5 ms·
Every time I've tried to use OpenBazaar it's been a real mess. Not the "unpolished open source project" kind of mess but the "why the fuck did you think that wo
by swiley 9y ago
Every time I've tried to use OpenBazaar it's been a real mess. Not the "unpolished open source project" kind of mess but the "why the fuck did you think that would have been a good idea?" kind of mess. The very first time I went to use it the ".config" file just automatically ran sudo and one of the OSX package managers (whichever one I didn't have installed.) If I had typed my password into the password prompt (which appeared with no explanation by the way) it would have really messed things up.
The idea seems neat, and potentially empowering. The implementation is pretty lacking though.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoThank goodness. I can only hope they're incompetent. You know what? We should build one. Right now. Otherwise someone else will. If we become the defacto standard, we can at least have some controls in place. You might argue that would disqualify the implementation, but network effects are very powerful. eBay is still eBay.
- swiley 9y agoTBH I'm not too sure something like that could even work. I remember logging into #bitcoin-otc one day and hearing about what arbatrage did, that was when I lost faith in these reputation based markets. Even stuff like amazons struggles with this.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoAh. What do you see as some of the major problems? It's hard to overstate how easy it is to dismiss ideas like this, though. I vividly remember my friend wanting to start a Bitcoin exchange in 2010 or so. He was like we can do it, people will eventually be transacting in BTC, this is a huge opportunity. Exchange? Isn't that finance? That's regulation hell, better not even try. Funny how things turn out. Before that he was talking about neutal nets when we were teenagers, and I thought he was crazy. AI was just a fad that died in the 80's. This particular idea seems of the same class, and I'm determined not to make the same mistake three times. But if there are hard issues with it, it's best to know. So what did you have in mind?
- whiddershins 9y agoIf you need random help, I'm in.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoSure, what's your email? Companies fail 100% of the time when they're formed like this, but this isn't really a company (it has to be free to compete with OpenBazaar) and I'm one person. EDIT: This is doable though. There are endless stories of new startups running circles around established competitors. I don't know if that will happen, but we should explore the possibility. How hard can it be to set this up in a nice packaged experience? It's a lot of work, but it's not difficult work.
- tylersmith 9y agoEdit: I did not believe sillysaurus was being serious. I am not trying to poach. If you'd like to work on a decentralized marketplace we'd love to have you help out with OpenBazaar. Feel free to join our Slack and discuss what you might like to work on if you'd like.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI mean, this is the perfect example of why not to join your project. You're here because we're talking about you. You made this offer because this is a subthread about displacing you, specifically. I don't trust people who are so opportunistic, and there are many reasons not to let you get control over a network that may be with us for the next hundred years. How about you go work on your project run by former spooks, and I'll start my own, and we'll see who comes out on top? You're also the beficiary of investors. Ask yourself: why are they investing in you? Your stated goal is to never turn a profit, ever. You've also foregone any ICO attempt, which is free money. Why? Because you can't, because if people start using your project with your new Tor support, you'll be a co-conspirator in a drug distribution network. But you don't just come out and say this. You're not straightforward. It's fake idealism, and that quality more than any other is what motivates me to compete here. The fact that you're worried is even more evidence that we were onto something. Maybe others will join me, if I show convincing progress. Or maybe not, and you'll be the eBay of the future. Considering your founders' ties, that's pretty unsettling. So why don't you join me instead? This is a standing invitation to all readers: email me. Let's figure out how to organize this and make it work.
- tylersmith 9y ago"I can only hope they're incompetent." Not all of us. There are multiple companies and a lot of people working on OpenBazaar of varying skills. Our new major version fixes a number of issues with version 1 which was built with much less funding and man power.
- tylersmith 9y agoI agree version 1 isn't great. We're alpha testing version 2 and so far it's being received a lot better.