3 ms·
Reading your comments, I'm starting to think the male brain is too emotional to effectively engage in science. Of course, that cuts rather to the point here: n
by acdha 9y ago
Reading your comments, I'm starting to think the male brain is too emotional to effectively engage in science.
Of course, that cuts rather to the point here: nobody will ever look at your comments and make a general observation about all men. The author mentioned her background as a researcher to establish her credibility to talk on the subject because she knew that people would question it just as strongly as they would ignore Damore's lack of authority[1]. She had an entire section about trust, no doubt anticipating these kinds of attempts to dismiss the science by criticizing the author. Had she left it out, I have precisely zero doubt that some dude would try to play gotcha confabulating a conspiracy theory around that choice.
Also, I do find it somewhat curious that I've read tons of science writing which included some personal details and that never seems to be criticized coming from a male author.
Finally, just for the record I'm not the author and have never met her. I'm also not a scientist but I did previously support a computational neuroscience department and her conclusions matched very closely with what they used to say when the topic came up, so I felt very comfortable sharing this article as a counter to all of the tedious “my opinion deserves attention because it sounds science-y” commentary I've seen here, especially given the copious citations to actual peer reviewed research.
1. Translating to fields more familiar to HN, this seems like a debate about building scalable databases between an EE who focused on semiconductor design and a CS grad student working in distributed systems: neither is automatically correct but the latter is speaking a lot closer to their area of specialization.
- Boothroid 9y agoI wasn't criticising the author - I was criticising the style. Anyone should be able to have a go at anything they want. If they are good, brilliant. I really don't give a monkey's whether the author identifies as fish, dolphin or attack helicopter. Just give me the science without your bloody life story and let me judge it. That's how science is supposed to work.