7 ms·
Exploring How and Why Trees ‘Talk’ to Each Other
- two2two 9y agoIf you're interested in this subject, Peter Wohlleben published a book in 2015 called The Hidden Life of Trees, What They Feel, How They Communicate. One excerpt from the book relevant to this article: "The fungus not only penetrates and envelops the tree's roots, but also allows its web to roam through the surrounding forest floor. In so doing, it extends the reach of the tree's own roots as the web grows out toward other trees. Here, it connects with other trees' fungal partners and roots. And so a network is created, and now it's easy for the trees to exchange vital nutrients and even information--such as an impending insect attack" (51). I look at groups of trees, and trees in general, very differently than I had before I read this book. I'm happy to see this Yale article make it to HN.
- dmix 9y agoDo you know how far from the tree do these network travel? Do the other trees it 'communicates' with have to be right next to it or can they be some distance? As someone who has a passing interest in mycology I find this as much interesting in how important fungi is to the world as are trees. It has many proponents who believe fungi doesn't get enough credit for fueling the world's ecology as plants and trees. Possibly due to mushrooms perception as being harmful to humans. Thanks for the book recommendation (Amazon link https://www.amazon.com/Hidden-Life-Trees-Communicate-Discoveries/dp/1771642483 https://www.amazon.com/Hidden-Life-Trees-Communicate-Discove...).
- gehwartzen 9y agoYeah, I was just thinking how some of our seemingly established forestry principles of thinning out overgrown portions of forests to keep it 'healthy' or engaging in selective logging could be disrupting some of these networks.
- jamesrcole 9y agoFor anyone interested, there's also "What a Plant Knows: a field guide to the senses" by Daniel Chamovitz, which is pretty good. https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0089RO8E0/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0089RO8E0/
- valarauca1 9y agoPrediction: As we start to approach a true AI, I have a feeling a side effect will begin to understand there multiple sentient organisms we simply dismissed due to _some_ standard. Much like how earth retreated from the center of the universe, to just a wet rock orbiting a slightly above average brightness yellow dwarf.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI think time will be a major factor. We probably would have trouble recognizing intelligence that operates on time spans of millions of years.
- ddebernardy 9y agoOne big standard is the ability to recognize oneself in a mirror and, insofar as I'm aware, humans are the only ones who have yet to pass it consistently. (Perhaps a few great apes have done so since.)
- hacker_9 9y agoNo? The 'mirror test' has been passed by a range of animals, including apes, elephants and dolphins.
- seszett 9y agoBut anyway it's obviously meaningless when we're talking about plants. Blind humans cannot recognize themselves in a mirror either, but it doesn't mean anything about their sentience.
- rectangletangle 9y agoIt becomes further confused when animals like dogs are introduced into the equation. They fail the visual mirror test, primarily because vision isn't their primary sense.
- anfractuosity 9y ago
- carapace 9y agoLiving in harmony with Nature-- on a scientific basis --is pretty much the most crucial challenge facing our (global) civilization right now. I was just reading about Muir and his communication with the living Nature around him. This isn't "mystic" mumbo-jumbo: many of the chemicals being used in these tree+fungus networks are also used in our "internal" systems. We speak tree on the chemical level. ------------------------------- I want to report on some events in a backyard here in San Francisco. The western part of the city, from Twin Peaks to the ocean, is mostly built on sand. Before the houses were there it was scrub and beach for more than a mile. The backyard in question consisted of this very sandy soil, with just enough organic matter to bind it a little and turn it tan-brown. Some plants had been set in years earlier, a couple of rose bushes, lilacs, some calla lilies. Grasses and oxalis and some other things were doing their best, but there were patches of bare dirt, and by dirt I mean of course just dirty sand. So I went to the store and got a bunch of bags of organic hummus/mulch and just plastered every open space with it an inch thick. It was rife with mycelium and the fungus lost no time in binding and sealing itself together in a single mass over the sandy soil. Realizing this I made sure to connect all the patches together by thick bands of mulch so the whole yard could communicate. The specific thing I want to mention is this: After a few weeks, maybe less, I was watering a patch of the mycelium mulch one day when I stopped and stuck my finger into the ground to check absorption depth. While the surface was completely wet, even drenched, imagine my astonishment when I found that just under the surface less than a quarter of an inch down it was bone dry. I watered that patch for a solid minute until puddles has formed in every slight depression. Still it was completely dry just under the surface. But the puddles vanished in seconds! I watered it again, just dumping water on it from the hose. A certain amount would puddle up, but the bulk of the water simply vanished. Gallons of water and still the soil was bone dry just below the wetted top layer. I poked around a bit more and found that the mulch had become nearly solid mycelium bound around the little wood chips and other media in it. It had a glossy sheen and was forming a sort of sheet or membrane rather than just strands. The point is: that fungus had sealed the water off from the sandy very-high-drainage dirt underneath and was channeling it somewhere. There is much still to learn about how Nature works.
- etplayer 9y ago> Living in harmony with Nature-- on a scientific basis --is pretty much the most crucial challenge facing our (global) civilization right now. Social anarchist and proponent of ecological anarchism Murray Bookchin has written about the challenges facing our current society and indeed produced by it with regard to the earth's ecology. He writes, >Social ecology is based on the conviction that nearly all of our present ecological problems originate in deep-seated social problems. It follows, from this view, that these ecological problems cannot be understood, let alone solved, without a careful understanding of our existing society and the irrationalities that dominate it. To make this point more concrete: economic, ethnic, cultural, and gender conflicts, among many others, lie at the core of the most serious ecological dislocations we face today—apart, to be sure, from those that are produced by natural catastrophes. Although I haven't started to read anything about his social ecological theories, I have found him to be a good writer even if I do not completely agree with him. I thought you would be interested. There's a bibliography on his Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Bookchin#Selected_bibliography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Bookchin#Selected_bibli...
- maxander 9y agoCarbon- and mineral-sharing between trees makes good game-theoretic sense. Any two neighbouring trees could easily be neighbours for upwards of a century, effecting and relying on the same soil; its an iterated "game" of extreme duration and no option of escape. Cooperation is the overwhelmingly better strategy in those kinds of situations.
- roceasta 9y agoExactly. Whereas cooperation between the trees and the pine beetles won't happen because the beetles migrate.
- thewayfarer 9y agoAbsolutely fascinating work! However, I'm not entirely sold on the usage of the term "mother tree." While Simard says > That’s how we came up with the term “mother tree,” because they’re the biggest, oldest trees, and we know that they can nurture their own kin. the interview doesn't reference any work that specifically states these mother trees will preferentially nurture kin over other species. For example, when she describes the more controlled greenhouse experiment with Douglas firs and Ponderosa pines, an injured mother tree Douglas fir dumped carbon into the network and the ponderosa pines still absorbed it. She may have other work that describes some kind of kin preference, but I don't see it cited and I don't quite understand what the mechanism to make this happen would be. Rather, (as a layman without any knowledge of the work and published papers around this topic), I see this phenomenon not as the result of "mother trees" but from "farmer fungi." The fungi, because of their large networks and relationships with the trees, become "resource managers" of the forest. The fungi have an incentive to make sure that the trees are healthy and will continue to provide nutrients for the fungi. When younger trees are injured, that is a threat to the fungi's survival, and therefore one possibility is that they have evolved this mechanism that transports resources from older trees to the younger ones to help the younger trees survive. The relationship between these fungi and trees are normally symbiotic, but the older trees "tolerate" (or fail to evolve some immune response to) this mildly pathogenic behavior because it likely benefits its nearby offspring or close kin. I think the concept of the "mother tree" might be slightly anthropomorphic, assuming that a large, multi-organ plant must be more intelligent and possibly be even more caring than small fungi that must only be able to perform simple functions. In reality, the fungi are the organisms in the best position to evolve this beneficial behavior. Again, I'm a non-expert with zero knowledge on this topic. If anyone could provide a reference to a free online paper that describes these "mother trees" as preferentially nurturing kin, I could be persuaded. And that would be a very interesting read!
- dmix 9y agoThis was the specific quote from the article: > In later experiments, we’ve been pursuing whether these older trees can recognize kin, whether the seedling that are regenerating around them are of the same kin, whether they’re offspring or not, and whether they can favor those seedlings — and we found that they can. That’s how we came up with the term “mother tree,” because they’re the biggest, oldest trees, and we know that they can nurture their own kin. It seems that Kevin Beiler was the one who did research about this so that may be a good place to start rather than the author. But whenever reading something like this quote below, where it's clearly a useful narrative for funding and public support, I find it's always good to be skeptical about how far that analogy extends: > We’ve got a lot of interest from First Nations groups in British Columbia because this idea of mother trees and the nurturing of new generations very much fits with First Nations’ world view.
- dmix 9y agoI'm curious how much of an effect the forestry industry has on these mycology networks as long as the trees get replanted. After coming across this quote: > In Sweden, scientists studied a spruce that appeared to be about 500 years old. They were surprised to learn that it was growing from a root system that was 9,550 years old. > In Switzerland, construction workers uncovered stumps of trees that didn’t look very old. Scientists examined them and discovered that they belonged to pines that lived 14,000 years ago. Analyzing the rings of their trunks, they learned that the pines that survived a climate that warmed 42°F, and then cooled about the same amount — in a period of just 30 years! This is the equivalent of our worst-case projections today.
- bane 9y agoI think we have to consider using higher levels of abstraction when discussing how organisms so far removed from our neighborhood of the tree of life deal with experiencing the universe. Instead of "talking" - communicating Instead of "feeling" - sensing Instead of "thinking" - processing And so on. We risk anthropomorphizing other living beings we can't possibly relate to. Just as it's important we gain better understanding of how other living things live, it's just as important to not apply how we live to them. At worst we should talk about "analogs" instead of euphemisms. Does a tree feel "pain" or does a tree feel a "pain analog"? The first is ascribing something that may not even make sense, the second grounds us in comparisons and looking for cause and effect analogs. Do trees talk? No, they have no mouths. Do trees communicate? As we understand these things more and more, it appears that there's some kind of analog there. Do trees feel? Maybe that's the wrong question. Do trees respond to stimuli? Of course!
- dredmorbius 9y agoFair suggestion, though "feeling" might be confused with emotional response rather than senses. Perception is the general term in psychology AFAIU (e.g., "perceptual psychology" -- among my more surprisingly fascinating uni courses). But the breakdown is a good one. It also brings to mind the trivium from the mediaeval academic curriculum: grammar, logic, and rhetoric. Grammar is the process of acquiring (and making sense of) information. Logic is the process of interpreting and processing information. Rhetoric is the process of transmitting information. Or: it's an input, logic, output sequence. This can be applied to much of information-systems or information-theory work. Perhaps with the addition of some endogenous or exogenous information storage and retrieval system. As for talking: the deaf speak, with their hands. Symbolic representative abstract communication is just that. I'd argue that the relevant element of talking is the interactivity of the conversation. Take the old Unix "talk" command. It was contrasted to "write", "wall", or "mail", in that both parties could talk at the same time. Myself and my girlfriend, 800 km apart. That in the 1980s was mind-blowing. And much cheaper than long-distance telephony.
- ivanhoe 9y agoDefinitely, although many features of complex organisms (humans included) can also be described as nothing more than sensing and reacting on various stimuli. It all depends on the level of abstraction that you choose to apply, and anthropomorphizing in higher levels of abstraction intuitively helps one understand the process easier. Like calling a computer bus communication protocol "master-slave", which of course doesn't mean we should feel sorry for exploited peripheral devices :)
- daxfohl 9y agoEver since reading the recent HN-highlighted article "Aliens in our midst" re ctenophore brains, https://aeon.co/essays/what-the-ctenophore-says-about-the-evolution-of-intelligence https://aeon.co/essays/what-the-ctenophore-says-about-the-ev..., I've been wondering if something similar happens among plants. This article shows definitely something. I'm interested to see how far it goes.
- frogcoder 9y agohere is her ted talk https://www.ted.com/talks/suzanne_simard_how_trees_talk_to_each_other https://www.ted.com/talks/suzanne_simard_how_trees_talk_to_e...
- bitwize 9y agoInsert Derrick Jensen quote about how the science of the dominant culture has discovered that trees have souls and can talk only now, after it has nearly ruined everything.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI'm starting to lean toward the notion that trees don't have nervous systems, but that forests are nervous systems. A complex, largely chemically-mediated, environmental-response mechanism. Typically operating at rates far slower than those of animal neurology. Trees don't have brains: forests are brains.