4 ms·
I just don't want any more stuff. I came to a realisation that much of what our society is about is focused on getting people to buy more stuff. I don't want
by andrewstuart 9y ago
I just don't want any more stuff.
I came to a realisation that much of what our society is about is focused on getting people to buy more stuff.
I don't want it. Minimise the stuff.
edit: I'm still surrounded by piles of it. Getting rid of stuff is hard. There's a sense of "value" attached to stuff even if you'd never miss it if you never saw it again.
- stretchwithme 9y agoTotally. The message of the Minimalism doc. https://www.netflix.com/title/80114460 https://www.netflix.com/title/80114460 Got rid of 20% of my stuff this year and hope to get rid of 20% more.
- rtpg 9y agobit OT but I was really disappointed by that documentary. It's a completely uncritical surface level look at the ideas. Was really expecting something a bit more developed. Then I realized that the two who are interviewed for it were in fact the ones making the documentary, so it has a whole infomercial feel to it.
- justboxing 9y ago> so it has a whole infomercial feel to it. Totally. I felt the same way and couldn't watch it past the 15 minute mark. Those 2 guys were mostly talking about their own lives and marketing their minimalist site (not I won't link to it here :)
- stretchwithme 9y agoDidn't realize that.
- peterlk 9y agoI once made a comment like this to my father. His response was: "that feeling is a luxury of having grown up with a plentitude of stuff". And I think he's got a point. It's really easy to get rid of stuff if you know that you can replace it (or at least replace its function). If you travel to places where "stuff" is not plentiful, people cherish their belongings (stuff) more
- daxfohl 9y agoBoth sides point to a plausible argument for "Less or More than (say) Ten things is undesirable". EDIT: turns out Mel Brooks has already spoken on the matter: https://youtu.be/Ah-WdAwVg9c?t=59 https://youtu.be/Ah-WdAwVg9c?t=59
- icelancer 9y ago100% the truth. My family had below-average income and all I sought to do was augment my life with stuff through my early 20's. As I've grown older I totally understand that it didn't make me happy (quite the opposite), but that realization doesn't set in until you've had the stuff in the first place. I saw much the same pattern with other poor kids I grew up with who went on to make good money.
- wutbrodo 9y agoThis is overgeneralizing par excellence. For a counterexample, I grew up with not very much money and now make good money, and I'm far _less_ into getting and having stuff than all of my born-rich friends. My slight tendency to hoard is more than balanced out by the fact that I don't feel nearly the need to or comfort with acquiring unnecessary things that all my friends do.
- ljf 9y agoPut of interest, what do you hoard? I'm similar - I don't spend much money, but I do (at times) find myself surrounded by crap or tools or the detritus of 'hobbies' that I tired of. Had another clear out lately and feeling great for it, though likely need another round or two...
- BrainInAJar 9y agoI grew up poor, but I'm not now, and I can't bring myself to throw away anything, because what if I need it some day?
- pm90 9y ago
- amorphid 9y agoA few years ago I took a job 4000km away, and I got rid of everything in my apartment. As I boarded my departure flight, I was carrying everything I owned in a backpack and carryon suitcase. I didn't even have checked luggage, and I didn't even own a pair of pants (wore sweatpants on the flight). It was a great feeling.
- csydas 9y agoI was fortunate enough to do something like this as well. It started with leaving a bad life situation and moving westward across the US to Seattle with everything I owned in the back of a 95' Honda Accord. Then a few years later it became everything I important I own in one box sent to a friend to sit in a closet and the rest in a small suitcase and a duffle bag. Both times were escapes to something better and the first time I had stressed greatly about "what am I going to do with all this stuff?". Actually getting rid of the stuff was a real relief, and now I wonder why I kept most of it and moved it so many times.
- agumonkey 9y agowelcome to frugal minimalism
- ekianjo 9y ago> I just don't want any more stuff. That's also because most of us live in cities nowadays and you can access to "stuff" you need outside of your place pretty much anytime, anywhere, therefore there is no need for you to build inventory anymore at home. But if you were living far from everything, you'd definitely want to possess things.
- ikeyany 9y agoThe trend happened for a reason. Suburbs aren't as interesting as they were in the 80s--no one wants a big ol empty palace in the middle of nowhere since technology is what gives us space now.
- pm90 9y agoProbably also a cultural thing. A big ol empty place in the middle of nowhere seems like a better place to raise kids and build equity early.
- ikeyany 9y agoThere is a distinct difference between a big ol empty place in the middle of nowhere and a place suitable to raise kids. Even those who want to buy and start a family would do so closer in than in the middle of nowhere. That wasn't the case 30-40 years ago.
- cortesoft 9y agoI totally appreciate that there are a lot of people who want to reduce the amount of stuff they have, and feel that our consumer society leads them down a path they don't want to be on. I am getting a bit sick and tired, however, of this refrain that everyone needs to be a minimalist. I like my stuff. I try not to be a hoarder, but I like buying things and having things, and I don't feel guilty about it. My personal tastes are for practical things, I don't have anything decorative that I care about, but I do love the 'toys' that I have. I like my metal working tools, my woodworking tools, my 3D printer, and all of the stuff in my workshop because I like making things. I enjoy buying things to make my hobbies more enjoyable. I like my RC helicopters, even though I rarely get to fly them at the moment. I like my old video game consoles, so I can satisfy my nostalgia when I want to. I might not play them more than once every few years, but I am glad I have them. I look forward to sharing them with my daughter some day when she is old enough to play. I like having all my old legos and erector sets, and look forward to sharing them with my daughter as well. I don't feel 'cluttered' by my stuff. I have a good organization system, and they don't interfere with my day to day life. What is the harm in having a box of legos in the closet? Everyone is entitled to live how they want, but don't act like I am a bad person because I like having stuff.
- andrewstuart 9y ago>> I am getting a bit sick and tired, however, of this refrain that everyone needs to be a minimalist I spoke only for myself :-)
- cortesoft 9y agoPerhaps, but your phrasing certainly made it sound like you were speaking a universal truth.
- fredoliveira 9y agoLiterally every single sentence of his comment starts with "I".
- 9y ago
- ksk 9y ago>I came to a realisation that much of what our society is about is focused on getting people to buy more stuff. With a few exceptions, that's why most people have jobs!