4 ms·
> If anything, it is just going to cause people to sympathise with the Daily Stormer I think that people who are willing to sympathize with neo-Nazis because a
by geofft 9y ago
> If anything, it is just going to cause people to sympathise with the Daily Stormer
I think that people who are willing to sympathize with neo-Nazis because a domain registrar refused to process their registration should be considered as just a subset of "Nazi sympathizers," and their views treated accordingly.
> From having a browse around, the site appears to be basically a joke. It's pretty distasteful but I personally don't think it warrants being taken down.
The site certainly presents itself as a joke to avoid substantive criticism or engagement with the viewpoints it's promoting from detractors. But, say, altright.com takes them seriously, and lists them alongside clearly-not-joking Neo-Nazi organization Identity Evropa:
https://altright.com/2017/08/05/the-unite-the-right-rally-is-going-to-be-a-turning-point-for-white-identity-in-america/ https://altright.com/2017/08/05/the-unite-the-right-rally-is...
The Daily Stormer has been promoting the event heavily and it looks like they are going to bring a lot of young new cadres to the rally. Identity Evropa will be there as well as several Southern Nationalist groups. There will be no Alt-Lite co-rally, it will be just us, the proverbial and literal White Guard out there defending the statue of General Lee. This is a good development. They are quickly becoming irrelevant and losing their street presence as we continue to grow and take up space.
No one knows how many of us will show up there just yet. A conservative estimate would put us at about 500, although if the Daily Stormer book clubs, frog twitter, and affiliated groups come through, we can top 1000.
They mention themselves that 4chan was the place where ironic appreciation of Hitler grew into earnest appreciation of Hitler:
https://dstormer6em3i4km.onion.casa/a-normies-guide-to-the-alt-right/ https://dstormer6em3i4km.onion.casa/a-normies-guide-to-the-a...
Anti-Semitic and racist jokes had been a key feature of /b/, but on /pol/ the sentiments behind the jokes slowly became serious, as people realized they were based on fact. /pol/ became a haven for virulent anti-Semites and aggressive racists, and tone of the Alt-Right is drawn directly from these roots on 4chan.
On 4chan, the Jewish problem was analyzed by news junkies and history buffs, feminism was deconstructred by sexually frustrated young men, and race was considered based on the actual data on the issue. The rehabilitation of Adolf Hitler and the NSDAP largely took place on 4chan.
Anti-Semitic and racist jokes had been a key feature of /b/, but on /pol/ the sentiments behind the jokes slowly became serious, as people realized they were based on fact. /pol/ became a haven for virulent anti-Semites and aggressive racists, and tone of the Alt-Right is drawn directly from these roots on 4chan.
[...] This made promoting the right-wing agenda not only meaningful, but also extremely fun. The Alt-Right carries with it that spirit of fun.
So, sure, maybe they are a distasteful joke. They are also earnestly advocating Hitler's ideology and Nazi ideology by name. The joke is a front, to push the Overton window far enough in their direction that the non-joking version of their ideology becomes tenable.
- jack9 9y ago> I think that people who are willing to sympathize with neo-Nazis because a domain registrar refused to process their registration should be considered as just a subset of "Nazi sympathizers," and their views treated accordingly. And there it is. If you disagree with me, you're a Nazi (subset). Predictable.
- geofft 9y agoI did not say that. I said, if you're sympathize with Nazis, you're a Nazi sympathizer. I think you can perfectly well disagree with Namecheap's decision without being a Nazi sympathizer (let alone a Nazi, which I accused nobody of being other than The Daily Stormer, who claim alignment with NSDAP policy). That is not what I was replying to. I was replying to the specific claim that people will sympathize with Nazis because of Namecheap's action. The only predictable thing here is your strawman response, and even so, I would have hoped we'd have a higher quality of discourse on HN.
- jack9 9y ago> I did not say that. > I said, if you're sympathize with Nazis, you're a Nazi sympathizer. If a human is wounded, I will render aid. This has nothing to do with ideological sympathy. There can be, and are, other motives. Making blanket statements, like you continue to make, are irresponsible, at best. > The only predictable thing here is your strawman response, It's not a strawman to point out your conceptual failings. Good luck with whatever.
- xaa 9y agoI would sympathize with them on this issue. This is actually the second time this week I have been called a Nazi sympathizer essentially for believing everyone, including Nazis, should be able to air their views in such a way that interested people can hear them. (i.e., they don't have the right to spam everyone, but they shouldn't be blacklisted from businesses otherwise open to everyone just because of the content of their speech). Being unironically called a "Nazi sympathizer" is by far the most chilling thing to me that has happened of all the political events that have occurred in the last few years. It is also sad that I have to add a disclaimer that I have voted Democrat in the last decade of elections, am not a bigot, etc, etc, (not that someone using this sort of language would believe me). Do people who say these sorts of things not realize the massive irony of accusing people who defend basic rights of a generally detested group of being "Nazi sympathizers"?