8 ms·
I don't understand this whole thing. Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. These are not the kind of people I would
by k__ 9y ago
I don't understand this whole thing.
Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included.
These are not the kind of people I would attribute any power to "crowd out" anyone.
To me it seemed that they started doing computer stuff, because no one, including women, wanted to have anything to do with them.
The "cool", way more aggressive, kids wanted to do sales, law, finance, management and stuff.
Computers were new and complicated, a unsafe bet for people who were so good included into society.
- delhanty 9y ago>Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. +1 - that's how I remember it too! I asked the following 12 days ago [0]: >One thing I'd like to ask the women in this forum: >If you'd grown up back in the day before tech was cool and techies were (generally) just nerds with no money, would you have still been interested in tech? >... I didn't get any replies though ... [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14956137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14956137
- purpleostrich 9y agoI just replied. We exist. In my case, I did not get exposed to programming or computers until I was 24 yrs. old, though chance employment.
- naturalgradient 9y agoThis is an aspect that has always been bugging me as well. There is this implied notion that for men, it was ok or even encouraged to be nerdy and spend all their spare time in front of a screen. In my experience, committing to this lifestyle meant being socially crowded out. Some people were unpopular to begin with and sort of found refuge in the computer world out of necessity, some of us accepted being unpopular/uncool because we did not care. One possible explanation, but potentially an offensive one, and only based on personal experience: fewer women were willing to make this sacrifice, at least in school. Interestingly, this was not because boys would be unwelcoming but because other women would judge them harshly for stepping out. On a related anecdote, I frequently observed girls in school downplaying their math abilities in front of their friends - not because men judged them, but because they did not want to stand out in front of their friends. I suppose the interesting question is why they felt this way, and I would not wager to answer it. I just think the theory 'men are not letting women into tech' simply does not hold up in the formative school years. Only very recently (since the social network movie) there has been this glorification of tech in combination with the startup lifestyle.
- threatofrain 9y agoI would argue that boys and girls today still have this attitude, and now Radio Shack has died (and in that context, isn't Raspberry Pi such a blessing?). It's hard to persuade boys and girls that math and science are cool. It's also unfortunate because a lot of parents think that throwing an iPad in front of their kid will make them more technical, when the characters coming over YouTube / Minecraft are just cancer.
- Edmond 9y agoThe "socially awkward" archetype of a computer programmer I think is mostly a western (probably American) cultural artifact. For instance I have worked with a lot of Indian immigrants who are programmers and I don't find the correlation between social awkwardness and the people doing programming. While programming might be appealing to socially awkward western/American men , I don't think one should go from that to concluding that they're the only people innately drawn to it.
- icu 9y agoThe "socially awkward" archetype certainly existed in New Zealand.
- mdorazio 9y agoBut the tech worker gender gap is much higher in the US than it is in India, so isn't this evidence of exactly what the parent comment is implying? US -> computers associated with nerds and social outcasts for a long time, now we have a big gender gap in CS degree holders and tech workers. India -> computers much less stigmatized, now we see a lower gender gap there.
- randomdata 9y agoThe article posted a few days ago suggested that people from places like India are pushed into tech for financial reasons, being one of the few options to escape extreme poverty. Because of that there is also a more equal distribution of men to women. Whereas Americans have far greater choice when it comes to being able to sustain oneself, and thus tech is not a top choice of – well – anyone, except among those 'socially awkward men'. The harsh reality, and one that is difficult to imagine for the small few of us who actually enjoy this kind of thing, is that tech is a highly undesirable career path for most people. Men and women alike.
- gaius 9y agoThe "socially awkward" archetype of a computer programmer I think is mostly a western (probably American) cultural artifact It was around that time in the 80s that "the nerd" or "the geek" became a staple movie character. Computers up 'til then had just been a piece of industrial machinery like a lathe or a microscope. Now they were associated with "losers". Richard Pryor in Superman III. Revenge Of The Nerds. Etc etc. And by and large society was perfectly happy to relegate computing to these losers and shun them. Noone cared about the demographics of these losers, either, it was not "problematic". It's only recently when the geeks have built something that took over the world, that people are saying, hey, I didn't do the work or make the sacrifices but I deserve the rewards. That's where we get "brogrammers" et al.
