6 ms·
I've been waiting for the inevitable rhetorical attack that Silicon Valley's slowly-but-surely increasing crackdown on everything that happens to offend SV is i
by jerf 9y ago
I've been waiting for the inevitable rhetorical attack that Silicon Valley's slowly-but-surely increasing crackdown on everything that happens to offend SV is itself a form of cultural imperialism. Without endorsing or rejecting that argument myself, I think it's inevitable that we're going to start hearing it soon. As the aspirations of SV grow ever more global more conflict of this sort is inevitable. By that I mean that I don't even blame SV culture itself necessarily, because the details of what SV culture is doesn't matter, there is no culture that could run a centralized global social network without these sorts of problems becoming ever-larger, the only difference is where the flash points would be.
- kuschku 9y agoOh, it has already started, and it has even lead to new laws targeting SV companies in Germany. > Why can facebook ban completely legal nude images within of minutes, but don’t even respond to requests from the police or even courts to ban a post promoting the Nazi party and suggesting genocide?
- pjc50 9y agoTwitter interestingly has an is_nazi flag in their API in response to the illegality of Nazi symbols: https://twitter.com/antumbral/status/876843545100824576?lang=en https://twitter.com/antumbral/status/876843545100824576?lang...
- realsimulacrum 9y agoIt also probably covers any video with music thanks to GEMA.
- mynewtb 9y agoThat tweet only shows a withheld_in_countries list to me. Can you maybe link to an actual example of said flag?
- userbinator 9y agoFacebook is in a difficult position, but I would bet that free speech laws (which they don't necessarily have to abide by, but would still want to be mindful of) and general public perception of nudity in US had a lot to do with that contrast. Germany is a particularly sensitive case with respect to Nazis, but from experience and those of others, European countries in general also tend to be far more accepting of nudity.
- forgottenpass 9y agoI'm eagerly awaiting that backlash. I complain but I'm probably 95% in agreement with the status quo. But I still want the push back. There's a line I like "Hegemony means never having to admit you have an agenda."
- coldtea 9y ago>I've been waiting for the inevitable rhetorical attack that Silicon Valley's slowly-but-surely increasing crackdown on everything that happens to offend SV is itself a form of cultural imperialism. Without endorsing or rejecting that argument myself, I think it's inevitable that we're going to start hearing it soon. As a non-American, I endorse the argument myself. The US has a quite particular culture, and yet most of its population (from all my experience) seems to consider it either (a) the pinnacle of human culture that others countries should/do aspire, or (b) the natural state of civilization (what things just "are", with everything else being inconceivable). Add to that the geopolitical force and might of the country, and the fact that its companies control most of the internet infrastructure, and it gets troubling that a country with very specific interests that it pursuits globally, and where Janet Jackson showing some tit was considered a major cultural "thing" the media and people wrote about for weeks, gets to decide such policies. >* there is no culture that could run a centralized global social network without these sorts of problems becoming ever-larger, the only difference is where the flash points would be.* Well, the EU for one has a much broader range of cultures within nation member states, and a much broader cultural and historical and geopolitical perspective.
- jerf 9y ago"Well, the EU for one has a much broader range of cultures within nation member states, and a much broader cultural and historical and geopolitical perspective." I would say that, exactly as you phrased it, that's multiple cultures. "The EU" can't run a "Facebook", it would be "The French" or "The Polish" or something like that. The EU is definitely in a place where increasing the amount that one of the dominant cultures imposes on the rest decreases the ability of the EU to function. (I'm talking first derivative here, which as you may recall eliminates the original value; I'll leave it to the reader to decide how far the EU is or is not already down that road.)
- coldtea 9y ago>I would say that, exactly as you phrased it, that's multiple cultures. "The EU" can't run a "Facebook", it would be "The French" or "The Polish" or something like that. It would have a base country where its HQ are yes. But it would still have employees from multiple EU countries, and operate within EU's laws, guidelines and cultural frameworks -- giving it a much wider perspective than 10.000 Americans (+ some wannabe Americans that came there to study/work) in a building in San Francisco.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIMO, the cultural imperialism started at home - tech's founding nerd culture has been colonized by a pernicious form of identity politics.
- praisewhitey 9y agoIsn't "nerd culture" already a form of identity politics?
- tnone 9y agoNot necessarily. Identity politics is when issues get defacto interpreted through the lens of social identities, even if that identity is irrelevant or even meaningless for the matter at hand. Observing that there is such a thing as nerd culture does not really qualify. It typifies a particular set of practices and norms that set it apart from more mainstream sensibilities.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoBeing a nerd hasn't been politicized anywhere near as much as being a woman, being an ethnic minority, or being LGBT. Furthermore, there's active efforts to shut down "problematic" parts of nerd culture. The recent Google fiasco with James Damore is a highly relevant example - creating a safe space for dispassionate debate about controversial ideas is the number one reason why I like nerd culture.
- lordCarbonFiber 9y agoLol what nerd culture do you participate in. It's "dispassionate debate" until an outsider tries to participate and then it's fire and brimstone. So long as ideas "follow the narrative" (regardless on how grounded in evidence or just made up) nerd culture will accept you. Otherwise, it's probably the most toxic and politicized groups around.
- mcphage 9y agoCertainly nerd culture isn't famous for an endless litany of flame wars. Emacs vs vim, that's pro-wrestling, right?
- saurik 9y ago... which is exactly why something like Mastadon is important: the entire concept of a centralized global social network with one party in control of content moderation makes absolutely no sense; I don't see how this issue is "rhetorical". It happens to be that America is "puritan": that's not false and is a problem; and if it had been some other country with some other issue, then the comment would have been exactly as valid.