6 ms·
There is never an absolute and total freedom of speech. That is, there is always speech of the kind than a society cannot and must not tolerate. Either a count
by alkonaut 9y ago
There is never an absolute and total freedom of speech. That is, there is always speech of the kind than a society cannot and must not tolerate.
Either a country accepts this within its legal framework and has e.g hate speech laws (e.g Germany) or it doesn't (e.g US), but in the latter case as being "outside" the law - and it must be met with force outside the law.
There are benefits and drawbacks to both models (which is why both exist). But at the end of the day there is little practical difference between "if you carry a nazi flag you'll go to jail" and "if you carry a nazi flag you'll be punched in the face".
In both cases open society is judging and delivering the sentence.
The notion that all speech must be accepted and never met with violent protest is both unrealistic and dangerous.
So to get back on topic: 1st amendment protects the open society but doesn't function without an open society. Violent protestors at rallies and tech companies gagging fascists is what it needs, and not a problem.
- renlo 9y agoThe thought that words or ideas should be met with violence concerns me. You're not going to end hate speech by attacking people, however wrong they may be. Google and Apple don't even need to adhere to the first amendment so I'm not sure why you conflated this with "hate speech should be met with violence", which would only cause more fighting and more violence (I doubt a Nazi would take a punch to the face without trying to throw his own punches, resulting in straight out combat between people with very strong notions of 'us' and 'them')
- alkonaut 9y agoWhat I meant was that everyone who values tolerance should defend it with the means they have available. A web host should deny hosting, an employer denies employment and a citizen denies use of public space for speaking hate and intolerance. What is necessary to deny this (whether it's enough to bring a vuvuzela) will vary. Punching nazis won't convert them, so it's probably counter productive - but disturb their rally and there is a risk you'll be attacked. No need to throw the first punch, ever.
- Agustus 9y agoWho judges the intolerant? What intolerance gets you lumped into those you profess to want to starve to death by denying employment or means to a wage? Easy to put supremacists in, but then if a person makes a comment at Evergreen, they are now in the racist group and can now be destroyed.
- alkonaut 9y ago> Who judges the intolerant? You mean who decides what is intolerant enough, and what isn't? That's a judgment everyone must make. A difficult one. One with lots of room for mistakes and arbitrary decisions. Yet the lesser evil.
- kstrauser 9y agoI 100% agree with you in principle, but I honestly never thought we'd be having this debate in 2017 about people carrying swastika flags and calling themselves Nazis. Frankly, that changes the entire equation for me. We cannot, cannot, cannot allow this to take root and grow. Everything thinks "it can't happen here", but it doesn't not-happen on its own. I don't want my grandkids asking "how did you try to stop them?", and having to answer "well, I very adamantly told them they were wrong but they didn't listen." I am incredibly tolerant of diverse idea. I grew up in the buckle of the Bible Belt, and now I live in the bluest of blue places. I have wonderful lifelong friends in both places (and lots of others) who I love as people but whose opinions infuriate me. That's OK! We talk about stuff and occasionally ruffle each other's feathers, but we get along just fine. I can argue both sides of gun control, abortion, and anarchism with clever friends for the fun of it. But what I can't tolerate is people in my America wearing, carrying, and acting out Nazi symbols in my backyard. That cannot be allowed to find fertile soil. I've said this before but I want to be perfectly clear: I have an exceedingly tight definition of that term. I have never called someone that word because I disagree with them, no matter how important the matter to me or how ferociously I oppose their opinion. I'm referring specifically to people who show up at white power protests wearing the uniforms, carrying the flags, and throwing the salutes of the group my family fought to stop within my mom's lifetime. That's not a slippery slope. It's perfectly possible - and reasonable, and good - to say "we'll allow people to speak abhorrent opinions" and still draw the line at literal Nazis.