- lhnz 9y agoThis is how I remember it in the UK, too. Computers were incredibly uncool and only people with zero interest in being cool were willing to invest their time in learning about them. If anything, these people were crowded out from lots of other domains and picked computing because it was the only place which would accept them. Now everybody is trying to turn this around, and imply a conspiracy to "[create] the now-familiar stereotype of the computer programmer as a reclusive, eccentric man". The stereotype wasn't created be a shadowy group of men to exclude women. That is absurd. Why would sexists block women from programming, while letting them into plenty of other more high status jobs? Reclusive, eccentric men have difficulty finding jobs in sales, law, finance and management, and technology is one of the few jobs where they can make a difference.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoThe stereotype wasn't created be a shadowy group of men to exclude women. That is absurd. Why would sexists block women from programming, while letting them into plenty of other more high status jobs? Well, we should be careful with claims like that. Think of the gender of most of the secretaries at all the jobs we've had. And little things, like if you're in a relationship, how often do you do the laundry and dishes? More directly, women really weren't allowed to become the things they wanted to be until the 70's. We like to act like that was so long ago, but that's one grandpa's lifetime. Not even a very old grandpa. I'm not saying it's due to systemic sexism, just that we're talking about a group of people whose very recent ancestors were denied opportunities we take for granted. They must have faced enormous social pressure to conform.
- lhnz 9y agoThat is my point though: as sexism reduced women joined high status industries to take jobs that require high verbal intelligence. They didn't join programming despite it being a high growth industry: why? I'd source this but what I'm discussing is just a Google away and a bunch of studies are never going to convince anybody. Anyway, my point is that the narrative of the article goes against my lived experience. One is allowed to believe their own eyes.
- busemann 9y ago> Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. > These are not the kind of people I would attribute any power to "crowd out" anyone. These are also the reasons the SJWs and other bullies from the regressive left have had such an easy time finding footing in the software development world lately and continue to do so.
- cmiles74 9y agoI don't think it's a stretch to imagine the socially awkward men you've met in the field aging into slightly less socially awkward older men tasked with hiring new developers. When hiring, it seems a small logical jump that they will higher more people like themselves (socially awkward men) and avoid people who differ. It's a pretty commonplace dynamic and an easy trip to fall into. What surprises me is how hard people are resisting recognizing this dynamic, and insisting the current state is somehow the "natural state".
- mmsimanga 9y agoI have not citation but from the recent articles on HN, is the problem not that they are not enough female CS graduates to hire from? The crowding out is happening in high school and college.
- k__ 9y ago"insisting the current state is somehow the "natural state"" This is a strawman, nobody assumes this is natural in any way. The point is, yes we want more women in the field, but the awkward male nerds that are there right now aren't the main problem. Better look at the hiring managers and what society "shows" women every day.
- cmiles74 9y agoDamore's argument was that the current state was because "biology".
- sanxiyn 9y agoNope, the argument was that the current state was caused by both social and biological effect, and that it is harmful to insist that the cause is entirely, or mostly social. Honestly we don't really know how large are contributions from social and biological effect.
- denzil_correa 9y ago> Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. These are not the kind of people I would attribute any power to "crowd out" anyone. The "crowding out" happened in the 1960s. Like the article points out, the stereotypical image of a computer programmer as a "socially awkward man" did not exist before the 60s. The creation of that very image is what led to "crowding out". And now, you are mentioning the same self-fulfilling prophecy.
- rawnlq 9y agoThere was a really interesting nerds vs feminists war on Scott Aaronson's blog a few years ago: > I believe that “the problem of the nerdy heterosexual male” is surely one of the worst social problems today that you can’t even acknowledge as being a problem http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2119 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2119
- rayiner 9y agoFirst, that's not true. https://i.imgur.com/pkZPrOI.png https://i.imgur.com/pkZPrOI.png. CS was a third women in the mid 1980s, dropping to under 20% today. Twenty years ago, the Space Shuttle's software team was quite gender balanced: https://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff https://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff. Second, nerds can do a perfectly effective job pushing women out of the profession without being aggressive or having social power. We do a lot to gender the profession in ways that has little to do with the work. Think about all the references to hiring "cowboy coders" and "code ninjas." We emphasize hiring the lone gunman coder who learned to code in their basements, while the job actually is highly collaborative and team oriented.
