7 ms·
The problem is that I (and possibly you idk) can't decide to start paying taxes in Cayman islands while still residing in the US. Why should a hedge fund be all
by adamnemecek 9y ago
The problem is that I (and possibly you idk) can't decide to start paying taxes in Cayman islands while still residing in the US. Why should a hedge fund be allowed to do that? Why should a hedge fund that takes advantage of the US social structure (funded by taxes) be allowed to not pay taxes in the US?
- hendzen 9y agoThe employees of the fund, who reside in the US presumably, will be taxed on the income they earn from the fund. Why should they be taxed twice? Google & Apple, etc play the same jurisdictional tricks, as do pretty much all multinational firms.
- adamnemecek 9y ago> The employees of the fund, who reside in the US presumably, will be taxed on the income they earn from the fund. Why should they be taxed twice? Why should it be the employees getting taxed and not the corporation? I might get taxed more than twice. Federal income tax, state income tax, sales tax, capital income tax, why should a corporation get a pass? I also don't think that it's getting taxed twice as they are different taxes. > Google & Apple, etc play the same jurisdictional tricks, as do pretty much all multinational firms. Why are you assuming that I condone that?
- ddeck 9y ago>Why should it be the employees getting taxed and not the corporation? I think you are confusing the fund with the mangement company. An asset manager is a company that manages assets for investors and charges fees. They have employees and offices and profits and pay taxes. Fidelity's parent for example is a US based LLC. An asset manger like this runs many funds on behalf of investors. For each investment fund, they setup a fund to legally ring fence the assets for that particular fund, which they manage on behalf of the fund's investors. This protects the investors and maintains separations of the assets. If the management company went bankrupt, the funds themselves are unaffected (aside from needing a new manager). The fund itself has no employees, it's just a method of legally separating out those assets. I would also point out that this particular case has nothing to do with the US. The manager in question is not a US citizen or resident and I would be extremely surprised if the management company was being setup there.
- adamnemecek 9y agoI'm not confusing it. You didn't answer the main question, why is it establishes in Cayman Islands? To avoid taxes. That's the end of it.
- icebraining 9y agoAvoiding taxes is not unethical in itself, or do you also denounce people who claim any tax deductions? The question is: why is the US entitled to these taxes, such that avoiding them becomes unethical?
- adamnemecek 9y ago> Avoiding taxes is not unethical in itself, or do you also denounce people who claim any tax deductions? False equivalence. You can deduce anything that's used to generate the profit. This makes sense. > The question is: why is the US entitled to these taxes, such that avoiding them becomes unethical? The answer to this question is the same as the answer to the question "why is the US entitled to taxes".
- charlesdm 9y agoYou can generally also deduct charity payments to your own "land conservation" charity, which can then go ahead and buy 50 acres of land around your recently built mansion. Pretty sure you wouldn't consider that one one that makes sense. Plenty of deductions exist for a reason, and generating profits isn't always one of them.
- breatheoften 9y agoThere are other reasons to do so (unethical but who is to say it's not part of the thinking ...). Foreign assets are also significantly harder to apply many kinds of financial regulations to from other countries. If this fund is a Ponzi scheme for example, then the foreign transaction boundaries can prevent (or severely complicate) federal jurisdictions from clawing back profits (for the early investors who might have net profit). Normally - any investor with profitable returns from a Ponzi scheme will have their gains clawed back to pay restitution for the losses of investors who got scammed.
- ddeck 9y agoThe fund doesn't benefit from the US social structure. The fund is just a legal fence around a bunch of assets. The investors in the fund are obliged to pay taxes on their income/gains in their relevant taxation jurisdiction, which will be the US for US investors and elsewhere for non-US investors.
- adamnemecek 9y agoIt's benefiting from the US structure indirectly. Investors into the fund are definitely benefiting from the US social structure and hence the fund is also benefiting. I can also imagine that the fund has some US legal protection (don't quote me on that). > The investors in the fund are obliged to pay taxes on their income/gains in their relevant taxation jurisdiction, which will be the US for US investors and elsewhere for non-US investors. So why is the fund getting a pass?
- icebraining 9y agoInvestors into the fund are definitely benefiting from the US social structure and hence the fund is also benefiting. Fine. When will you start paying taxes to Greece and Italy for essentially inventing the core civilizational structure the West is based on?
- adamnemecek 9y ago> paying taxes to Greece and Italy Haha, the EU is paying them more than enough already.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cgmg 9y ago"It's benefiting from the US structure indirectly. Investors into the fund are definitely benefiting from the US social structure and hence the fund is also benefiting." So, have you been paying your taxes to Germany, Canada, the UK, and the rest of the world?
- cgmg 9y ago>Why should a hedge fund that takes advantage of the US social structure (funded by taxes) be allowed to not pay taxes in the US? You seem to have a very US-centered view of the world. To those of us who don't live in the US, it comes across as bizarre. "Takes advantage of the US social structure" is so vague as to be practically meaningless, and could be extended to almost any developed economy. Not all of us owe Uncle Sam, you know.
- adamnemecek 9y agoI'm not American. It's not so much about the US as about the country where they do business which I assumed was the US.
- petre 9y agoWhere does Google do business for instance?
- adamnemecek 9y agoeverywhere they make money
- charlesdm 9y agoThe fund could be funded by wealthy families in, say, Monaco and Saudi Arabia. The investors shouldn't have to pay US taxes just because the fund manager is US based. It makes sense they pay local taxes (even if they are nil) on their gains. The fund manager, however, probably should pay US tax (on any of his profits).