- throwaway0255 9y ago> Either a country accepts this within its legal framework and has e.g hate speech laws (e.g Germany) or it doesn't (e.g US), but in the latter case as being "outside" the law - and it must be met with force outside the law. Or it could, you know, not be met with force outside the law, because we live in a civil society where people are free to think independently and express themselves, and we have laws against assaulting people. Call me crazy. I don't know when in my lifetime liberals pulled this 180 on freedom of speech, but seriously, it's causing me to do the hardest 180 of MY life right the fuck into being a conservative after spending the first 30 years of my life as a liberal. What you just wrote is one of the craziest things I've ever read. You're directly calling for and praising violence against people based on their ideas and beliefs and how they choose to non-violently express them. Just 10 years ago you'd be booed by every liberal in the nation and rightfully regarded as an anti-intellectual, a book burner, or a fascist. My whole life, liberals were so proud to declare that they defend their opposition's right to speech even though they don't agree with it. When did this change?
- Broken_Hippo 9y ago"When did this change?" When we grew up and realized that no, people really shouldn't be marching the street calling for genocide or calling for other groups to be treated as animals. When we realized it is bad to harass others, by surrounding them with torches and yelling racist slurs or by burning freaking crosses in someone else's yard. When we realized that we don't actually want to spread hate and convince others to think the same. This won't stop folks from thinking this or spreading it to some extent, but there isn't a reason we have to give them space in the public sphere, with marches on public roads obviously meant for everybody, regardless of background. Nor does an employer have any need to respect the right of their employee to spread hate, a web hosting service to host the websites, and other such things. Another thing we've realized as we've grown up is that one cannot both protect freedom of speech like this and have any true means of actually overcoming it. This puts actual goals like equality and a more fair society at risk. And above all, it changed when folks re-thought "Fuck Nazis and Fight them". Of course, this is all just speaking from the top of my head and nothing in here is known fact without someone factchecking it, as I have not.
- ivanhoe 9y agoI disagree, there are some huge practical differences actually. When government gets to decide what political views are not acceptable it results in: * Potential abuse of this power by (elements of) the government to silence the opposition or hides mistakes; * Police, army and secret services in time get very close ties with extremists, like it happened in Germany and many other European countries; * Censorship is done by bureaucracy, and bureaucracy always tends to blindly apply the rules. There are many examples of how this is bad and dysfunctional (e.g. when Uncle Tom's Cabin book was banned for racism); * These bans are really easy to circumvent, as can be seen all across Europe; * By forcing extremists to hide their most notorious symbols, you actually make them less horrible and more acceptable to the general public, and it actually helps them to move into a mainstream and spread their ideas. Alt-right is much more dangerous than bat-shit crazy right, because (as we've seen in US recently) it will get traction much easier. * You can ban nazi symbols, but it will not change a single idea in anyones head, these people will still believe in the same things as they do now. * equally important: you create a bubble where bad things are boiling in the underground, but general public is not aware of this. Having nazis or KKK freely marching around is a reminder to the rest of people that this threat exists and that things are far from ideal for minorities. If it's the government's job to take care of this then people will leave it to the government, they'll not feel it's up to them to take active part in it. * and the last, but also important: these people are citizens, with the same rights as anyone else. And with the need to be heard as anyone else. By silencing them you will push some of them into even more crazy extremism and you will give the whole movement the aura of the forbidden fruit, mystery and secrecy and that will make it more attractive to many, especially to teenagers. On the other hand, by letting them march around from time to time you channel that negative energy, they can't complain about being mistreated, and you keep them at bay and their influence marginal.
- hyperdunc 9y agoAll very good points, thank you.
- hyperdunc 9y agoA violent reaction to speech you hate is unnecessary and corrupting. Only countering with persuasion based on reason and facts will stop the abyss from staring back into you.
- alkonaut 9y agoThe "paradox of tolerance": solution draw a limit for what is met with reason and what isn't. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- hyperdunc 9y agoDue in large part to identity politics and multiculturalism, there's no social consensus on what that limit is.