5 ms·
Ain't not gonna happen. From what I can tell from articles and company brochures diversity means young, good-looking people in an open office all staring at the
by maxxxxx 9y ago
Ain't not gonna happen. From what I can tell from articles and company brochures diversity means young, good-looking people in an open office all staring at the same screen.
There will be no diversity regarding introverts, shy, disabled, fat, ugly or other types of people.
- thedevil 9y agoThis made me wonder: What does it take to become a protected/victim group? Ugly and socially-unskilled people are not protected/victim groups even though their lives are harder. My current hypothesis is that the main reason that a group gets that status is that they have an emotionally compelling victim-story (although I think there's some randomness due to political movements). Under this hypothesis, the struggles of the ugly and socially-unskilled may be less emotionally compelling because they are less likable and so we have less empathy for them. Disclaimer: All of this is just descriptive speculation. I don't very well understand the relative struggles of different groups and don't endorse poor treatment of anyone. And I'd love for anyone to show flaws in my hypothesis or present a better one.
- notahacker 9y agoConventionally ugly and socially-unskilled people might get rough treatment from their peers, but generally haven't been subject to special laws against them, pogroms or even the relatively mild insinuation they should be avoided as a group because of their "immorality" or "agenda". Also, appearance and social skills are gradients which don't fit neatly into groups, and many people who might widely be considered to sit at the ugly/unskilled end of the spectrum have absolutely no desire to identify as such.
- Karunamon 9y ago>...or even the relatively mild insinuation they should be avoided as a group because of their "immorality" or "agenda". No, instead you get barbs about "creepiness" or "weirdness". Our society generally treats introverts poorly outside of very specific niches.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoIs it that society hasn't discriminated against them, or that we haven't been made aware of such discrimination. Many extremely racist laws that directly discriminated against minorities have fallen out of common knowledge and we are only aware of it because the common understanding of past injustice (and a few specific stories) are in the collective knowledge. So perhaps such discrimination has existed, but too few have worked to add it to the common knowledge of our society. For example, maybe ugly people get significantly lower pay and longer prison sentences (all else being equal), but no one has spent the time researching such data? Should laws against sexual harassment end up being considered, to some extent, laws against the unattractive and socially awkward since the same interaction may or may not be considered harassment? Maybe treatment of socially awkward children (which can get very brutal and lead to suicide) hasn't been considered an issue of a group because no one has yet made the emotional argument it should be discrimination of a group. >and many people who might widely be considered to sit at the ugly/unskilled end of the spectrum have absolutely no desire to identify as such. There is a lot of history of who was considered black and who wasn't that might be of note.
- notahacker 9y agoNobody is pretending that ugly and socially awkward people have never been discriminated against by individuals and peer groups; all kinds of people are cruelly and unusually treated on a large variety of arbitrary and non-arbitrary criteria on a daily basis, and many more are marginalised. But social awkwardness isn't something which was only decriminalised 14 years ago in the US and still illegal in 72 countries. Influential religious leaders do not deliver sermons on the duty of ugly people to subordinate themselves to their partners. Beautiful, socially adept people don't hold tiki-torch-lit rallies to venerate people that lead the fight to keep ugly or socially awkward people as property. Maybe nobody influential is making the emotional argument that kids bullied for their individual awkwardnesses should be protected as a group because nobody influential is making the emotional argument for discriminating against socially awkward children as a group... Protected discrimination classes haven't emerged as a consequence of extensive research to find hints of systematic discrimination, they've arisen as a response to obvious, organised and usually very open attempts to encourage and enforce systematic discrimination. If you're inclined to make the mistake of assuming that discrimination against protected classes is historic or the result of statistical fishing expeditions, it's probably because - whatever other mistreatment or misfortunes you might have suffered in your life - you're not in a group that is subject to organised and systematic attempts to suppress it.
