3 ms·
the second group was immediately told the correct percentage the [federal] government spends on welfare (1 percent) If the researchers reported "1 percent" as
by gojomo 16y ago
the second group was immediately told the correct percentage the [federal] government spends on welfare (1 percent)
If the researchers reported "1 percent" as the actual federal government spending on welfare programs, they were themselves misleading people in the service of an agenda, perhaps by using an incredibly narrow legalistic definition of "welfare".
For 2009, Wikipedia reports $3.1 trillion in US federal expenditures. $224 billion, about 7%, went to Medicaid and SCHIP -- medical assistance to lower-income people -- which would fall under a common, casual definition of 'welfare'. Another $360 billion -- over 11%, went to a category Wikipedia calls "Unemployment/Welfare/Other mandatory spending", which appears to include ~$40 billion in unemployment compensation, at least $100 billion in "other income security", and $100 billion in food and housing assistance. Again, most people would consider most or all of this spending 'welfare'.
Even Social Security and Medicare -- as they often subsidize the spending of people with more money than they've paid in, especially low-income people -- have at least some component that would be fair to consider 'welfare'. Together, they are over $1.3 trillion of the federal budget -- more than 40%.
A plain English definition of 'welfare' from Princeton's WordNet is "governmental provision of economic assistance to persons in need". From the items listed above, one could easily make the case 15%-40% of the federal budget fits that definition.
And this is without even going into subsidies for the middle-class and corporations -- the home mortgage interest tax deduction, cash-for-clunkers, financial bailouts, farm subsidies -- which are also economic assistance, and ostensibly justified because the recipients are said to have some pressing need, and sometimes archly labeled 'welfare'.
(While I've used 2009 numbers, the 1999/2000 numbers -- when the Kuklinski UIUC study was published -- aren't that different in overall proportions. The respondents -- with their more-common answers of 5%/8%/11%/15% -- were all closer to the real values than the researchers' preferred 1% answer.)
- eli 16y agoYou may be technically correct, but I think very few people would consider Social Security part of "welfare." IMHO, you could rerun the study with the phrase "food stamps" instead of "welfare" and get very similar results.
- tokenadult 16y agoI think very few people would consider Social Security part of "welfare." Okay, so now we have an illustration of mass irrationality in the political system. Looking at how Social Security is funded and distributed fits typical definitions of a welfare program.
- btilly 16y agoLooking at how Social Security is funded and distributed fits typical definitions of a welfare program. I disagree. Typical definitions of a welfare program have money going to poor people as a central feature. That doesn't describe Social Security. Social Security pays a disproportionate amount to those who are well off. There are two factors. The amount you get paid out depends on how much you put in, and your life span. People who are better off generally wind up paying in more, and then live longer to collect benefits. Overall Social Security represents a wealth transfer from young to old, and from the poor to the top 20% of the population. Oh right, and in recent decades it has been a net source of working revenue for the federal government, through the form of buying Treasury bonds. But now it is considered broken because the federal government does not have any way to pay back to Social Security money that is owed it from general funds...
- tokenadult 16y agoSocial Security pays a disproportionate amount to those who are well off. I agree with this criticism of Social Security and this basis for saying that Social Security is distinct from welfare. The reason I tend to regard Social Security as a welfare program is that it is, I think by general agreement, an ENTITLEMENT program, in other words a program that a subsidized recipient can draw from with only minimal reference to individual characteristics of the recipient. (You disagree with me on that point, in part, but the degree to which Social Security payments to recipients are linked to taxpayer "contributions" to a Social Security account is only partial, not on exact actuarial principles.)
- btilly 16y ago