4 ms·
I can tell you that the Thinkpads are better built and far more reliable. Even most Macbook owners I know who've had both will agree. We had 3 newer MBPs and a
by mattmaroon 19y ago
I can tell you that the Thinkpads are better built and far more reliable. Even most Macbook owners I know who've had both will agree. We had 3 newer MBPs and a 1 yr old Lenovo X60 for 6 months in California. It seemed like the Macs were in and out of the shop constantly, experiencing all sorts of weird problems. Like most Apple products, the hardware is of mediocre quality and drastically overpriced, and the service is atrocious.
But you don't buy Apple comps for the hardware. If you like OSX better (and if you're programming, you most likely will) get a Macbook. Even with the troubles we had, our 3 programmers all agreed that they would not have switched back to Windows. We joked that we'd just keep an extra MBP on hand at all times, and honestly it's not such a bad idea.
Either way though I'd never buy a MBP refurb. That's just asking for trouble.
- brk 19y agoNot me. Current crop of Thinkpads I've seen (about 2 dozen or so) have been utter crap. Multiple hard drive failures, cheap construction, flaky as hell. I've used MBP and MB and prefer both over current gen Lenovos.
- mariorz 19y agoYou know there is also this new OS called Linux. Reportedly works great on apple hardware too... And also, yes, many people buy apple machines for the hardware.
- mattmaroon 19y agoIf using Linux, I'd recommend the Lenovo hands down. The hardware is clearly superior and significantly cheaper.
- mariorz 19y agoI'd recommend a macbook for linux, precisely for the superior hardware to price ratio, but many aspects of how you define superiority come down to personal preference I guess. My point only was that lenovo+windows and mac+osx aren't the only choices at all. In fact, I may be mistaken, but I think speedwagon wasn't even considering windows as an option.
- speedwagon 19y agoThat's correct - the first thing I would do with the Thinkpad is install Ubuntu, so it's more of a hardware question for me.
- etal 19y agoIf you're open to different operating systems, and a student, it sounds like you could tolerate a not-so-premium setup if it came to that. I'm guessing you're not really a gamer, and probably not doing extreme graphics or video work. In that case, a Thinkpad or MBP might be overkill. Alternatives: 1. Look for cheaper Linux laptops from Dell or HP. I get the feeling that the laptop as we know it is going to change significantly within the next couple of years, at the very least with solid-state hard drives, so why bother with a top-of-the-line machine right now? And, you'll probably be making a lot more money once you're out of school, so you'll be tempted to splurge then anyway. 2. Get one of these newfangled ultra-portables like the Asus eeePC or Everex Cloudbook. (I've been eying the Cloudbook myself.) If this programming thing becomes a habit for you then you might also develop the habit of collecting computers. In that case you could have a "serious" (but still semi-cheap) desktop computer at home, with a decent-sized display and hard drive, do most of your work on it, and also use it as a server of some sort in your home. The ultra-portable would be for, ya know, laptop stuff. (Disclaimer: I'm laughably frugal, and my company also supplies me with a real laptop -- a Thinkpad R61 -- which I like.)
- Zak 19y agoUnless you plan on replacing your laptop regularly or not taking it places, buying an HP or Dell may not be the most frugal decision. Apples and Thinkpads have metal frames that keep internal components from flexing and breaking solder joints[0]. Dells, HPs and most other cheaper laptops don't. I don't have any hard data for it, but I think laptops with frames last longer. I know several people who's computational needs aren't demanding who are still using iBooks and Thinkpads made in 2000. [0] iBooks seem to break the BGAs on their video chips a lot anyway, but I don't think any new Apples have that problem.
- mattmaroon 19y ago
- vlad 19y agoI disagree. I have the latest Lenovo T61 14 inch widescreen as well as the latest Macbook Pro 15 inch. The Lenovo has crashed about 4 or 5 times over the past few weeks when putting it in or taking it out of its official docking station. The Macbook Pro is incredible. I find the backlit keys and the excellent screen and keyboard are more useful or better than the little light, crappy screen, and good keyboard on the Lenovo. The regular Macbook is actually a terrible choice. Although the built-in motherboard video X3100 chipset can run Half-Life 2 in multiplayer pretty well on Windows, the drivers on the Mac make that video card as useless as the one in laptops from 2 years ago. I don't play video games anymore, but it might help your decision to know that video on the Macbook is already outdated more than any other Core2Duo laptop on the market right now running Windows.
- axod 19y agoSorry, but why would you want to run Half-Life 2? Are you insane? There's work to be done.
- jeremiah 19y agoMatt Maroon's comment is more anecdotal than factual. Apple consistently gets the highest marks in unbiased studies (Consumer Reports) for both the quality of its hardware, customer service and support. To counter his anecdotal view I'll add mine; I also own a number of Macs and while I had problems with my 1400cs I have not had problems with my refurbished PowerBook. In fact, I dropped it from a meter's height and it is still performing admirably.