as stuff as well). I don't see how such a term can be used consistently in a meaningful way as entities like an actual physical thing and the memory of an encounter are vastly different things on a conceptual level.
- dorkwood 9y agoIf I was only working to accumulate 'stuff', then I wouldn't work at all. Or at least I wouldn't work as many hours as I do. The sad fact is that if I stop working, I can only survive for maybe six months until I need to start working again. I don't like having to give half of my life over to someone else, but I haven't happened upon a better alternative yet.
- gdulli 9y agoHappiness is neither the presence of material things nor the absence of work.
- JoeDaDude 9y agoIt's been said already but deserves repeating: "Most people buy things they don't need with money they don't have to impress people they don't know".
- phaed 9y agoDepends. In many cases Stuff(life) > life. Having access to a toothbrush and toothpaste throughout my life enhances the quality of the life lived. A car saves tons of hours of life that I would otherwise have spent it walking from place to place, giving me extra time. A phone allows me to communicate with loved ones far away that I would never see otherwise. Books give knowledge and perspective that allow me to overcome many obstacles in life. etc. A lot of it is worth it. Some of it is not. Time is not the only thing of import in this life, just ask any prisoner living a life sentence if he thinks he's lucky for having all that extra time.