4 ms·
> Why can I dock and undock tabs in my web browser or in my file manager, but I can't dock a tab between the two apps? There is no technical reason why this sho
by jcelerier 9y ago
> Why can I dock and undock tabs in my web browser or in my file manager, but I can't dock a tab between the two apps? There is no technical reason why this shouldn't be possible.
that's absolutely possible on linux with i3wm for instance
> I'd like to pipe my Skype call to a video analysis service while I'm chatting, but I can't really run a video stream through awk or sed.
awk and sed, no, but there are many CLI tools that accept video streams through pipe. e.g. FFMPEG. You wouldn't open your video through a GUI text editor, so why would you through CLI text editors ?
> Window Managers on traditional desktops are not context or content aware, and they are not controlable by other programs.
Sure they are, on linux: https://linux.die.net/man/1/wmctrl https://linux.die.net/man/1/wmctrl
Fifteen years ago people were already controlling their WM through dbus: http://wiki.compiz.org/Plugins/Dbus#Combined_with_xdotool http://wiki.compiz.org/Plugins/Dbus#Combined_with_xdotool
The thing is, no one really cares about this in practice.
- posterboy 9y agoTabbing is not implemented by the wm, as far as I know.
- d4l3k 9y agoAs mentioned i3wm does. https://i3wm.org/docs/modes.png https://i3wm.org/docs/modes.png
- tadfisher 9y agoFluxbox has had WM-level tabbed window groups for ages now: http://fluxbox.org/features/ http://fluxbox.org/features/
- ori_b 9y agoTabbing is not implemented exclusively by the WM, currently -- that's correct. But there exist window managers that handle tabbing. So, it's largely a matter of removing code. Lots of code. And then fixing more code that makes assumptions that it controls the drawing of the tabs. And there's already the Xembed protocol for embedding windows in other windows, so it's technically possible to even move tabs from one application into another, with a coordinating dance. None of the changes that he wants really needs changes to X11 (although, as far as I know, it would be totally impossible under Wayland.) It just needs someone to change applications to support it. I'd be interested to see an attempt.
- posterboy 9y agoI fail to see the use of web tabs in the file explorer. What's the use case?
- jcelerier 9y agoit's very useful for keeping folders pinned without them taking space in your desktop. Just like for terminals, etc.
- posterboy 9y agofolders? we were talking web-content-tabs. Sure many file-browsers (thunar, pcmanfm ...) can tab file-browser views, but I don't see the need for web-tabs in a not-web-browser. Firefox likewise can show folder content for file:///, but not feature complete compared to a file-browser.
- jcelerier 9y agouh ? I'm re-reading all the parent conversation chain and cannot see where there is mention of "web".
- tracker1 9y agoconsidering how easy it is to switch tabs in a browser compared to a buried filesystem window, or multiple windows that are also buried. I can definitely see the use. I'd like to be able to have the file browser and terminal share a window via tabs as well. I'm not sure we'll see it though, as for the most part the applications are developed fairly separately, and almost certainly won't see it in an open operating system working well for even most apps that people use. Short of maybe google releasing a filesystem browser extension and terminal extension, which may be entirely possible.
- kennywinker 9y agoGood luck piping your skype call into ffmpeg
- kbenson 9y agoIf every window had one or more associated files in /dev which corresponded to it's audio and video output, it wouldn't necessarily be that hard. You wouldn't even have to worry about actually having bits there until someone was listening, because the OS knows when someone opens a file, and could send the appropriate message to the window system to start sending the video associated with that window to the pipe as well. There's no reason why a desktop window application could not supply audio and video to, or receive audio and video from, ffmpeg or even a chained command that might just include ffmpeg at some step.
- striking 9y agoI wonder if some sneaky LD_PRELOAD hacks could make this possible.
- jcelerier 9y agoDunno about skype but video4linux exposes devices such as /dev/video0 where you can read / write the raw video stream so...