- delhanty 9y ago>Think about all the references to hiring "cowboy coders" and "code ninjas." From my memory since the mid 1980s, those references came in somewhat later - about the time tech became cool and there was money to be made. Maybe something about the macho culture of game programming once it reached significant mass?
- k__ 9y agoFor academia/public this may be true, but these jobs were always balanced.
- rhapsodic 9y ago> Second, nerds can do a perfectly effective job pushing women out of the profession without being aggressive or having social power. We do a lot to gender the profession in ways that has little to do with the work. Think about all the references to hiring "cowboy coders" and "code ninjas." We emphasize hiring the lone gunman coder who learned to code in their basements, while the job actually is highly collaborative and team oriented. If the casual use of innocuous phrases such as those are "pushing" women out of the software development profession, then I would conclude that either: a.) women, on average, have fragile psyches and avoid working in rough-and-tumble environments where phrases such as "cowboy coder" (the horror!) are tossed around. They need an environment where speech is tightly controlled so as not to upset them or scare them off, or b.) an overwhelming majority of women tend to not be interested enough in software development as a career to pursue one. I'm going with b.
- botverse 9y ago> Computers were new and complicated, a unsafe bet for people who were so good included into society. That's precisely the main point of the article. The reason why programming was left to women. Then men just took over when it was field tested and proven to be a profitable business. Doesn't matter how awkward those men were, they were still men.
- pron 9y agoA couple of things. 1. Programming didn't start in the 80s or 90s. It started in the 40s-50s, and we've been doing it for seventy years now. When you were (by your own admission) a socially awkward boy interested in PCs, there were 50-year-old professional programmers working in banks, defense, aerospace and other industries whose programming culture was very different, because they didn't have computers at home at all, and all of them were first exposed to computers in college at the earliest. 2. When historians and sociologists say terms like "crowd out", they do not mean there was any conscious intent behind it, let alone ill-intent. They describe social dynamics. Also, since the eighties at least, professional programmers in the industry have had a lot of power -- whether you felt it or not -- as evident by the size and influence of the tech companies where they worked.
- deepnotderp 9y agoI think number two is a very important point. My problem is that the entire media, including this article, is using it with ill intent to paint men as sexist.
- pron 9y agoBut that's the point. The term "sexist" itself, at least in its scholarly meaning, does not imply intent. Sexism is a feature of a social structure where women are granted significantly less power than men. The prevailing hypothesis -- which has a lot of supporting evidence -- is that we are all sexist, men and women alike, merely by virtue of being socialized in a sexist society. When people first discovered microbes and claimed that people were spreading diseases by, say, not washing their hands properly, they did not mean that people were spreading disease intentionally, but it was nevertheless a fact that they were. But to understand why, you had to know about germs (which are invisible to the naked eye, and were only known to those who study the subject), and you had to be proactive in order not to spread diseased.
- deepnotderp 9y agoMinor problem: that's EXACTLY what the media and outrage engine is specifying.
- funion 9y agoThis is just one anecdote, but I'd like to share my personal experience. Fitting in with the typical boys who took computer classes in high school was really difficult and unpleasant. I'd been using computers and writing code longer than anyone there thanks to parental encouragement, but as a girl that didn't matter. Girls in the class got picked on all the time. I got nicknamed "secretary" and singled out every class by the other nerds, getting told to go be a secretary because I could type fast, should input their code for them instead of writing my own, etc etc. People pulled classic bully moves like pulling my chair away when I went to sit down. I felt more bullied by them than I ever did by other kids. In my personal experience, the socially awkward computer boys were actively unwelcoming to girls, and awkwardness did not preclude meanness.
- komarichiii 9y agoThis resonates with my own experience as well. I have been programming since I was 10 in a country where I was the first of my peers whose family got a PC. I got bullied both by the "jocks" and by the "nerds." The jocks bullied me because I was a nerd while the nerds made fun of my ambitions and disparaged my looks. Fun times!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kamaal 9y ago>>Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. Actually this true of any area of work that is kind of relatively new with progress and overall scene changing very rapidly. What you see in Tech, there are plenty of such examples in early Industrial revolution or Renaissance. Most people only want to get in because their either want a job, or they think there is an element of easy money. Its only when the effort vs return equation becomes clear and you realize its way harder than you thought - The 'make it easy for me' chorus grows.