8 ms·
America, Home of the Transactional Marriage
- beebmam 9y agoThere really should be no financial benefit to marriage. It becomes a coercive force that encourages people to marry and stay married, even though they may not want to.
- jseliger 9y agoMore interesting, I think, is how lopsided sex ratios can affect who marries and for how long: https://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/19/briefly-noted-date-onomics-how-dating-became-a-lopsided-numbers-game-jon-birger https://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/19/briefly-noted-date-onomic...
- elipsey 9y agoI thought that was a considered a feature, not a bug....
- lotsofpulp 9y agoA legal marriage is a legal contract, and all contracts are transactional (as far as I know). I don't think it's wise to pretend that a marriage contract is different from any other, and it's most useful in cases of conflict where a 3rd party (judge, hospital, etc) needs to determine what to do. The love aspect of it does not and should not have to do with the legal aspect. At the end of the day, putting food on the table and a roof over your kids' heads is life's priority, so finding a partner who can assist with that is understandably a prerequisite before any of this love/compatibility stuff can be built on top.
- Sukotto 9y agoI sure wish I had treated it (as you say) more like a "real" contract. It would have saved us a ton of trouble to lay out our respective expectations, roles, responsibilities, duties, and penalties for breaking the above. I think it would have saved us both a ton of trouble, misunderstandings, and hurt feelings.
- subroutine 9y agoNot that it isn't important to lay out those things before signing a marriage contract... but I'm not sure how much flexibility you have in deciding the (legal) penalties for breaking those informal expectations etc. I imagine the terms of a marriage contract are defined by each state, as sort of a take-it-or-leave-it contract. There might be ways to hedge, like prenuptial agreements. However (and not exactly the same thing), I recently spoke with a corporate attorney regarding company protections in the unfortunate case something happened to one of the company founders under various scenarios (e.g. if a company founder gets married and dies within 5 years of incorporation, is there a way to require the spouse to sell those shares back to the company, rather than them owning a controlling stake). Prenuptial agreements were brought-up, and my attorney basically said, "yeah those exist, and are an option, an expensive option, but in a legal battle, pffft, don't expect a prenup to be your pocket ace."
- dragonwriter 9y ago> A legal marriage is a legal contract Not really; its sometimes referred to as a contract, but legally the law of contracts doesn't apply either in formation of marriages, or when the expectations associated with marriage are broken. Marriage is somewhat analogous to a legal partership (especially in common law jurisdictions, where merely behaving as if it existed can cause it to legally exist.)
- lotsofpulp 9y agoActually, for a couple who earn about the same each, there is a marriage penalty: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/04/16/upshot/marriage-penalty-couples-income.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/04/16/upshot/marria...
- sokoloff 9y agoIf the tax penalty is smaller than the savings from sharing a household, it's still an advantage to be married vs single and living alone.
- bitlax 9y agoA benefit, independent of marriage, which applies to those who cohabitate and roommates.
- xxXXxx- 9y agoThere's other financial benefits to marriage, off the top of my head: Family health insurance plans Unlimited tax free inheritance Spousal social security and pension Social security survivors benefits
- protomyth 9y agoWell, you could be unmarried and living together.
- PakG1 9y agoI don't know how it is in other places, but in Vancouver, if you cohabit for a number of years, you are subject to the same stuff as if you were married couples. I can't remember the details, forgive me, busy work day.
- kobeya 9y agoThat's called common-law marriage and it exists in California too, but it doesn't mean you start paying married tax rates. It just means that, e.g., if your partner falls terminally ill you are allowed to make medical decisions for them just as a spouse would, or if they die you take custody of the children rather than their side of the family, etc.
- closeparen 9y agoThe economic benefits of sharing a bedroom with another income earner will only get more powerful as we crowd into cities that don't want to grow. DINK is on its way from being a nice bonus to baseline entry criteria if you want to live within public transit range of a job. That doesn't require marriage, per se, but something that looks a lot like it.
- roceasta 9y ago>coercive force that encourages people to marry and stay married Not necessarily 'stay married' because for many people there's a financial incentive to get divorced. And you can't get divorced if you don't get married in the first place.
- laretluval 9y agoThe whole idea of marriage is to be a coercive force that pushes people away from a defect-defect equilibrium in the Prisoner's Dilemma of relationships.
- icanhackit 9y agoI'd wager entertainment and advertising plays a large part in it as well. Educated people see the folly in shows like the Kardashians, daytime soap operas and ads showing material wealth as virtuous and something to aspire to. Less critical thinkers lap that stuff up and misinterpret the source of happiness and contentment. TV shows can create toxic expectations that can't be practically met by everyone, and for many people these shows have replaced community culture and personal belief systems. The culture of material expectation could help explain the difference between Canada and the US when it comes to relationship stability and partner selection. Obviously better social welfare in Canada/West Europe is a massive driver, but it would still need to be paired with a culture where the stigma of poverty isn't as great and material wealth isn't as coveted.
- compiler-guy 9y agoThere is remarkable data showing that the television show "Sixteen and Pregnant" reduces teen pregnancy rates in locations where it is shown. This would tend to support your hypothesis. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/wp/2014/04/09/how-mtvs-16-and-pregnant-led-to-declining-teen-birth-rates/?utm_term=.523213462be8 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/w...
