3 ms·
If marking something as a dupe would transfer points to the duped thread I would agree. I would also agree if it was marked as a dupe within a reasonable amount
by wongarsu 9y ago
If marking something as a dupe would transfer points to the duped thread I would agree. I would also agree if it was marked as a dupe within a reasonable amount of time. But marking a popular, 12 hour old thread as a dupe of a marginally older, unpopular thread and giving it the ranking of the unpopular thread feels wrong and doesn't respect the intent the community has expressed by voting.
- philbarr 9y agoThis seems a reasonable argument, and I think the mods should adopt your idea of transferring the points to the duped thread (and possibly the comments?)
- walterbell 9y agoAnd the post ranking!
- loceng 9y agoI assume points being transferred would cover the post ranking.
- walterbell 9y agoThe ranking is based on arrival rate of points, ratio of comments, total points, and other factors including manual moderator boost or demotion.