5 ms·
Please, HTC, no more ad-libbing your own user interfaces They suck and are hard to remove. We all call it nonSense for a reason. Stick to making hardware, and
by jrockway 16y ago
Please, HTC, no more ad-libbing your own user interfaces They suck and are hard to remove. We all call it nonSense for a reason. Stick to making hardware, and let Google handle the software. It's cheaper and your users will be happier. (Just once I would like to buy a phone that I don't have to reflash as soon as I bring it home. Should have gotten an N1, I guess.)
Hardware-wise, this concept is not too compelling. Needs physical buttons. Needs the trackball. I don't want to pay for stereo sound or the ability to turn into an alarm clock. Give me battery life and a higher-res screen instead. I don't want gimmicks, I want a solid phone that always works and doesn't get in my way.
I agree that they should make their "premium" phones out of metal, though. I think Apple is leading the way here (with a metal case and a very high-res screen), and that HTC is just going to copy. But that's fine, an Android-based iPhone 4 clone with WiMax will be phenomenal.
- rbranson 16y agoHTC had high-res screens WAY before Apple did. The Touch Diamond had a 286PPI screen in June 2008, which is a month before the 3G came out, with it's meager 163PPI screen. The Touch Diamond, Touch Pro, Touch HD, Touch Diamond2, Touch Pro2, HD2, Evo, Desire, Droid Incredible, and Nexus One ALL had >200PPI screens before the iPhone 4 was even announced.
- DougBTX 16y agoMeh, the "cool" point is >300PPI.
- masklinn 16y ago> Needs physical buttons. Needs the trackball. No. Really, no.
- commandar 16y agoPhysical button = tactile feedback. I was wholely unimpressed by the soft buttons on the Nexus One and Moto Droid. As for the trackball? Still the best precision text selection device I've used on a mobile.
- norova 16y agoWhen it comes to text selection, how often do people use it? I ask that in sincere curiosity. I know personally that I only select text once, maybe twice a week on my Palm Pre. Holding shift and dragging through the text works great for me. Perhaps you meant in terms of positioning the cursor? Anywho... Tactile feedback from keyboards/button has always been an issue with me, but I find that a slight vibration from the phone when a softkey is pressed does the job just fine.
- masklinn 16y ago> When it comes to text selection, how often do people use it? I ask that in sincere curiosity. I do that pretty regularly to quote in mails and forums on my iOS device. But I think the issue isn't about how often it's used, but how seamless it is. If you can do it without thinking about it, it's good. If you have to stop when you need to select text, it's not.
- acgourley 16y agoI like the incredible buttons. Flush, but the phone vibrates a bit when you hit them.
- apgwoz 16y agoOne problem is that they all vibrate in the same way. If they had a bit different vibration patterns, you could simulate the type of feel you get with actual push buttons (e.g. you might feel that there's a right edge on the right button)
- masklinn 16y ago> Still the best precision text selection device I've used on a mobile. I've had no problem with the iOS method so far, and haven't been longing for the return of the trackball at all.
- jamesbritt 16y agoThis is why I cannot use my G1 as a music player in the car. I cannot manipulate it without looking at it, which I really do not want to do while driving. My Sansa E500 thing is easy to manage by touch only (except if I want to see the name of the song playing); my eyes don't leave the road if I want to skip or repeat or pause a song. Likewise, if I need to make or take a call while driving, and pulling over isn't an option, I want to be able to do a much as I can by touch, and not worry that a misplaced tap or glide on smooth glass has triggered some unwanted behavior.
- nailer 16y ago> Please, HTC, no more ad-libbing your own user interfaces They suck and are hard to remove. We all call it nonSense for a reason. No, people on XDA developers (phone nerds) use the tern 'NonSense'. HTC sticks to common UI principles, ie: * Identifiable icons (eg, using a globe, rather than a blue and white sphere, for a web browser) * Known color schemes, eg, black, green, and white, versus Googles white, blue, orange and green. * A home screen which can host animations. Google's can't, which is why the widget selection is poor and those that exist don't do as much. * Always visible phone function, something Google themselves did in 2.2 * Widgets that don't waste space, compared to the default 2 x 4 widgets for Twitter and Facebook with the massive stip between. I could go on. HTC have UI designers. Android clearly don't - it's not a matter of personal preference, it's a matter of basic design principles. Edit: Fixed 'Apple' rather than 'Android'.
- masklinn 16y ago> HTC have UI designers. Apple clearly don't Wait, what?
- cgomez 16y agoPretty sure he meant Google, which wouldn't be true either...
- nailer 16y agoWell per the post, there's more evidence of Google either not adopting or ignoring well known UI design principles throughout Android, in terms of making common functions widely available, consistency in UI, not using a color scheme with two colors directly sitting across from each other on the wheel.
- joubert 16y agoThey famously eschew design ideas from design "dictators", favoring data-driven design (e.g. choosing a blue that yields more ad clicks); I wonder if they do this in the Android development cycle or once it is in users' hands.
- tkahn6 16y agoWell as a counterpoint, my father returned his Droid for a Droid Eris because he liked the Sense interface much more than the stock Android one.
- dagw 16y agoBy "we all" you mean a tiny number of hard core nerds who hang out on obscure forums. I know several people who own HTC android phones, and not one of them has re-flashed their phones or expressed any desire for removing Sense.
- jrockway 16y agoDo any of them know there is any other way? Ignorance is bliss.
- borism 16y agoIf it wasn't for HTC's horrendously slow release cycle (not as bad as Sony Ericsson's though) I wouldn't care if it's nonSense or not.
- brk 16y agoI've had an HTC Incredible for a couple of weeks now. The Sense UI has felt better-implemented than the Moto Droid UI, to me at least. I've also had (and still have) an iPhone 3G/S for a couple of years. While I still think the iPhone is overall a better UI and better app store, the HTC phone is the first Droid-based phone I've owned or played with that didn't come across like an unfinished experiment in cellphone design. I'm vaguely aware there are other options to the Sense UI, but I do not dislike it enough overall to warrant an investigation into any of the other options.
- ergo98 16y ago>Please, HTC, no more ad-libbing your own user interfaces They suck and are hard to remove. We all call it nonSense for a reason. SenseUI is an excellent interface. I say this as a fairly hardcore user. It's a bit of a UI stepback using my N1 instead of my Magic+. I'm a fairly hardcore user so I like it vanilla for other reasons, but I guarantee that doesn't matter at all for about 95% of consumers. > I think Apple is leading the way here (with a metal case and a very high-res screen), and that HTC is just going to copy. HTC Legend was out before the iPhone, largely composed of a single piece of aluminum. HTC has absolutely kicked Apple around when it comes to screen resolution. So how, exactly, is HTC copying Apple? Quite the opposite.