- KekDemaga 9y agoLooks like the result was more positive than that though I'm curious how they came to the final conclusion: "Using data from Google Trends, Twitter, Nielsen ratings and Vital Statistics birth data, Professors Kearney and Levine found that teens who watch “16 and Pregnant” immediately go online to search for (and tweet about) birth control and abortion. Through some very impressive and fascinating dot-connecting, Kearney and Levine found that “16 and Pregnant” led to a 5.7% reduction in teen births — a percentage that accounts for one-third of the total decline in teen births: 20,000 fewer teen births a year."
- alasdair_ 9y agoI'm almost certain that this was the initial effect, but later seasons (where every one of the cast members are reasonably wealthy due to cash from MTV) had the opposite effect. I can o ly find 2014 data right now rhough. Relatedly, "baby simulators" lead to an increase in teen pregnancy -https://www.statnews.com/2016/08/25/infant-simulators-teen-pregnancy/ https://www.statnews.com/2016/08/25/infant-simulators-teen-p...
- zxcvvcxz 9y ago> The country’s exceptionally thin safety net prompts residents—especially those with less-steady employment—to view partnership in more economic terms. Huh? This is literally the opposite of reality. It's the poorer countries with low GDPs per capita that have thin public safety nets, and where strong marriage and family ties are a must, economically speaking. Here in The West, we're so rich that we'll redistribute our money (tax dollars) and allow you to become a single mother. Furthermore, name me another part of the world with fat homeless people. Marriage is not "transactional" in the country with one of the richest countries on Earth. With a GDP per capita of 57,466.79 USD (2016), marriage is optional, and economically independent women don't need to settle with mid-tier men, especially not during the "fun years" (e.g. 18 - 30). Remember, 80% of men are below average: https://theblog.okcupid.com/your-looks-and-your-inbox-8715c0f1561e https://theblog.okcupid.com/your-looks-and-your-inbox-8715c0...
- coldtea 9y ago>It's the poorer countries with low GDPs per capita that have thin public safety nets, and where strong marriage and family ties are a must, economically speaking. Here in The West, we're so rich that we'll redistribute our money (tax dollars) and allow you to become a single mother. That was then, this is now, as they say. In the west safety nets might not be as thin as in the "poorer countries" but they have been getting increasingly thinner. And being a "single mother" is the last thing (economically speaking) anyone would wish for in today's climate. So you're both right. Marriage is even more transactional in the poorer countries, but the article is about how it's becoming more transactional in the US too, which is indeed a thing. >Marriage is not "transactional" in the country with one of the richest countries on Earth. That doesn't matter for those who can't find a job, or that are an illness away from being homeless and with no savings -- which are millions.
- gozur88 9y ago>In the west safety nets might not be as thin as in the "poorer countries" but they have been getting increasingly thinner. I can't speak for the rest of The West, but the safety net in the US has been getting better over time. Compared to my childhood it's easier to qualify for government assistance and it's easier to get medical care.
- lmg643 9y agoThis is a pretty provincial piece. Marriage has been transactional for thousands of years. To this day, the practice continues around the world. I have a colleague in the US who has an arranged marriage (he was born overseas). But of course, let's pretend that "romantic love" is the historical norm (versus recent movie invention) and we've somehow fallen from this expectation.
- swsieber 9y agoThe divorce rate is a new thing though, right? I'd bet that even if it was an arranged marriage, if you knew you weren't going to get divorced, you'd try to find ways to love your partner...
- closeparen 9y agoRecognizing domestic violence and spousal rape as outside the bounds of acceptable behavior and/or grounds for redress is also a new development, in the grand scheme of things.
- victorhooi 9y agoDo you have any evidence do suggest this is actually a leading cause of divorce, as opposed to other things like personality clashes, financial stress, etc. Everything I've read seems to suggest that incompatible personalities and finances are the main reasons people in our society split up - which would seem to debunk your theory.
- closeparen 9y agoIf it's happened so much as once (and I don't think that's controversial), then it's a good thing we let people get divorced instead of telling them they had better find ways to love their partners.
- riquito 9y agoDo you seriously think that all the fights and demonstrations to get the right to divorce were mostly because of "incompatible personalities and finances"?
- gozur88 9y agoThis article seems completely unmoored from any historical context.
- dangoldin 9y agoThis reminded me of a book I read last year that takes about the role of work and poverty in a poor, anonymous town in California. Definitely worth reading if you're interested in this topic: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0043GWQ22/ref=oh_aui_d_detailpage_o02_?ie=UTF8&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0043GWQ22/ref=oh_aui_d_de...
- nl 9y agoAn interesting somewhat related phenomenon is the rise of the medical divorce, where a couple will divorce to protect assets from medical debt bankruptcy[1][2]. The ACA and Medicaid expansion lowered the divorce rate by a measurable amount in some population groups[3] which I find amazing. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/feeonlyplanner/2014/08/21/divorce-due-to-medical-bills-sometimes-it-makes-sense/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/feeonlyplanner/2014/08/21/divor... [2] http://www.helsell.com/helsell-news/medicaid-divorce-an-overview/ http://www.helsell.com/helsell-news/medicaid-divorce-an-over... [3] http://fortune.com/2017/02/16/obamacare-divorce/ http://fortune.com/2017/02/16/obamacare-divorce/
- kennethh 9y agoI can recommend reading The Rational Male, he discusses the dynamics of marriage and you get a much better understanding after reading the books or the articles on the website. https://therationalmale.com/ https://therationalmale.com/ Teaser: women initiate 70+% of the divorces and the reasons they do is not what is shown in the media.