13 ms·
The Neurodiversity Case for Free Speech
- rbanffy 9y agoThey lost me when they used the word "Inquisition". We have a need of unbiased discussion. This is not it.
- golemotron 9y ago> They lost me when they used the word "Inquisition". The article has a single author. His name is Geoffrey Miller.
- rbanffy 9y agoThe article was written, edited, reviewed and approved for publication by, hopefully, different people. Even if it has a single author, it's the result of a cooperative effort.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- golemotron 9y agoThat isn't quite how English works.
- rbanffy 9y agoWhat is actually your point? Does it significantly detract from my conclusion this is not an unbiased discussion?
- golemotron 9y agoI didn't quite get your point. It was an article, not a discussion. Seeing bias (which is also called 'point of view') is fine. It does not invalid the article. You get to add to it - you get to discuss. Why didn't you?
- notahacker 9y agoA quick Google suggests the author was subject to a bit of adverse publicity for tweeting "Dear obese PhD applicants: if you didn't have the willpower to stop eating carbs, you won't have the willpower to do a dissertation #truth" and continues to publish and teach at the same institution after making his excuses and apologies and getting a formal warning. It's a sad irony indeed if it's people frowning on that comment that's lead him to lecture everyone else on [censorious academic culture] arbitrarily deterring marginalised people from study.
- aussieguy1234 9y agoThe Author is Autistic. It's likely he didn't realise what we was saying was offensive until after the fact.
- Asdfbla 9y agoAnd is it a bad thing to let him know it is offensive? If he can't comprehend it naturally, maybe he can at least learn. I guess you could make a case that people who are diagnosed to lie on the autistic spectrum should get a bit more leeway from the administration with regard to disciplinary action (because it's not really their fault), but what else are you gonna do? Give them a free pass? I don't think that even has much to do with the feared political correctness anymore.
- aussieguy1234 9y agoNo, but do we let him know by educating him, or should his "lesson" be getting fired from the University or facing disciplinary action that is likely to worsen his condition? Hopefully he will take legal action against the universities policies if it's the latter on the grounds of unfair disability discrimination.
- Asdfbla 9y agoSeems hard to judge which of his statements are caused by his condition and which by him just being a vocal and opinionated person in general - but I guess that's a point in his favor because if that distinction is hard to make, it's probably better to err on the side of free speech instead of trying to figure out what's typical and what's atypical behavior which gets a free pass.
- eesmith 9y agoPure BS. Newton wouldn't be able to publish through a modern Harvard because nothing would be new. Recall too that the publication of Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica was completely funded by a private party, Halley. "Sooner or later, he would say ‘offensive’ things that get reported to Harvard and that get picked up by mainstream media as moral-outrage clickbait." Again, BS. Newton was an anti-trinitarian. He believed that worshiping Christ as God was idolatry. And he was a fellow at Trinity College. Had he mentioned this, he would have lost his job, at the very least. (It would have been a powerful weapon for the Leibniz side during the so-called calculus wars.) He even managed to get the job requirements for his position changed so he wouldn't have to lie about his beliefs. Instead, he kept his heretical ideas secret that it wasn't until long after he died that others had an clue about them. In other words, "picked up by mainstream media as moral-outrage clickbait". He was used to it then, and he would be used to it now.
- ggreer 9y ago> Pure BS. Newton wouldn't be able to publish through a modern Harvard because nothing would be new. It's a thought experiment. Hypothetical modern-day Newton would have some hypothetical novel discovery. > Instead, he kept his heretical ideas secret that it wasn't until long after he died that others had an clue about them. It's true that Newton kept some of his religious views secret, but he made other controversial views known and was widely regarded as a misanthrope. Had modern university speech codes existed back then, Newton would have likely been fired over some controversy. As a result, science would have advanced more slowly. That's the article's core argument: University speech codes filter out many eccentric geniuses, reducing the quality of ideas and slowing scientific progress. It's something I hadn't considered before, and I'm hard-pressed to find a good counterargument. It's definitely not dismissible as, "Pure BS."
