3 ms·
It's a thought experiment using an ahistoric Newton as a straw man to fit the argument. An argument by an author who likes to make lists of famous people who a
by eesmith 9y ago
It's a thought experiment using an ahistoric Newton as a straw man to fit the argument.
An argument by an author who likes to make lists of famous people who are conjectured to have Aspergers ... I write "conjectured" because most of those assignments seem more based in hope than any historical reality, as pointed out in the comments to the essay.
Thought experiment: university speech codes allow other types of geniuses. Modern science is highly collaborative, and misanthropic lone geniuses like Newton will do little to advance most fields, but much to retard them by creating an environment which rejects geniuses that don't wish to be in a misanthropic environment.
See, BS handwaving is easy!
- eesmith 9y agoTo follow up, Newton can be characterized various ways, including "English academic around 1600", "possible Asbergers", and "possible asexual". The argument is something like "Newton was neurologically atypical and the Newton of the 1600s couldn't manage the speech codes at modern Harvard therefore the speech codes at modern Harvard discriminate against the neurologically atypical." However, replace "neurologically atypical" with "English academic around 1700s", which could include Hooke, Boyle, Halley, and many others. Would they be able to be at a modern Harvard? I suspect not all of them would. On the other hand, the author lists many scientists "who seem, given biographical records, to have been on the autism/Asperger’s spectrum." Two are Barbara McClintock and Alan Turing. I selected them because I have read biographies about their lives. Would they be able to be at a modern Harvard? Almost certainly. So it's not obvious that rejecting Newton implies rejecting all those who are on the autism/Asperger’s spectrum.