4 ms·
> we've "proven the existence of dark matter" The article says we've proven the existence of dark energy, not dark matter. They're not the same thing. That sa
by pdonis 9y ago
> we've "proven the existence of dark matter"
The article says we've proven the existence of dark energy, not dark matter. They're not the same thing.
That said, if it does turn out that the SN1a "standard candle" scale has to be revised, that might impact the finding of accelerated expansion on which the dark energy model is based. It will be interesting to see how other cosmologists respond to this paper.
- sgt101 9y agoDo cosmologists allow for the doping of the matter involved in these interaction due to stella aging? It seems to me that more distant supernovas must act differently from the closer ones because they are much younger and therefore undoped by earlier supernova debris.
- pdonis 9y agoAs I understand it, the assumption behind using SN1a as standard candles is not that they all have exactly the same absolute brightness, but that there is a reliable relationship between the light curve (the curve of apparent brightness vs. time) and the absolute brightness. This relationship takes into account variation in the chemical composition of the supernova, which is what "doping" would affect. However, what this particular paper seems to be saying is that there might not be just one light curve-brightness relationship, but two, corresponding to two different explosion processes. If that's true, astronomers would need to go back and review the SN1a data with this new classification scheme in mind.
- raattgift 9y ago> the finding of accelerated expansion on which the dark energy model is based Dark energy arises because of the decomposition of 4-d spacetime into volumes of 3-d space each distinguishable by a time coordinate, and choosing as the timelike axis the one in which matter is -- on average and at the largest scales -- at rest against the 3-d spatial coordinates. That fixes a preferred frame -- the cosmological frame -- for observers who are comoving with the spatial coordinates. Such observers will see no dipole anisotropy in the cosmic microwave background (or the cosmic neutrino background, or other relic fields), and will be comfortable with approximating the distribution of visible matter far from them as a homogeneous isotropic fluid, in spite of local inhomogeneities and local anisotropies (like, for example, the planet each of us has between her- or himself and a large percentage of the rest of the universe). All comoving observers in such a universe will generally agree that in one timelike direction the visible matter is denser and the CMB is hotter and that in the other timelike direction the visible matter is sparser and the CMB is colder. Let's pick the former direction as the past. All observers in such a universe -- even non-comoving ones -- will agree that it takes energy to separate two massive bodies that are gravitationally bound. So in the past, when comoving matter was denser, it would take more energy to separate the bits of matter from one another than in the present, when comoving matter is sparser. Something is keeping objects like galaxy clusters fixed against the comoving coordinates, instead of giving them peculiar velocities against these coordinates as they gravitationally attract one another.[1] That is dark energy, and we can experimentally determine its value in the cosmological frame. The rate at which visible matter is diluting away along the cosmological frame's past->future direction is what what we try to measure. Standard candles are useful for helping fix a distant galaxy to comoving coordinates. As our confidence in the location of distant matter improves, so does our confidence in the average value of dark energy. There are a sizable number of relationships involving measurable quantities like angular diameter, surface brightness, emission/absorption line "forests", and so forth that help us fix galaxies in the cosmological frame of reference, so throwing questions upon only one coordinate:observable relationship is far from fatal to our estimates of dark energy density. It sure is interesting though! So, back to "accelerated expansion": dark energy represents something working against the tendency of matter to gravitatonally collapse. Whether that something is constant or evolves is something we can determine by observation. Whether that something is uniform everywhere outside galaxy clusters or not is also something we can determine by observation. Current evidence is consistent with a constant uniform feature of the action of large scale structures. In particular, while normally gravitating matter is diluting away in the past->future direction we picked out in our cosmological frame of reference, dark energy is not diluting away. If, still staying in the cosmological frame, we switch our spatial coordinates from comoving coordinates on the cosmological frame to spherical Earth-centric coordinates, we have to adjust our understanding a little. A distant galaxy has a lower radial distance at earlier times than at later times. We can identify this with a recession velocity, and use that to explain the cosmological redshift and the presence of various cosmological horizons. But this is a coordinate-dependent explanation. It is perfectly fine to stick with comoving coordinates and resort to other explanations for the cosmological redshift. Indeed, it was that galaxies at extreme distances still look like galaxies that led to the metric expansion of space in the first place: small-angular-diameter galaxy clusters can't really be moving relativistically away from us or they would look VERY different structurally. Additionally, we haven't abandoned Lorentz covariance, so treating matter receding over the horizon as moving superluminally has to be considered a non-physical artifact of a choice of coordinates and frame of reference. And sure enough, just by changing the coordinates alone, these problems disappear. [1] individual galaxies within a cluster have peculiar velocities against the comoving coordinates that the cluster's centre of momentum stays fixed against. Likewise, massive elements within galaxies (e.g. Earth) have peculiar velocities against the comoving coordinates thanks to local gravitational interactions (e.g. Earth orbits the sun). Each of these introduces an anisotropy in the view of the overall distribution of matter in the universe and in the view of the CMB by an observer with a peculiar velocity. Such observers are not strictly comoving ones. But they're generally awfully close to comoving, because they're almost certainly embedded within a larger structure that is comoving.
- oldandtired 9y agoI just enjoy the way you use all these words to say that the theoretical entities exist when experiment has not shown any evidence of their existence. Try to remember that a model is only a model and a theory is only a theory that is one possible explanation of the reality we observe. It is an attempt to get a handle on understanding the universe around us. When you and others go off and start proclaiming the actual existence of these theoretical entities without at least the experimental confirmation of such, then you are setting yourself to be considered in the same light as attendees at the local ufo conventions. It annoys me when theoretical entities are declared as existing when the evidence is only slightly in their direction or the only evidence is that they need to exist based on the current mathematical models being used. When said and done, dark energy and dark matter are mathematical entities required by the prevailing theory. The prevailing theory is only one of a number of possible models. Which one you subscribe to is up to you and your view of how the current evidence stacks up. At this point, none of the models seems to cover enough bases to make it the most likely scenario. So, for me, this is still an open question. The current prevalent model has at it basis, some, from my point of view, untenable inconsistencies. The first and foremost is that gravity (whatever model you might ascribe to) is the majority controlling force. The inconsistency is that model uses gravity to give rise to "Black Holes" and yet has not stopped the "Big Bang" from happening. When you start to play around with reconciling both entities, it becomes a bit of a problem. You then add time dilation effects due to gravity (as per the various models in use) and you get other strange quirks/inconsistencies appearing. The upshot of this is that people should be careful to not declare the actual existence of theoretical entities from incomplete models just based on belief. This just turns the supposed science into religion and religion is considered anathema amongst certain groups within the science communities. The theories and models are supposed to be helpful working explanations that can change or be thrown out based on new evidence. They have a particular usage profile and range of applicability. If you go outside of that usability or applicability range then the theory/model will start to fail. As we were taught in undergraduate engineering all those decades, you use the applicable model/theory for the specific circumstances being investigated.
- raattgift 9y ago