3 ms·
> Firefox should make this feature opt-in only. I agree, but note that they are explicitly trying to get more info than they can from the small, biased sample
by yjftsjthsd-h 9y ago
> Firefox should make this feature opt-in only.
I agree, but note that they are explicitly trying to get more info than they can from the small, biased sample that is users opting in.
- wila 9y agoThen they should fix that by asking in the GUI politely if you are willing to share and also explain how-to disable it easily. Just starting to collect your browsing data is a bad idea (tm) especially if your main claim is "more privacy".
- kogepathic 9y ago> they are explicitly trying to get more info than they can from the small, biased sample that is users opting in. Maybe because most people using Firefox use it precisely because they don't want the browser vendor to track their behaviour? I wonder how the Torbrowser folks will deal with this.
- Fuxy 9y agoThey claim is biased but is it really biased? How do they know? I think this is just making up excuses so they can collect more data. They get good enough data from the people that have volunteered it. I don't know what makes them think it's biased but I seriously doubt that is true.
- Operyl 9y agoBecause, usually the kind of people that’d opt in are techies/power users or work (volunteer, or paid) for Mozilla themselves. Let’s say only 1% of your userbase opts in to this, how is that not biased? (As it currently stands, I believe this is a further optin in a tucked away menu).
- yorwba 9y agoThen they should make the possibility to opt-in more prominent, instead of switching to opt-out with the option tucked away in some menu where only techies/power users will disable it.
- pishpash 9y agoThe Mozilla user base is already biased. Plus they can run experimental test fixtures to canvas sites. This sounds like a solution looking for a problem.
- gcp 9y ago>They claim is biased but is it really biased? How do they know? I think this is just making up excuses so they can collect more data. Informed, constructive opinion there. One clear sign of the bias is that the crash rate of the browser goes up massively every time a new version transforms from beta to release. Clearly, it's not renaming that string that makes the browser crash. The populations are just fundamentally different. To give an obvious example, beta users are overwhelmingly more like to have up to date video drivers. (Which can be seen in crash reports, but is also very logical).