3 ms·
(The following is not arguing against the article, but just providing some context. It's about time we see more arguments against neoliberalism, which serves on
by smt88 9y ago
(The following is not arguing against the article, but just providing some context. It's about time we see more arguments against neoliberalism, which serves only a very tiny portion of people at the expense of large masses of others.)
For those in the US who are used to non-standard definitions of "liberal", the word "neoliberal" refers to people who support unregulated markets, austerity, and free trade. Reagan is perhaps the most iconic neoliberal in US history.
Confusingly, many self-professed "liberals" (US definition) are accused of being neoliberals. Examples include Bill and Hillary Clinton.
Even more confusingly, the word is now used not to describe people who have any relationship to classical liberals (what libertarians aspire to be), but rather people who support a strong government that serves the wealthy -- anti-labor, anti-market, elitism tending toward plutocracy.
- wahern 9y agoThere are two related but distinct meanings of neoliberalism. The meanings come from different strains of scholarship. The meaning that encompasses Bill Clinton is one that appeared (AFAICT) in the 1990s in American political economy circles. It basically describes Tony Blair's so-called Third Way. The phrases describe a near simultaneous shift by the Labor and Democratic parties toward classically liberal economic theory. This was not a coincidence. Both Bill Clinton and Tony Blair effectively succeeded Reagan and Thatcher, who had completely transformed the political economy landscape, successfully selling a free market platform to the public. (Bush and Majors were interim conservative leaders, but nobody talks about them anymore. Their legacy is overshadowed by their predecessors and successors.) Neoliberal and Third Way describe an approach where the government no longer directly intervenes in the market, but instead rely on muscular but indirect regulatory regimes. The older meaning of neoliberal comes from, I think, the 1960s or 1970s to describe then-radical economists like Milton Friedman who rejected almost all government intervention, however indirect, in contrast to traditional liberal economic theory (espoused by the Republican and Conservative parties) which accepted in theory some significant regulatory role. This older meaning is the one more widely understood today. But when I was in college in the late 1990s and early 2000s reading political science, I was most familiar with the newer meaning of neoliberal. Third Way is less ambiguous, but Tony Blair took office when Bill Clinton was beginning his 2nd term. American pundits were, I think, already using the term neoliberalism before Third Way developed any significant cachet this side of the pond. EDIT: So the article says neoliberal was first coined in the 1930s. That makes sense. The more I think about it, there's really a third meaning to neoliberal that is probably what most people understand today: an epithet to describe policies that promote free trade and open markets to the detriment of working-class whites. EDIT EDIT: Okay... I should have just read the article first ;) Which seems to agree with my sentiment.