- matt4077 9y agoDo you really belief a 17th century university didn't have "speech codes"? Just as a hint: to become a professor at the time, you had to be an ordained priest. Edit: From Wikipedia: "In April 1667, he returned to Cambridge and in October was elected as a fellow of Trinity. Fellows were required to become ordained priests, although this was not enforced in the restoration years and an assertion of conformity to the Church of England was sufficient. However, by 1675 the issue could not be avoided and by then his unconventional views stood in the way.[20] Nevertheless, Newton managed to avoid it by means of a special permission from Charles II"
- azangru 9y ago> Newton also wants to publish Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica, to explain the laws of motion governing the universe. But his literary agent explains that he can’t get a decent book deal until Newton builds his ‘author platform’ to include at least 20k Twitter followers Is this really a thing? Can authors nowadays be required to have a strong social media presence?
- matt4077 9y agoIf you're a Harvard professor, you'll find someone to print your book. No worries. For others, it could obviously be something that makes it easier to find a publisher. Not because it somehow proves your PC-credentials, but simply because it's sort-of proof that you have an audience.
- pjc50 9y agoHarvard has its own press for this sort of thing. They produce all sorts of books with tiny print runs.
- chippy 9y agoI think the main thing is "a decent book deal". Most authors do not have these. Most academic books are not read outside of academia. Even a book that gets published and does well within academia (gets on many courses reading lists) will not give the author an income. A decent book deal is the very rare book that is both used in the academy and which goes mainstream - something like A Selfish Gene, or a Carl Sagan.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoI'd say that nowadays, anyone can be an author - which is the problem. Without marketing or going viral, whatever shit one writes will go nowhere. It's not enough to write something good, it needs traction. Which also means why bad writing also becomes popular - more marketing / traction.
- wvh 9y agoThe trend of outrage posses armed with pitchforks and torches in politics, gender debates and whatnot is particularly worrying for those of us that need some slack and don't deserve to be crucified by an angry mob because we used the wrong word or said the "wrong", e.g. politically incorrect thing; even as most of that crowd of the offended know very well no actual harm was intended, they still choose to dramatise the situation for their own political or psychological needs. This is why I defend freedom of speech and freedom to offend, because I know that I am somewhat on that autistic spectrum and can say things that might offend some people, and that even though those people know deep down inside there was no the intention to hurt or say bad things, they still want to make a point out of it. Having a strong feeling about something doesn't make you right. Emotional drama can make you an asshole, too. I can pretend this is merely about ideological matters, but in all honesty, my stance likely finds its true origin in my own neurological "layout" and life experiences – as probably counts for anyone who has a strong opinion about something. People who are somewhat on the autistic spectrum tend to have an affinity for rationality and some difficulties with emotions and "group-feel", and it's sad that this irrational polarising climate isolates them more and makes them avoid others as much as possible. We really need to get away from this mindset of: the other side is wrong and they are nazis and hence deserve bad things happening to them and we will get you fired and come and rape you and an angry soapbox SJW will piss in your shoe. It's the 21st century, get your shit together, no matter what side you are on or what crazy thing you believe in.
- digi_owl 9y agoI can't shake the suspicion that these things are manufactured in some way. A kind of "color revolution", or an advanced form of "think of the children".
- eesmith 9y agoYou have overgeneralized the description so it's meaningless. Those with coprolalia also say 'the wrong word or [say] the "wrong", e.g. politically incorrect thing; even as most of that crowd of the offended know very well no actual harm was intended', yet they do not receive the "pitchforks and torches" treatment, to repeat the phrase that you have to "dramatise the situation for [your] own political or psychological [need]." You are, of course, talking about metaphorical torches. Those marching with real torches recently had very different views. I defend the freedom of association, which is a necessary balance to the freedom of speech. Without both, there is no liberty.
- matt4077 9y agoIt's funny how you're arguing a case where an angry mob "crucifies" the poor sap who accidentally used a wrong word, when the actual event that kicked off this debate was an actual angry mob, with real torches, honest swastikas, and loaded semi-automatic weapons who not-so-metaphorically ran over a completely non-threatening young woman. The people marching and screaming "Jews will not replace us" also don't strike me as the autistic type abhorring "group-think", considering their enjoyment of shouting hateful slogans in unisono. And lets not get into your contention that these peoples' only fault is somehow being "too rational". Just take a look at any photos from that rally and decide for yourself if they seem to be the sort of people who got an extra helping of rationality. Hint: some of them have face tattoos.
- lhnz 9y agoThis was posted on the 18th of July. The Charlottesville rally is not relevant.
