3 ms·
No. No one's telling Nazis they can't put their venom on the Internet - they're just disinclined to help them. Joe Nazi has the right to say stupid things, but
by kstrauser 9y ago
No. No one's telling Nazis they can't put their venom on the Internet - they're just disinclined to help them. Joe Nazi has the right to say stupid things, but what about Google and Apple's right not to host their content? And what if hosting that content reduces others' freedom of speech by making them afraid to speak?
Frankly, the slippery slope argument doesn't carry much weight with me here. Companies are choosing not to help literal swastika-wearing Nazis. No one's refusing to carry other non-extremist content, whether garden variety conservative pro-life or anti-gay-marriage messages, or liberal BLM or Antifa pages.
I'm a huge free speech supporter. I donate to EFF and the ACLU. And yet, I'm perfectly OK telling Nazis to go find their own Internet and please stay off mine.
(And to be clear, I don't mean "Nazi as in someone whose opinions I don't like", but "Nazi as in throwing a sieg heil salute and calling themselves Nazis".)
- WillPostForFood 9y agoYou are allowing speech on your internet to be arbitrated by a bunch of big corporations. There is no reason to think that's going to go well in the long run. There are about a thousand special interests each with their own agenda that want something blocked. There is already huge pressure to remove ISIS content. It puts these companies in an untenable situation if they take down the nazi content, but leave up ISIS recruiting and terror bombing videos. We've already seen the Syria War crime video fiasco, so I think there is slippery slope already happening.
- kstrauser 9y ago> You are allowing speech on your internet to be arbitrated by a bunch of big corporations. I disagree. First, Apple and Google are refusing to host a particular app in their stores. But on the subject of hosting, there many thousands of web hosts, many in places that probably wouldn't care about serving such content. The oppressed literal Nazis can pick any one of those, but I think it's ludicrous to expect that any particular provider should be expected to serve it. Even if they're big and popular. Maybe especially then. Suppose Google were an Israeli company. I'd like to think we could all agree it would be unreasonable to call on them to demand they help disseminate literal Nazi content. Google and Apple aren't Israeli, but I don't think that makes it OK to insist they go along with it. And ultimately neither company is saying that you can't go find that information on your own, even using the browsers they provide. They're just saying they're not going to cooperate to make it easier and more convenient. I can't think that's a bad thing.
- 0xbear 9y agoComcast CEO: I bet you a million dollars you can't get the Left to come out against Net Neutrality Trump: Hold my beer
- kstrauser 9y agoI don't think your understanding of net neutrality agrees with reality.
- 0xbear 9y agoAll I know is this is a very slippery slope and somewhat of a litmus test, much like Larry Flynt / Hustler case. The reasoning goes that these, admittedly extreme views are a canary in the coal mine, and for as long as they aren't suppressed everyone else is likely to be OK. But once our corporate masters figure out they can now suppress speech they disagree with (or even agree with but can't publicly admit it), they'll be pulling on that handle like an opioid junkie. The list of topics could be very broad, and the recent example of James Damore shows that views don't even have to be extreme: a bit of virtue signaling from professional victim groups is quite sufficient.
- Toboe 9y agoTo use the wikipedia definitionof net neutrality: Net neutrality is the principle that Internet service providers and governments regulating the Internet must treat all data on the Internet the same, not discriminating or charging differentially by user, content, website, platform, application, type of attached equipment, or mode of communication. What does that have to do with googles decisions on community grooming? Do you disagree with the notion that googles appstore forms a (sort of) community with moderation (regardless of what one thinks about this exact moderation-action) where as the data an ISP delivers isn't a community? Because if we accept that notion, then your comment seems to be a red herring.
- 0xbear 9y agoLet's say Google bowed to internal/external pressures and started "grooming" its communities by denying service to conservative news outlets and individuals its AI and human curators decided are not in alignment with Google's prevalent ideology. To me such a thing is just a few steps away from where we are at the moment. In fact in some cases it's already happening: demotion in search ranking, demonetization of YouTube videos, cooked autocomplete results, just to name a few examples. Twitter also engages in "grooming" all the time. Even unquestionably legitimate opinions (like those of e.g. Scott Adams) are shadowbanned and de-trended, where more radical ones from the left (calls for assasination of the president or calls for violence) are present in the trends. If your retort is that these platforms are companies, then you have to apply the same reasoning to Comcast, Verizon, and many others that control the last mile. If CEOs of those companies also decide to engage in "community grooming", life could get very interesting.
- honestoHeminway 9y agoBut these companies dont just provide a service. They provide the infastructure of the public. If the very same Nazis would have closed a private owned water suppliers water-pipe in the 40's for jews and exclaimed "There is always the well in the town and the river." could that be called discrimination?