3 ms·
I understand calling someone an engineer is critical to your marketing, but they aren't engineers. Teaching someone a framework isn't teaching them any form of
by bdcravens 9y ago
I understand calling someone an engineer is critical to your marketing, but they aren't engineers. Teaching someone a framework isn't teaching them any form of engineering. It's teaching them to be an employable technician. Engineering is teaching from first principles.
A good rule of thumb: can they do their job if Stackoverflow.com is blocked at the corporate firewall?
- Raphmedia 9y agoIn Canada it is illegal to practice engineering, or use the title "professional engineer" or "engineer", without a license. For example, after complaints were lodged by the Canadian Council of Professional Engineers, a court in Quebec fined Microsoft Canada $1,000 for misusing the "engineer" title by referring to MCSE graduates as engineers.
- majormjr 9y agoThe 'Professional Engineer' title is regulated but there is some doubt with the plain 'Engineer' title. It also varies depending on each province Microsoft was fined but still hasn't changed their certificate titles, and this fined was levied in 2004. So it shows that enforcement of this is spotty at best.
- derekp7 9y agoThe title of the page at https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/learning/mcse-certification.aspx https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/learning/mcse-certification.... is "Microft Certified Solutions Expert".
- bdcravens 9y agoMicrosoft ended the MCSE (replacing it with MCITP) and then brought it back without the "engineer" title in 2012.
- jnbiche 9y agoAll in all, I agree. However, I'm a self-taught software developer who could do (and frequently do do) my job without Stackoverflow.com. Furthermore, given enough time, I'm also confident I could build from scratch any of the frameworks I use on a day-to-day basis. And yet I would not consider myself a software engineer (even though I've held that job title). The more I learn about serious computer science and engineering work, the more I realize that I can't do that kind of work with any degree of fluency...yet. I'm continuing to work (slowly) toward that direction. But I've also realized that relatively few software developer jobs actually require these skills. Nonetheless, I am a very solid software developer, who can built robust, correct, and reliable software. Actually, I think "software technician" is a great name for bootcamp graduates to hold. It perfectly captures the level of training they've finished.
- lovich 9y agoDo mechanical or electrical engineers do their jobs without access to datasheets or reference tables? In what world is engineering defined on a person's ability to remember facts vs their ability to build things inside of resource constraints and with high levels of tolerance?
- bdcravens 9y agoI didn't say no reference materials, only Stackoverflow :-)
- lovich 9y agoIf you can guarantee documentation as good as documentation for physical materials then I'd say yea. I do agree that there are a portion of developers who seem to just copy and paste from stack overflow without even trying to understand whats happening
- bdcravens 9y agoYes, and that's was what I was referring to. My bigger point of course being that there are plenty of "engineers" that really don't know how to solve problems, but just assemble code.