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago>Under this hypothesis, the struggles of the ugly and socially-unskilled may be less emotionally compelling because they are less likable and so we have less empathy for them. The ends up being the reason they should be considered for protective group status ends up being the same reason they would not pass any such consideration.
- mrkurt 9y agoThat's pretty cynical. This is not a zero sum game, improving diversity makes things better for everyone. Because properly improving diversity means you're making an environment that focuses less on "type of people" and more on "type of job". As an example, a lot of effort goes into a good interview process. When you work hard to minimize unconscious bias in interviews, you're making the interview process and criteria fit the actual job better. Bad interview processes select for people just like the interviewer, good interview processes select for the actual job and don't filter on tangential stuff.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI am a little cynical about the diversity efforts because I think they will maybe expand the favored groups a little but it's still OK to discriminate against a lot of other groups. I even wonder if we are removing some people from the "in" group and moving others in but in total the number of people that are "in" doesn't change that much.
- mrkurt 9y agoBut what I'm saying is that most of the efforts, particularly the hiring / salary / perf eval related ones, are making the "in groups" matter less. I understand the cynicism, but the actual work people are putting in is much more nuanced than you'd expect from reading twitter or hn or the news. There's a reason that diversity appeals to companies, and it's not 100% morality. It's because diversity is an indicator that companies are doing better with HR. Fwiw, I'm actually someone working on this problem, and the changes we implemented improved the chances for every group you listed. That was not an accident, people who care about team performance worry about homogenous groups: https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-boss-doesnt-want-your-resume-1452025908 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-boss-doesnt-want-your-resum...
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago> This is not a zero sum game, improving diversity makes things better for everyone. A positive sum game can still result in losers. Imagine two players, both starting with 2 and 2 and ended up with -2 and 10. Not a zero sum game, but there is still a loser. Even if it makes things better on average, it can still be worse for select individuals. One example, as tech work places become more diverse, socially awkward people end up facing more trouble due to having to interact with a more diverse cast of individuals which involves an increasing scope of understanding of social interactions. If their own disadvantages are given no consideration, they end up worse off, and this can be even worse since their social awkwardness leads to a vastly smaller social support network to help them.
- dleslie 9y agoParticularly, anyone over the age of 35.
- whipoodle 9y agoIt blows me away that this so rarely comes up and yet it's a problem literally all of us will face, unless we get different careers or die. Even GP doesn't mention age, apparently the oppression of ugly people is a more pressing concern. It really fills me with dread how much we don't want to talk about this. And I turn 36 soon.
- dleslie 9y agoI've had a few heated fights with hiring managers over candidates being immediately dismissed upon the discovery that they were over a certain age.
- xxXXxx- 9y agoWow! Hiring managers should really know better. Age >40 is a protected class in US employment law.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIn what way?
- xxXXxx- 9y ago"Protected class" is a term used in US law to indicate a group of people with common characteristics who are protected from discrimination based on that characteristic in certain circumstances. It's illegal to discriminate against people over 40 in the US for employment purposes because "age over 40" is a protected class in employment law via the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 See[1] for a list of the protected classes One would assume a hiring manager would have a familiarity with the laws around hiring. Especially since many states (and maybe the US?) are required to post information about those sorts of laws in a visible place in places of employment. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class
- j45 9y agoIt's interesting - I know someone who has gotten good at somehow locating, interviewing and hiring some very skilled and talented people who might not interview well because of their perceived social awkwardness. People wonder where he's finding all these great people, but the reality is he was able to connect with introverts, and drilling down into people's capabilities beyond surface impressions.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI just experienced this in an interview. The first 50 minutes were horrible, he barely said anything useful, but then suddenly he woke up and it turned into a really good conversation. Not sure how this happened though.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoPeople are often nervous in interviews, though it can be hard for anyone to keep that energy level over the long term. Or perhaps you smiled?
- maxxxxx 9y agoTalking is not a natural state for a lot of people. Relaxing or smiling is not enough. You actually need to motivate them to talk.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]