- matt4077 9y agoEdit (previous, sarcastic comment below): I belief it is disingenuous to try to discuss such issues without addressing the elephant in the room. I also felt the imagery (angry mob/pitchforks/etc) more than subtly pointed in that direction. In addition, I feel there are two mechanisms in play here that undermine an honest debate: First, there's a glut of people insisting they're only defending "free speech" and not supporting people such as those at that rally. It reminds me of the "movement for ethics in game journalism" that had nothing to do with misogyny, no sir. Secondly, the debate is moved to some other subject where people will agree with the idea that it would be absurd to, for example, censor something like the Principia Mathematica. That agreement will then, in turn be used to defend things that are definitely not scientific masterpieces. The underlying idea is, once again, the slippery slope, or some sort of inability to differentiate things that are obviously different. (Previous reply mocking the objection regarding the timeline: "At the moment I posted, my post did not yet exist, nor did your objection to it. Therefore, I will refuse to take it into consideration.")
- 9y ago
- matt4077 9y agoThis article already fails with it little thought experiment. Because if there's one thing we can probably agree on it's that freedom of speech today is larger than it was in 17th century England. Since he was able to publish back then, he would be able to publish today. Other than that, this is just the slippery slope again, although I appreciate that they throw in Newton–considering he's arguably the inventor of the slippery slope.
- chippy 9y agoThe Newton example is not about free speech but rather his behaviour, actions, and perceptions of non academics. The example given implies that he would be able to publish, but he wouldn't be able to get a decent (i.e. well promoted, popular) book deal. The example of Newton at the beginning of the article is a little thought experiment where we consider how having odd or off coloured views, or behaving strangely is treated differently by the outside of the academy. Such a thought experiment leads me to think that in the 17th Century it was easier to be a genius, odd, socially awkward mad professor than it is now. I don't know what it was actually like back then, but I do know that today the academy is in the spotlight more than it was when I was in it.
- Keysh 9y agoBut it's a really bad example. In real history, Newton was able to keep quiet about views that would have gotten him fired and possibly imprisoned. Most of the "weird" Newtonian stuff the author is referring to are things Newton kept private, not stuff he published; we only know about them because of work done by historians in the 20th Century. In particular, we know from Newton's private writings that he had strong Unitarian tendencies (that is, he doubted the validity of the Trinity). Had he made those views public, he would certainly have been fired and possibly suffered worse. (By the late 17th Century, it was illegal for Oxford or Cambridge to hire or even teach people who weren't proper Anglicans; denying the Trinity would have put Newton into this category.)
- notahacker 9y agoIt's also a bad example because "Greek alchemy, Biblical cryptography, fiat currency, Jewish mysticism, or how to predict the exact date of the Apocalypse" are not the sort of thing which are censored by even the most ardent proponents of political correctness today. They might expose him to ridicule, but that's actually an integral part of free speech, as well as being far less onerous than the explicit bans on the religiously unorthodox having any involvement in academia in Newton's time
- stared 9y agoThere is one more hidden bias, which (IMHO) have much stronger impact for aspies - application forms and grant proposals. Even though officially it's all about merits of accomplishments and ideas, almost always there is an expectation to deliver it in a form of "sales pitch". So, any honest and straightforward presentation is unlikely to stand a chance with one full of "soft bullshit" (e.g. promises to cure cancer, create universal quantum computer, etc).
- mickronome 9y agoNot only that, as you undoubtedly know, but the implicit social expectations and judgments are strongly present even in supposedly objective areas such as courts of law. I don't remember all the specifics and I've lost most of the references since then, but I've read some research on this, and regardless if you are a victim or accused for a crime, if you have ASD you are at a massive disadvantage. One example: Research appear to show that while people with ASD commit violent crimes at about the same rate as the general population, they are incarcerated at a much higher rate. I've seen numbers between 2 to 4 times the incarnation rate.
- Asdfbla 9y agoIs the hypothesis that seems important for the article - that civilization was mostly advanced by lone neurodiverse geniuses - actually true? Sounds dubious, but who knows. At least modern science seems to be a very collaborative affair. Was there ever a poll or study to find out if university faculty as a whole actually is scared to offend people or threatened by some hypothetical PC police? I would imagine that the debate is only relevant for the social sciences anyway, since you shouldn't have opportunities to offend people in more technical subjects anyway.
