4 ms·
I can give you an anecdotal counter-example: when I was a kid I ate tons of sugar. Ice cream. Twinkies. Hi-C. Foot Loops. You name it. If it had sugar in
by lisper 9y ago
I can give you an anecdotal counter-example: when I was a kid I ate tons of sugar. Ice cream. Twinkies. Hi-C. Foot Loops. You name it. If it had sugar in it, I ate it. I was never overweight, nor was I particularly athletic. If anyone should have suffered negative consequences from eating too much sugar, it was me. But nope, I was perfectly svelte and healthy. I graduated high school in 1982.
- Tharkun 9y agoRecently the type of sugar has been the subject of controversy/research. IIRC, most sugar used to be actual sugar, but sweets and soft drinks often contain high fructose corn syrup these days. Apparentlt our body can deal with glucose reasonably well, but sucks at dealing with fructose.
- dredmorbius 9y ago"Table sugar" (sucrose) is a bonded glucose and fructose molecule. HFCS is roughly the same ratio, though not bonded. The bond breakdown is pretty much instantaneous within the GI tract from my understanding. This suggests little actual difference between sucrose and HFCS.... keep reading ... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sucrose https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sucrose https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-fructose_corn_syrup https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-fructose_corn_syrup ... though Robert Lustig who studies this now seems to be claiming that there are different metabolic effects for sucrose and HFCS: Lustig also confirms what many consumers have intuitively figured out — that “sucrose (sugar) and HFCS have different metabolic effects,” including those that come from the much higher fructose content of HFCS which can range from 55 to 90 percent, and in the case of crystalline fructose to practically 100 percent. (Sucrose, or natural sugar, by contrast is a 50/50 combination of bound glucose and fructose). http://foodidentitytheft.com/obesity-expert-dr-robert-lustig-hfcs-a-significant-factor-in-childs-type-2-diabetes/ http://foodidentitytheft.com/obesity-expert-dr-robert-lustig...
- DanBC 9y agoSucrose is 50% glucose and 50% fructose. HFCS is 42% fructose, 53% glucose and 5% other sugars/polysaccharides. Is it the fructose?
- will_brown 9y agoSounds like a bunch of BS from the sugar/soft drink industry. I'll suggest a more practical/simple explanation between the different glucose and fructose and the diseases I mention. Fructose: primarily broken down in the liver. Glucose: When blood glucose rises, the pancreas releases insulin. Again I am talking about fatty liver disease and type 2 diabetes (insulin resistance), based on numbers alone it would seem children are more susceptible to developing fatty liver rather than insulin resistance, but that seems to be a very bizarre basis to suggest one is healthy. Moreover, even if a body doesn't develop insulin resistance, insulin itself is enlarging cells throughout the body, including fat cells, priming the body for obesity, which carries its own health issues. And again I only say sugar is a contributing factor to obesity, but no doubt insulin is a hell of a primer for obesity.
- will_brown 9y agoWell I have a grandmother who lived to 92 years old and smoked heavily everyday, she never developed OCPD, carcinoma of the lungs, or any other health issues commonly related to cigarette smoking. Again the first case of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease in a child was 1983, today 10% have it. Compare the sugar content of the Hi-C, fruit loops and ice cream of the 70's and compare it with the products of today. And that's not to say if you were born 10 years later you would have non alcoholic fatty liver disease or childhood type 2 diabetes, but the point is those didn't exist at all in the 70's. And it's not exactly controversial, talk to any pediatrician, 100% of all childhood cases of type 2 diabetes and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease could have been avoided through diet.
- lisper 9y ago> Again the first case of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease in a child was 1983, today 10% have it. Sure, but what I'm saying is that if sugar were the sole cause, the first case should have shown up long before 1983. I was eating tons of sugar through the seventies, and I doubt very much that I was anywhere close to alone in that. I do not doubt that sugar (fructose in particular) is bad for you. But it seems to me that it can't be just sugar consumption that accounts for today's higher disease rates. There has to be something else going on that we haven't figured out yet.
- will_brown 9y agoJust to reemphasize my first comment, sugar is an obvious contributing factor to obesity. As to the diseases (type 2 diabetes and fatty liver) in children, there may be other contributing factors but ask any pediatrician, remove the sugar from the diet and these diseases can be prevented in 100% of cases. So someone such as yourself who ate a ton of sugar in the 70's, you primed your body for obesity, whether or not you were ever obese or simply overweight. What does that mean? Well when you consume glucose and it enters the blood your body releases insulin, insulin enlarges all the cells in the body but especially fat cells, and that significantly alters how your body stores and burns fat. All things being equal if you don't have a caloric surplus your body won't store the excess fat. A caloric surplus that leads to fat storage is about 30 calories per day or about 2 peanut m&ms, so it's not much. That said not knowing anything more about your childhood diet, I do know if your sugar consumption was the same but you were a child today on average you would be consuming 500-600 more calories today than in the 70's. Therefore, you would be more likely to be overweight or even obese today than in the 70's. You don't need to be obese to have fatty liver or type 2 diabetes, but statistically you would be more likely to have those diseases if you were obese. I am not suggesting sugar is the sole factor of obesity or these disease, rather sugar removal would prevent 100% of these diseases in children, otherwise I can't argue against your anecdotal evidence of eating a ton of sugar but only highlight the reality kids today are consuming significantly more sugar on average and significantly more calories on average. See: http://www.cleveland.com/fighting-fat/index.ssf/2010/04/americans_are_consuming_more_calories_than_ever.html http://www.cleveland.com/fighting-fat/index.ssf/2010/04/amer...