4 ms·
I mean, you could apply that same rationale to anyone, particularly anyone Japanese, who finds lolicon acceptable, since both points of view are culturally subj
by krapp 9y ago
I mean, you could apply that same rationale to anyone, particularly anyone Japanese, who finds lolicon acceptable, since both points of view are culturally subjective, but then the swipe against American prudishness would just seem petty and arbitrary.
- coldtea 9y agoYes, but those are minding their own business in Japan -- they don't go out calling this or that "unacceptable" or "uncomfortable" in foreign countries -- like the article does. But I'd take it one step further: I don't find all global cultures equally OK. I find some backwards in some areas, and I think Japan's idea of what's OK is superior here. Like I find e.g. nordic ideas about prison and EU ideas about the death penalty superior as well, but US ideas about free speech better.
- ue_ 9y agoI don't know how true it is, but I read that the government of Japan conducted a study which showed that most people are not in favour of the material, and would support legislation against it. The number was around 80%. I'd appreciate if someone could find this source again, though I'm afraid I have lost it. I've a very vocal opponent online about legislation against drawings that people find distasteful. I do not enjoy the material myself, but I think it is absurd and indeed without rational jutsification that countries such as Canada, the UK, Australia, NZ and some states in the US have legislation banning such material. I see no reason for the material to be illegalised. In the countries I have listed, the material is illegal to possess, nevermind sell or trade or upload online. Is it a symbol of puritanical values? I don't know, but it certainly seems an infringement of the liberal values expounded by J.S Mill which I would rather adhere to (with small exceptions).
- Laforet 9y ago>Is it a symbol of puritanical values? It fills the void of moral panic previously occupied by transvestites, homosexuals, adulterers, divorcees and witches (in that order). Give it enough time and the society will find the next deviant behavior to raise their collective pitchfork.
- devwastaken 9y agoAre you saying that just because its a distant culture, and they're not calling 'us' out, (though all cultures do that to each other), its 'OK'? I can understand differences in culture that can be real annoying, or feel wrong, but the actual product is perfectly good. Here, we're talking about lolicon, and Japans obsession with it that has become more and more normalized. The argument usually is that its not real, which, is true, and I'd argue that if its not real, to leave it in a gray area. But, when you normalize something that in reality is always illigal, there's a big problem. I'm talking about normalizing as in, commonly broadcasted shows have no problem with sexualization of children and making it seem romantic realtionships with middle schoolers and adults is 'cute' and normal. There's a really NSFW talk about this from demolitionD that I mostly agree with: https://youtu.be/Owa5KcQ9Mxc https://youtu.be/Owa5KcQ9Mxc Now, I don't agree with this video on that an innate attraction makes you a bad person, or a pedophile, I do agree that normalization of such things into the mainstream inevitably leads to real-life action and lack of enforcement when said terrible actions happen.
- ue_ 9y ago>Here, we're talking about lolicon, and Japans obsession with it that has become more and more normalized. Is "Japan" obsessed with it, or just a subculture native to that country (i.e otaku)? >The argument usually is that its not real, which, is true, and I'd argue that if its not real, to leave it in a gray area. Why? Films/books/comics/stories/etc. depicting drug use, murder, rape etc. are indeed "not real", yet few would have a problem with this. It seems to me that we are returning to the age when violent video games are considered "gray area", which is how the stone starts rolling towards their unreasonable and evidence-lacking censorship. >But, when you normalize something that in reality is always illigal, there's a big problem. Is there any evidence that this is a big problem in this instance? And further, what of other instances such as the ones I have outlined? >making it seem romantic realtionships with middle schoolers and adults is 'cute' and normal. Many people do find them cute. Not I, but people do. This does not mean that they are persuaded to act upon that cuteness. Being portrayed as normal in fiction makes no reference to how normal it is considered in real life. I can assure you that most Japanese know that such relationships are not normal, just as I know that what happens in the Simpsons isn't normal. Where's your evidence for this? I watched this video a while ago. It mainly applies to TV and media which is widely circulated. However it is possible to have the material legal for purposes aside from distribution such as on TV. Currently in the UK and other countries, especially Canada, we are at the situation where mere possession is illegal. >nevitably leads to real-life action and lack of enforcement when said terrible actions happen. Does it? There is evidence I have seen that is contrary to this hypothesis, here's one: http://openjournals.maastrichtuniversity.nl/Marble/article/viewFile/374/317 http://openjournals.maastrichtuniversity.nl/Marble/article/v... There are others, but my current Google-fu is failing me, so my apologies.
- krapp 9y agoThe author seems to go out of their way to point out the cultural relativism between his own views and Japan, and differentiates between lolicon and child porn. I see no problem with him finding lolicon personally uncomfortable, or with the premise that Americans in general might find it unacceptable, because they very well might. I don't see him condemning it outright. The article, however, is written in defense of distributed platforms like Mastodon as a way to enable free expression, as well as an attempt to raise the question of how to increase mainstream adoption of tools like it when those tools are primarily known for hosting controversial content. I don't believe the author or the article are as Puritanical as you make them out to be.
- mcguire 9y agoSo your preferences are the standard by which all should be judged?