11 ms·
Bitcoin cash mining profits jump
- int_19h 9y agoSo, is the combined price of BTC and BCH in circulation still more than BTC alone before the fork?
- keypusher 9y agoYes. BTC went up significantly after the fork, and BCH is also climbing.
- jstanley 9y agoSignificantly so. The price of BTC alone is still more than BTC before the fork.
- int_19h 9y agoHow do cryptocurrency adherents explain this? I mean, that value has to come from somewhere. As I recall, when the fork just happened, the explanation was that the price of BCH was largely meaningless, because you couldn't actually withdraw them as cash, either directly or via BTC or other coins. You could only trade within confines of exchanges where they materialized. Did that change since then?
- wyldfire 9y ago> How do cryptocurrency adherents explain this? Speculators be speculatin'. > I mean, that value has to come from somewhere. Demand is constrained: only miners and those who bought BCC since Aug 1 fork have any BCC to sell. Most of us struggle with "hmm how do I recover/import my BTC wallet keys into BCC? Holy crap it's worth how much?!" And finally much of the BCC is semi-orphaned by the fact that they hold pre-fork currency but have no idea that BTC exists.
- wyldfire 9y agos/demand/supply/
- wyldfire 9y agoAs a result of the fork I now have independent currency on both chains? If I think that Bitcoin Cash will ultimately not succeed, I should sell into this P&D, right?
- AgentME 9y agoIf you actually have the private keys to your bitcoin (ie. you have your bitcoin in bitcoin wallet software on your computer such as in the official client or the electrum client), and you had them at the time of the fork (Aug 1), then yes. If you had your bitcoins held by a 3rd party like an exchange, then it's up to them to decide whether they want to support a fork like bitcoin cash at all and credit it to your account.
- somenewacc 9y agoYes.
- pyrrhotech 9y agocorrect. All indicators (miners not switching, 60% Korean volume, 0 dev support, plethora of FUD articles about core) are showing that it's a P&D and now is a great time to sell all your BCH back to BTC.
- echelon 9y agoIs there any chance that Bitcoin Cash becomes the preferred fork of Bitcoin? How likely would that be to happen?
- jstanley 9y agoIt is a possibility, of course, but I don't think it's very likely. Segwit is (finally) about to activate on BTC which means we'll eventually get Lightning Network on mainnet. Segwit is not going to activate on BCH because the BCH proponents are ideologically opposed to Segwit. Additionally, almost no businesses are taking payment in BCH. BCH has to build its ecosystem up from scratch like any other altcoin. I think it has similar chances of "overtaking Bitcoin" as, for example, Litecoin. EDIT: I don't know why the BCH price has gone up so much. It's almost certainly in even more of a bubble than BTC is currently in.
- theprotocol 9y agoSegwit is not necessary for Lightning Network. It's a false dichotomy: on-chain scaling does not preclude off-chain scaling (which is what LN is). Bitcoin with Segwit will prioritize off-chain scaling (hence the 1MB blocksize limit and the current moves to prevent increasing it to 2mb), while Bitcoin Cash wants to enable on-chain scaling as the mainstay; but by no means are they mutually exclusive. The Segwit activation raises new questions and concerns: the agreement to proceed with Segwit was a compromise known as Segwit2x (Segwit + 2mb blocks). Now it appears much of the Core team has no intention of honoring the 2x part (see core software 0.15 changelog: it will block any nodes signaling for segwit2x). Yet the 2x part is locked in - meaning we are currently headed towards a hard fork.
- jstanley 9y ago> Now it appears much of the Core team has no intention of honoring the 2x part It's not a case of "not honouring" the 2x part; no members of the core team were part of the NYA. You can't come up with an agreement and then accuse people who didn't sign it of failing to honour your agreement!
- rasmus1610 9y agoI resisted buying BCH because I just don't think it has the same long term value as BTH like almost any altcoin. Hope I don't regret this decision in 6 months
- trophycase 9y agoTrader here: It's a pump and dump. Don't worry about it
- ericb 9y agoI'm not so sure. There are a lot of people who wanted bitcoin to serve the cash use-case who aren't convinced core will keep bitcoin low-fee and workable as anything other than a settlement layer. Bitcoin cash is closer to the original vision. Signs I'm watching: * Merchant adoption * bitcoin-abc doesn't have any commits in the last 21 days. * Mining has not diversified (yet) so this doesn't appear to have gathered tons of support and it is really centralized. https://cash.coin.dance/blocks https://cash.coin.dance/blocks
- rothbardrand 9y agoThose people are not paying attention, or are paying attention to the wrong people. Bitcoin cash is not closet o the "original vision"... that's a Roger Ver claim which is asinine beyond belief. SegWit literally fixes an issue that Satoshi identified in the white paper... and Lightening Network is literally a nice rebranding and enhancement of the payment channels that Satoshi came up with. Segwit quadruples capacity and lowers fees-- in fact Jihan said in a blog that the segwit fees were "unfair" because they are too low. Who is it you think who wants high fees again? You've been listening to the people who want to take over bitcoin, not the engineers.
