5 ms·
Free speech is a right, and something that the government must allow. People and companies have no imperative to provide the same freedom on platforms they cont
by danpalmer 9y ago
Free speech is a right, and something that the government must allow. People and companies have no imperative to provide the same freedom on platforms they control.
While I respect the decision to remain neutral, I have more respect for companies that say no to hate on their platforms. There is no requirement for them to provide a platform for it, and I think it's courageous for companies to have human morals, too many don't.
- kemitche 9y agoI find nothing wrong with either approach. "Service providers" that are neutral are fine by me. Free speech - the concept, not the amendment - would not work in the current connected world if every service provider had to "ok" your message before it got out.
- danpalmer 9y agoTrue, and I'm not suggesting that service providers would have to "ok" anything. I just think it's fair for them to set terms of service that lay out what you can and can't do, and for those terms of service to have some moral backing to them, beyond simple legality. One thing I think should be differentiated though is certain types of communication channels. I think internet access should be protected for freedom of speech. Selling merchandise online though is not fundamental to that speech though and should not be protected. Similarly I don't think a domain name is a fundamental requirement (in the case of the Daily Stormer).
- throwawayjava 9y ago> I just think it's fair for them to set terms of service that lay out what you can and can't do, and for those terms of service to have some moral backing to them, beyond simple legality. This would make a great piece of cyberpunk dystopian fiction. Humanity in a far off future finds its codified moral compass not in religious texts, not in the spoken words of religious leaders, and certainly not in books written by philosophers. But rather, in corporate contracts copy-pasted together by Employee #5 at some hyper-growth startups during the Early Years.
- mikeash 9y agoI just wish they'd be honest about it. Shopify Payments has a long list of products they won't allow. But when it's Nazis, suddenly they're taking a principled stand that they don't pick and choose.
- Chris2048 9y agoWhat the product is, and who is selling it are entirely different aspects.
- whatshisface 9y agoNazis? That's starting to become a pretty broad word. How conservative do you have to be before you become a Nazi? More importantly, how fast is the line moving?
- mikeash 9y agoLast time I checked, Breitbart's Shopify store was selling items featuring the Nazi parteiadler. I don't think this is a difficult or ambiguous case.
- whatshisface 9y agoWell, I had to google both the word parteialder and the brietbart store, but I found this HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13608777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13608777 So, I could argue that the fact that it is being discussed indicates that it may be a little ambiguous after all. It's worth noting that your final conclusion was that the symbol "screamed Nazi" when you saw it, and that you could understand it not being sufficient.
- mikeash 9y agoLiterally anything can be ambiguous when people blind themselves sufficiently. There's a gigantic debate over whether the Confederate flag is a symbol of slavery! Organizations like Breitbart thrive on "reasonable" people's willingness to give them a tremendous benefit of the doubt. They're like a little kid who lies down on top of the covers and plays with toys when you tell them to "go to bed." And a lot of people who should really know better step up and say, "technically they did what you said, I see nothing wrong with that."
- greggman 9y agoJust paying devil's advocate but it seems by your logic all the phone companies should be ok to monitor all conversations and ban anyone having a hate converations. All email providers should be ok to scan email and ban anyone for hate emails or any other topic they dislike. They're private companies right? The phone companies may be regulated as public utilities but most of my friends don't use the phone company's voice services anymore. Instead they call on Facebook Messenger or Line or WhatsApp which are not regulated as public utilities. I don't know where to draw the line. Kicking them off say youtube? Maybe. Kicking them off the entire internet? I'm not so sure. Allowing them to stay on the internet (if you agree banning them from the internet is going too far) requires some companies to carry their content.
- DanBC 9y agoShopify is not a dumb pipe. Email services are not dumb pipes. Even common carriers are not strictly dumb pipes.
- wedowhatwedo 9y agoIs Breitbart's store a private communication or is it public communication? Email and phone conversations are private communication. Breitbart is public communication. There is a difference.
- kennywinker 9y agoThere is a way to carve out exceptions to corporations ability to limit free speech. The cost of laying phone lines or setting up a network of cell towers and buying bandwidth makes entering the phone market prohibitive. If even one company bans your speech from their phone network, you are likely to be unable to speak. Phone companies should be considered the infrastructure of speech, and thus not be allowed to limit the types of converstions you have. Shopify is just one of many ecommerce platforms. There are simple roll-your-own ones as well. If they ban someone, there is no major impedements to getting their speech out still. Right now all I see is shopify profiting from hate, not defending free speech. Brietbart can go set up opencart on a vps.
- kenjackson 9y agoMonitoring phone calls seems like a big leap from where the conversation was it. I think most people would agree that if you keep things private that even a private entity shouldn't expose that. But if you broadcast the information publicly, then you are now liable to be held to a different standard. So if a group started holding advertising public WhatsApp calls where they'd discuss plans to exterminate minority groups then I think WhatsApp would be OK in canceling their account (assuming its consistent with their TOS). I don't think messaging apps should be able to collude though. This should be at a case by case, company by company basis.
- Danihan 9y agoIt's also a cultural value worth aspiring to.
- mc32 9y agoKeep in mind, a few decades ago this same thinking would allow companies to deny services to people because of the companies' racist policies. So right now things dovetail nicely into morally defensible stances, but there is no guarantee things will coincide this way in the future which is why we defend free speech in more absolutist terms (with special carve outs).
- odiroot 9y agoYou're confusing free speech with US constitutions' first amendment. Not all of us live in USA. Free speech is a universal right, independent of the platform. Now US government respects this freedom and executes it on it's platform, that's the public space. Now, on the other hand, many US companies don't give you the same freedom. They don't allow the free speech on their platforms. We should be thinking whether it's good or bad and don't muddle the discussion with the American-specific PoV. I personally don't like to see companies having any morals. There's nothing courageous about it. I would like to see companies have ethics instead and follow them to the best of their abilities. Ours is the privilege of judgment.
- shkkmo 9y ago> I personally don't like to see companies having any morals. There's nothing courageous about it. I would like to see companies have ethics instead and follow them to the best of their abilities. Yes, absolutely. Corporations are people and don't need to take moral or political stances, especially when there is still so much work to be done just getting Corporations to behave at all ethically.
- vixen99 9y agoWhose ethics or do you think everyone has the same ethical principles?
- oh_sigh 9y agoDoes your view apply to bakeries as well? Is it ok for bakeries to not bake cakes for gay people because they disagree with the lifestyle choice?
- jazzyk 9y agoThere is no clear definition of what "hate speech" is. For example, would you categorize this WaPo article: "Segregationists have again assumed their pedestals in the Justice Department, the White House and many other American temples. Paper alone won’t drive them out. Start throwing rocks." [1] as hate speech? If yes, should we ban WaPo? If not, why not? Who decides? By what standards? Private entities which are not de-facto monopolies (like Google) have the right to do as they please, but they should publish VERY clear rules, which will then apply to anyone, regardless of political affiliation. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/made-by-history/wp/2017/08/15/charlottesville-showed-that-liberalism-cant-defeat-white-supremacy-only-direct-action-can/?utm_term=.4c802065c754 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/made-by-history/wp/2017/...
- lj3 9y ago> People and companies have no imperative to provide the same freedom on platforms they control. That's what I keep hearing, and yet a company in Denver was forced by law to bake a wedding cake for a gay couple against his religious morals. Why does that not apply to internet companies?