3 ms·
I'm all for decentralized communication but I don't think the example of the article is particularly convincing and I wonder if the article is asking the right
by xg15 9y ago
I'm all for decentralized communication but I don't think the example of the article is particularly convincing and I wonder if the article is asking the right questions.
So the uncomfortable reason why Mastodon is so popular in japan is that Pixif operates a large Mastodon node which is used to share/discuss questionable images.
Discussions about lolicon aside, does any of this actually has something to do with the detail that Mastodon supports federation?
The article states that decentralisation is important to allow different rules for different communities. However if, e.g. if Pixif disabled federation or switched from Mastodon to something proprietary, would that change anything? Similarly, Reddit is highly centralized technically but - currently - provides freedom for each subreddit to define their own moderation rules (within the restrictions of Reddit, the company).
I feel there is a difference between the "decentralisation" when talking on the social or the technical layer and that difference should be kept in mind.
- glenstein 9y agoYou answered your own question re: the connection between the problem identified in article and Mastodon's structure. A major premise of the article is that Mastodon solved usability issues common to decentralized platforms, and provided a functional space for Pixif's content that wasn't possible with Twitter's rules. I say this as someone who really wants Mastodon to succeed, and hopes for the emergence of mastodon-esque alternatives to Facebook and reddit. A problem with decentralization is that it tests the limits of our tolerance for noxious content. (If you don't think Lolicon qualifies, substitute whatever counts for you as noxious.)
- salmonellaeater 9y agoReddit cannot allow lolicon or Nazi imagery because it's illegal in some countries, and the company would risk fines by allowing it. Mastodon has no such problem as long as the server is in a country that allows the content. Mastodon also avoids the problem some Youtube creators are facing with demonetization. If a video is controversial, Youtube may decide not to show ads on it at all (nor pay the creator) because some advertisers don't want to be associated with the content. I don't know if any Mastodon servers use advertising at all, but if they did they could be more fine-grained in matching content to advertisers. A similarly federated video-sharing network could serve controversial video creators.