4 ms·
I have to wonder... I've seen the inside of a court room a few times, it's really not my favourite past time. Maybe civil is more fun than criminal. What I'm
by TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago
I have to wonder...
I've seen the inside of a court room a few times, it's really not my favourite past time. Maybe civil is more fun than criminal.
What I'm getting at is, wouldn't you rather go skiing, or hiking, or hanging out with friends or family. Or whatever your thing is.
Wouldn't you, at some point, just think "righteo, this ain't that fun, let's just agree to something already"? Or do these things take on a life of their own and sweep you away with them? Or are people really just that keen to prove how right they are?
Do you think anyone, on their death bed thinks "I wish I'd spent more time sueing the pants off everyone."
- ganoushoreilly 9y agoIt's about proving a point, standing firm on that point (even if you're eventually proven wrong) then doubling down. Most civil individuals would have reached a mediation point. This case also seems pretty personal and despite what most would think, i'm of the camp that thinks emotions are driving a lot of it.
- joelrunyon 9y agoEmotions + a few billion dollars or so.
- trustfundbaby 9y agoWhen you're talking about millions and billions of dollars at stake, sure people think what you typed above first ... then they go "nah ... fuck that. I'm suing".
- omot 9y agoI think it's more of a sunk cost thing. Like gosh I've spent the last 8 waking years to get to this place. I'm not letting these investors screw me over. Even if he goes skiing or hiking, or hanging out with friends or family its going to gnaw at him for the rest of his life.
- icantdrive55 9y agoI know a Veterinarian that lost his license. I honestly believe do to lies. He spent 2.7 million on lawyers. He now just is mad at the Lawyers, and is sleeping behind his former veterinarian hospital. He is practically homeless. Travis has a lot of his personality out on the internet. Actually, it should be a warning for all of us. I will never forget him shimmying around in that Uber Black arguing with a guy who went bankrupt. I just thought he wasn't meant to have power, and money. And I know he was lonely for females he thought he deserved. Oh yea, those women were there just for the money. My point is good luck finding a sympathetic jury. I'd rather have him go off, and start something else, maybe a dating site? He doesn't seem like the charitable type.
- clairity 9y agoi get what your saying, but want to add some precision: 1) using the term "sunk cost" is not quite correct here - sunk cost implies that the future value doesn't justify continued investment. in this case, it's likely that further investment (in time and cost of this court case) results in billions of dollars in value to one or both of the litigants. it's in fact very rational to pursue this litigation because there is real monetary gain at stake (and not simply the face-saving variety). 2) there's a fairness issue at play: "i did the work so i should get the reward.", or "i provided the money, so i should get the reward." you have to balance these two impulses fairly, not just for this case, but for future iterations of the game (in the game theory sense). for future iterations, it is "worth" applying a punishment now (in the form of an expensive court case) so that future rewards are meted out fairly as well.
- kevinpet 9y agoIf we're going to have pedantry, lets make sure we have correct pedantry. "sunk cost" just means that a cost has been paid, and it's non-recoverable. When it comes up, it's usually to point out that only the future cost and benefits matter when making a decision.
- clairity 9y agonot seeing the disagreement... what's at odds here?
- nthcolumn 9y agoI'm sure all the board members have sued and been sued many times. It's just work. I've worked with people, it was a fact of life, they prepared for it, they built war chests, CYA in contracts just ambiguous enough with arcane clauses, weird stuff, it was as important as the regular projects, sometimes the contract wasn't the objective.
- DonHopkins 9y agoAnd if the "CYA Clause" doesn't protect you from getting fucked up the ass, you should always have a "Reach-Around Clause" so at least you get some attention while it's happening.
- bitJericho 9y agoThe courts are so messed up, you're talking about one half day of court time every six months during ongoing litigation.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoWho is this pointed at? Benchmark or Travis? They have completely different motivations for why they are fighting this fight.
- rayiner 9y agoThere is real money on the line here. Kalanick is being accused of fraud, and Benchmark is trying to expand its control of Uber. You don't really just say "oh, I'll let people call me a fraud and destroy my credibility and take away my company and go skiing instead."
- pmorici 9y ago> Wouldn't you, at some point, just think "righteo, this ain't that fun, let's just agree to something already"? That is what the opposition is hoping you do. Seems to me that a large number of legal cases amount to little more than a siege. First party to cry uncle loses.
- CamperBob2 9y agoWhat I'm getting at is, wouldn't you rather go skiing, or hiking, or hanging out with friends or family. Or whatever your thing is. There's some selection bias at work here. Someone who would answer "Yes" to that question isn't going to grow up to run Uber.