12 ms·
> While I definitely don't support the people they're booting off... A bit off topic but how many bytes are spent on prefaces like this on responses to this to
by koolba 9y ago
> While I definitely don't support the people they're booting off...
A bit off topic but how many bytes are spent on prefaces like this on responses to this topic?
I assume that the vast majority of people on the planet don't support Nazis or anything related. I find it interesting that any discussion of them has to include that line lest the speaker/writer be labeled as one (which happens quite a bit anyway but that's a different topic).
- peternicky 9y agoReminds me of RIGB (Silicon Valley)
- corobo 9y agoYup, I expected more of a backlash and I'm not good with words under mob pressure. I prefaced it to avoid the "oh so YOU'RE a racist too huh??" potential retort.
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoWell, when we're at a place where asking where someone is from is considered an example of white supremacy, then it seems we need to couch everything we say with strained deference to social justice. Those are the times we're in, and I blame the left for its obsessive dismantling of our language.
- corobo 9y agoSee here's a great example of why I prefaced my message. Sorry but I'm lacking in either English language skills or politics but I haven't got a clue what you're saying. I'm ill-equipped to respond to this sort of reply. I'm not even sure what side of the fence you're debating for here. Now imagine if it was filled with accusations of being a racist, I'd probably just be curled up in a ball under my desk waiting for the fallout to end.
- apetresc 9y agoI think you may just need to read more carefully. It's abundantly clear what he's saying, and "what side of the fence" he's on.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ghostly_s 9y agoNo, it's not. Leave the OP alone, why on earth are people shaming them for needlessly clarifying they don't support white supremacy?
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoI couldn't even imagine how stressful it must be to enter into this kind of conversation when English isn't your first language. I feel for you. What I meant was that the meaning of terms like "white supremacist" and "racist" has changed dramatically in recent years. To the point where it's very difficult to speak clearly about these types of things.
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoI realized that even here I wasn't very clear. What I was saying was that you shouldn't have to say that you don't support racists before every single statement. But because of how our language has shifted, you now have to, and it's unfortunate.
- CWuestefeld 9y agoI don't think this is a language problem at all. It's because of a stupid binary us vs them mindset. