3 ms·
>Is anyone here planning on suing FACEBOOK? Who amongst us has the team of lawyers to undergo that? This is for 99.999% of people not a legitimate concern. I d
by dboreham 9y ago
>Is anyone here planning on suing FACEBOOK? Who amongst us has the team of lawyers to undergo that? This is for 99.999% of people not a legitimate concern.
I don't think it is wise to think about this in these narrow terms. Consider the following scenario:
Avoidance of these problematic license terms becomes "a thing" in the industry that moves and shakers, but not the likes of us, are worried about.
You might have aspirations to sell your company to BigCo, or get investment from VCs.
Now we have a concern that use of problematic license code is a poison pill that these investors are not willing to swallow. You aren't considering suing Facebook, but they might think about it.
We saw exactly this with GLP'ed code in the past (I have signed a couple of deals where I had to pledge on a stack of bibles that we did not have any GPL code in our tree).
- chrisco255 9y agoIf they want to go to patent war with Facebook, they're going to have to answer to Facebook's patent portfolio counterclaims, whether they own companies which use React or not. Facebook owns thousands of patents they have bought over the years. Your company or startup should focus on building a great product and attracting users.
- leereeves 9y agoWhat happens if you use RN and one of your "corporate affiliates" sues Facebook?
- CodeWriter23 9y agoOr happen to own a few shares in a BigCorp that decides to sue Facebook over any patent?
- chrisco255 9y agoThe use of RN doesn't necessarily mean you are violating Facebook's patents, whatever they may be. RN is still published with a BSD license. One of your corporate affiliates better know they're starting a patent war and their code base will be analyzed for patent infringement counterclaims by Facebook's attorneys.
- dboreham 9y agoI'm talking about big companies that have O(10x) as many patents as Facebook.
- chrisco255 9y agoA lot of BigCos like that are already using React in their code base. Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Salesforce, to name a few.
- ngsayjoe 9y agoAs a small startup, I absolutely love Facebook's React patent licensing. It gives me the advantage to use React (Native) while my bigger VC-funded competitors can't. It is like the opposite of economy of scale, haha.