- stared 9y agoCivilization is advanced by a collaboration of many, many people. Yet, often some novel ideas come from people who not only have them, but also - are not afraid to talk against mainstream assumptions. I go into this topic in http://crastina.se/theres-no-projects-like-side-projects/ http://crastina.se/theres-no-projects-like-side-projects/ (with examples of: Albert Einstein, John Bell, John Carmack).
- sideshowb 9y agoSome of the drier subjects in my CS degree were considerably enhanced by quirky lecturers at least trying to make a joke here and there. Did you read the bit in the article about teaching feedback? To be clear I am not arguing for the right to make racist, sexist jokes etc in a place of work. I am pointing out that if I was in the neuro-diverse lecturer's shoes, fear of offending somebody I don't know for reasons I don't understand would probably dampen my teaching style.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoNo, but it mainly points out that some of the people which are globally seen as geniuses that advanced the world, with names that are written down in the history books - Newton, Einstein, Jobs - all had neurodivergent disorders. It indicates that those people wouldn't have fit in in modern universities, but I don't know enough about those people, whether they were politically incorrect or whatever. I know Jobs was a dick (based on reading a biography), but again, not sure if that would've been different if he lived in the age of college speech rules or code of conducts - I think he wouldn't have given a fuck and would've done his things regardless. The article mentions Newton too, who, or so I read recently, published some pretty blasphemous stuff - e.g. agreeing with the Copernican view of the universe - but managed to add some nuance and such at the end of his treatsie, making sure to point out that God works in mysterious ways and such.
- roceasta 9y agoThank goodness we are still able to make the case. The only alternative to free speech is violence. I want to be able to hear what the alt-right has to say, what Islamic extremists have to say, what misogynists have to say, etc.
- sideshowb 9y agoHoping that's not a sarcastic comment (it's hard to tell online). I want to be able to hear what all those people have to say, so I can try to persuade them that they're wrong.
- Ygg2 9y ago> so I can try to persuade them that they're wrong. I think this is really difficult, but a worthwhile goal. In all honesty my goal would be to understand where they are coming from and help turn them or future generations from such course.
- roceasta 9y agoNot sarcastic. Yes, persuade people they are wrong where they are wrong; learn from them where they are right (we are all fallible). Persuade other people that they are wrong; teach other people where they are right. Plus an unlimited number of other possible responses. >I can try to persuade them that they're wrong That assumes you know what their ideas are. If present trends against free speech continue, it's not a luxury you're necessarily going to have.
- sideshowb 9y agoYes, learn from people where they are right as well - +1 to that. It might be that they're none of the horrible things people claim and are just victims of unfortunate name calling or mud slinging.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThe problem with the parties mentioned in the grandparent comment (nazis, alt-right, islamic extremism, and on the (claimed) other side of the spectrum, antifa, SJW's, environmental extremists, etc) is that their claims are often backed by emotions (we hate $demographic), but said claims also incite a strong emotional response (often from one's morals - e.g. you should not be racist). Emotional responses is not logical discourse. Also, morals, norms and values are very hard to change. I mean most people - including you I believe? have a moral saying "Murder is wrong". I don't know how to convince you to change that moral. But, when it comes to issues inciting a strong emotional response, that becomes easier. "It's wrong to punch people in the face" becomes a much more flexible norm when said person is a nazi. "Murder and the death penalty are wrong" is a norm that becomes looser when it concerns someone that raped your child. TL;DR, persuading someone off their values and moral codes is not trivial. Those are things that take a long time, gradual and long-term campaigning, subtle cues of acceptance. They do work, mind you; 70 years ago, homosexuality was a crime and the punishment was castration (Turing), nowadays it's much more accepted and gradually becoming normal.
- rbanffy 9y agoIt's fascinating to see an article about neurodiversity and freedom of speech with the comments section closed.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoJust because of all that doesn't mean it's not controversial - that's kind of what the article is trying to point out. I wanted to share it with e.g. colleagues as a thoughtpiece, but decided not to because of what it might say about me.
- rbanffy 9y agoStill, I'd imagine someone who publishes an article defending the extremes of freedom of speech would not have the comments section closed.
- dfboyd 9y agoThe article is unreadable on Chrome on Android; after load is complete, the related-articles div fights with a pop-in div for control, both of them rendering repeatedly on top of each other and continually yanking the scroll to the bottom of the page.