4 ms·
We seem to be at the limit of the fastest fastball. http://www.popularmechanics.com/adventure/sports/a6063/how-the-105-mph-fastball-tests-the-limits-of-the-huma
by eesmith 9y ago
We seem to be at the limit of the fastest fastball. http://www.popularmechanics.com/adventure/sports/a6063/how-the-105-mph-fastball-tests-the-limits-of-the-human-body/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/adventure/sports/a6063/how-t...
"However, even if the radar gun used last Friday gave Chapman 5 mph, his pitch still flirted with the maximum speed a human can throw a baseball, which Fleisig says is about 100 mph. Fleisig has found that adjustments to a pitcher's biomechanics, as well as better conditioning of the entire kinetic chain from the legs to the core to the arm, can improve a pitcher's velocity on his fastball. But he's discovered that as the pitcher approaches 100 mph, these tweaks and strengthening have diminishing returns.
"Another cause of the 100-mph ceiling owes to this: the amount of torque needed to throw in excess of the century mark is greater than the amount of force the ulnar collateral ligament (the elbow ligament Strasburg tore) can withstand before giving out, according to tests Fleisig has done on cadavers.
An addition quote from http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/17/sports/baseball/harveys-injury-shows-pitchers-have-a-speed-limit.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/17/sports/baseball/harveys-in... .
"Fleisig, a biomedical engineer, knows what an arm can handle, and years of research give him the confidence to answer one of baseball’s more intriguing questions: Is there a limit to how fast a human being can throw?
"His answer: Yes, there is.
"And, he adds: That limit already has been reached.
"“Oh, there may be an outlier, one exception here or there,” he said. “But for major league baseball pitchers as a group of elites, the top isn’t going to go up anymore. With better conditioning and nutrition and mechanics, more pitchers will be toward that top, throwing at 95 or 100. But the top has topped out.”"
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoHybrid designer babies, splice in the ligament and fast-twitch muscle genes from a Cheetah. This will work until DNA testing becomes part of the standard anti-doping screening.
- eesmith 9y agoSure. And Cordwainer Smith mentions (in The Ballad of Lost C'Mell) that the cat underperson "C'mackintosh had been the first Earth-being to manage a fifty-meter broad-jump under normal gravity." At present what you mention is equally as science fiction as the nanotech predictions of the 1990s. In any case, the author argues that "Athletic performance follows a normal distribution" and "The normal distribution we see in athletic capabilities is a telltale signature of many small additive effects that are all independent from each other." I wanted to give a counter-example. Normal distributions don't have the hard cutoff that we've seen in pitching speeds. Edit: "No other primate throws with anything comparable to human force. Chimpanzees, who are much, much stronger, pound for pound, than human beings, can throw, as any zoo visitor knows. But the best an adult male can do is about 20 miles per hour. A 12-year-old human pitcher can easily throw three times that fast." http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/27/science/evolution-on-the-mound-why-humans-throw-so-well.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/27/science/evolution-on-the-m... The hypothesis is that early humans, "around 1.8 million years ago ... [began] to hunt big game and needed to throw sharp objects hard and fast", or perhaps it was only "hundreds of thousands of years". In either case, it appear that humans have specifically evolved for throwing, with most of the energy coming from the shoulders, not from long or cord-like tendons. Our genetics may already be near the optimal, with respect to single point mutations. Not only might cheetah ligaments and muscles make little difference, they might actually be worse.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt can still be the case that the advantage humans have when throwing works even better if it is combined with different muscle.
- kbenson 9y agoGiven the reasoning for why we are at our limit given a few comments up, that specific combination is unlikely to yield benefits, as the ligaments cannot take any additional strain. Are there better ligaments to be swapped in a well?
- eesmith 9y agoAgain, "Sure!" We simply don't know, and there's no good reason why it can't ever be so. However, will cheetah muscles be better? We don't know. This possibility is strongly in the speculation part at the end of essay. It's science fiction at this time. We might instead have nanomachines which augment the muscles and tendons. Is that more likely to occur first? (To avoid detection, smuggle it into the body through a glass of water, and have it geolocated so it breaks down quickly into normal body waste products.)
- nikofeyn 9y ago> In either case, it appear that humans have specifically evolved for throwing, with most of the energy coming from the shoulders, not from long or cord-like tendons. that's not really true. as someone who can throw a baseball quite fast, you really want relaxed shoulders. tense shoulders are a great way to get injured. from my experience throwing, most of the throwing power is generated from the hips. then it comes up your lats on your back which generates a whipping motion through the shoulder. you want this energy transfer from the hips to the arm to be as smooth as possible, hence loose shoulders. near the end of the throw, the triceps and then forearm engage to complete the whip. other than knowing this from throwing, it's pretty easy to know because these are the muscles that are sore when i haven't thrown in a long while.
- maxerickson 9y ago
- Ultimatt 9y agoFor one thing, genetics doesn't really work this way. Another is that you would need the cardio vascular system of the cheetah, you would need the same sorts of haemoglobin as the cheetah, the same respiratory system as the cheetah, the same sorts of fat and sugar metabolism as the cheetah. Gimping a human out with just one weird thing extracted from another species is never going to work. It's a bit like saying you can take a GPU from a desktop and put it on a Raspberry Pi. Ultimately yes you can, but its so non-trivial to the point you wouldn't bother.
- Someone 9y agoThat is being worked around since 1974. "Tommy John surgery" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulnar_collateral_ligament_reconstruction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulnar_collateral_ligament_reco...) is legal in the MLB. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulnar_collateral_ligament_reconstruction#Misconceptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulnar_collateral_ligament_reco... halfway claims you won't throw faster than before if you get that operation, but I'm not convinced those are objective statements; _if_ this were to make you a faster pitcher, and that became generally known, I would think the MLB would be under pressure to forbid it, and the surgeons making those statements would lose customers willing to pay lots of money for these operations. Also, if the tendon is the factor limiting speed, putting in a stronger one should lead to increase speed)
- philwelch 9y agoTommy John surgery isn't an elective performance-enhancing surgery--it's a treatment for a ligament injury. One surgical procedure that is performance-enhancing, and never gets cracked down on, is LASIK: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/human_nature/2005/04/the_beam_in_your_eye.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/human_natur...
- sliverstorm 9y agoA normal distribution can include the appearance of a hard limit, with a small variance. Someone could very rarely come along with a marginally stronger ligament, and add one or two mph
- Retric 9y agoI think we already select for those people. Remember, F=M*V^2 just from V^2 100 vs 102 mph = 4.04% more force. Except if your adding tissue the Mass now increases because the arm has more weight on it. IMO, a more likely mutation is smaller bones in the arm as they are not really needed. However, genetic changes or say a missing pinky finger are unlikely to show up as the number of pitchers with a real shot at the top is a small subset of humanity. Further, the ball is not going to get lighter so again heavy diminishing returns.
- rxhernandez 9y agoYour force equation is incredibly wrong. The units you listed gives energy. If you're going to pretend to do physics calculations, at least get the basics down. You somehow got lucky because the relevant drag force equation has a v^2 term in it.
- Retric 9y agoEnergy is not the problem. The parent says a "stronger ligament" was a solution which is a question of Force. AKA if the only limit is really the forces acting on that tissue how much stronger must it be. Clearly at some point if you strengthen that part of the system then something else will become the limiting factor.