- ericb 9y agoI've been listening to both, and I question the motives of both. Members of core have contradicted themselves so often when asked why the block size can't be raised that there must be another agenda. When they claimed a one-line arbitrary constant was impossible to change and then gave conflicting reasons why, they lost credibility. I've only seen this waxy-flexibility of logic when someone can't reveal the real reason behind what they want, or they are purely irrational. Core have not been good stewards. Even in the unlikely event they were "correct," the mismanagement of the community, censorship, inability to communicate or build consensus has been atrocious. In terms of original vision, Satoshi pretty clearly described layer 1 scaling. source: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=287.msg8810#msg8810 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=287.msg8810#msg8810 -------- It would be nice to keep the blk.dat files small as long as we can. The eventual solution will be to not care how big it gets. But for now, while it's still small, it's nice to keep it small so new users can get going faster. When I eventually implement client-only mode, that won't matter much anymore. There's more work to do on transaction fees. In the event of a flood, you would still be able to jump the queue and get your transactions into the next block by paying a 0.01 transaction fee. However, I haven't had time yet to add that option to the UI. Scale or not, the test network will react in the same ways, but with much less wasted bandwidth and annoyance.
- hans0l074 9y agoN00b/ELI5/Ask HN question : Where is all this money coming from?
- rastapasta 9y agoFrom people who are willing to exchange 'real'-money backed numbers ('fiat') with might-have-some-worth-soon numbers.
- rocqua 9y agoNot all the quoted money is actually there. The only real money being spend are the transactions on the exchanges. There, it becomes hard to differentiate many 'real' buys of bitcoin cash from someone just flipping back and forth between the two.
- eswat 9y agoOther than Bitcoin Core most of the popular alt coins have come down in price during this rally so many traders are just exchanging one cryptocurrency for another.
- Animats 9y agoThe next regular difficulty adjustment took weeks to reach after the mining power decreased. It was hours between blocks for a while. Now new blocks are mined every 10 minutes again, which makes mining cost-effective again and allows transactions to go through. With a lower difficulty and a $800+ price, Bitcoin Cash mining looks good right now. The "market cap" for BCH has to be way overestimated. It assumes there's a BCH for every BTC. But there isn't. Not everybody got their converted asset out.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoJust trade it with that in mind. Bad news for commodities typically means a constriction in the supply with the same amount of demand. Price goes up, just like with oil or orange juice prices. People thinking about bitcoin like a company's stock or the stock market contribute to why they can't comprehend the train wreck to all time high prices. Hopefully there will be good ways to go bearish by the time Coinbase enables Bitcoin Cash.
- danmaz74 9y ago> Hopefully there will be good ways to go bearish by the time Coinbase enables Bitcoin Cash. You can short it on Bitfinex...
- ringaroundthetx 9y agothey will have finished booting out all of the US users by the time Coinbase enables BCH trading.
- prostoalex 9y agoIt's a good step forward, but mature financial instruments like stocks have option contracts, which also allow expressing negative sentiments. Short sellers are vilified by company management, but they do introduce financial discipline and focus on the book value vs perceived value.
- richardw 9y ago
- bdcravens 9y agoWorth noting that in the past 18 hours it has dropped about 25% from its recent high.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lawn 9y agoNote that Bitcoin Cash will have a difficulty reduction at block 479808 (in 62 blocks as of this writing) projected around 30% further increasing the profitability vs Bitcoin [1]. It is now 52% more profitable to mine Bitcoin Cash [2]. [1]: http://bitcointicker.co/bccnetworkstats/ http://bitcointicker.co/bccnetworkstats/ [2]: https://cash.coin.dance/blocks https://cash.coin.dance/blocks
- cesarb 9y agoThere's a twist to this profitability statistic, which I haven't seen mentioned anywhere yet: your reward for mining a block can be spent only after many other blocks are mined on top of your block. That changes the game significantly. What matters for a miner is not "it's more profitable with the current difficulty and price", but instead "it's more profitable with the current difficulty and the price X blocks in the future". Moreover, once they've mined a block on one chain, it's in their interest to keep that chain alive and working well for at least X blocks, so they can convert enough of their reward into fiat to pay their costs. The obvious way to do it would be to keep mining on the same chain, which generates yet more block rewards to be claimed later. All that might make the chain choice somewhat sticky for the miner: once on one chain, it's better to keep on the same chain instead of switching every time the price swings.
- rothbardrand 9y agoBCH is a hastily written hack job by a third rate team (I talked to some of them on twitter, they really don't understand a lot of what they are doing)... with a drastic difficulty retargeting algorithm. A bit of a pump combined with hash power manipulations lead to this. This is all show to try and prop up the coin. Both the pump and the "profitability" of mining it. %98 of the blocks of this coin are mined by an unknown entity-- in other words, it's not decentralized. It's trivial for that entity to manipulate the difficulty retargeting mechanism in his favor. Stay away. This is not "bitcoin" in any sense.
- davidgerard 9y agoThis is all true, but none of it has ever affected interest in a cryptocurrency. BTW, not even the one actual use case for bitcoin is interested in bcash: https://www.reddit.com/r/DarkNetMarkets/comments/6s30ss/have_any_darknet_markets_announced_support_for/ https://www.reddit.com/r/DarkNetMarkets/comments/6s30ss/have...
- matthewbauer 9y agoI wonder if "forking" Bitcoin will become the default method for new coins to be created in the future. It seems like it has advantages, you can pretty much "prove" that you have not premined your coin (although implementation of the fork still would be very important).
- icedchai 9y agoSadly, I exchanged my BCH for BTC before this occurred. I missed out on those 2x gains! (Of course, these are all coins I mined years ago, so it's free money anyway.)
- richardw 9y agoIt seems the split created value. The derivative is worth what the original was worth not that long ago. Great in the short term but possibly means the combined value is less trustworthy. Derivatives of magic money I guess. So what's to stop continued splitting until the public figures it out and then we all crash?