4 ms·
There's a chance (like there is with every technology that isn't actively developed for a long time) that just when you think coal's dying someone's gonna come
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
There's a chance (like there is with every technology that isn't actively developed for a long time) that just when you think coal's dying someone's gonna come along and figure out how to apply an innovation from some other field that makes it so much cheaper/cleaner/whatever that it sticks around for a long time.
- epistasis 9y agoThere's a chance of that, but up until now all such attempts have been stupendous failures. The Kemper plant in the article was a $7.5B failure. Much more likely is an innovation in the battery sector. Utilities are finally waking up to the huge value proposition of batteries on the grid. They can be used instead of upgrading transmission and distribution infrastructure. They can be somewhat easily relocated to new sites if projections of electricity demand were wrong. There are a ton of flow technologies that are on the cusp of being really useful. Lithium ion tailored for the grid is already the cost winner for several applications. I do hope that we come up with some carbon sequestration innovations, but I doubt that they'll be tied to coal in any way. Possible, but extremely unlikely. If there was any horse to back in the race, there's more than enough money for horse to get out of the gate. There are a lot of people with assets that are close to getting stranded.
- hwillis 9y ago>Much more likely is an innovation in the battery sector. Utilities are finally waking up to the huge value proposition of batteries on the grid. They can be used instead of upgrading transmission and distribution infrastructure. Back of the envelope math: the electric grid would cost ~5 trillion to replace[1]. At $200/kWh that's 25,000,000,000 kWh. The US uses 11,152,000,000 kWh per day- that's 2.24 days of storage. Doubling the effective power of the grid using a day's worth of storage is trivial AND cost effective (at $200/kWh). Add in renewables and that storage gets several times more valuable, too. [1]: http://www.businessinsider.com/replacing-us-electrical-grid-cost-2017-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/replacing-us-electrical-grid-...
- epistasis 9y agoThe flip side of storage directly connected to the grid is demand response: consuming electricity at times lower than peak. This serves nearly an identical function to storage that's permanently fixed to the grid, as long as it's truly dispatchable. The numbers you posted there are remarkably similar in the amount of storage in passenger cars as we shift to an EV fleet. 260 million vehicles in the US with 50 kWh batteries on average is 13,150,000,000 kWh. With smart charging at the cheap times, passenger vehicles can serve as fantastic time-shifters as demand increases on the grid. Just some of those pesky logistics and coordination tasks to solve...
- hwillis 9y agoThe average residential consumer uses 29.6 kWh per day so 2.24 days of storage is 66.3 kWh- pretty close to 50 kWh! Also worth noting that the average daily power consumption for electric cars would only be ~8.5 kWh per person. >With smart charging at the cheap times, passenger vehicles can serve as fantastic time-shifters as demand increases on the grid. Just some of those pesky logistics and coordination tasks to solve... Yeah... and being actively fought against, annoyingly. Variable rates aren't even available to most people.
- greglindahl 9y agoThere's plenty of time for that to change -- there aren't that many electric cars yet.
- hwillis 9y agoYou're talking about variable rates? Hawaii is a good example of what the future might look like, unfortunately. The power companies there are fighting very hard against variable rates because it would make solar way, way more feasible. It's kind of an extreme example because solar power could virtually eliminate Hawaiian power companies at a very substantial cost savings and a very short timescale, but the same principal elements are present everywhere in the mainland US too. Australia has a lot of variable rates though, so that's nice for them.
- georgecmu 9y agoIn 2008 DARPA kickstarted a major research effort into cleaner, cheaper ways to make transportation fuels from coal[1]. There was at least one transformational technology opening up large chemical and materials markets that came out of that effort.[2] [1] https://www.wired.com/2008/09/darpas-coal-to/ https://www.wired.com/2008/09/darpas-coal-to/ [2] https://www.usea.org/event/coals-bright-future-unlocking-new-markets-novel-technologies https://www.usea.org/event/coals-bright-future-unlocking-new...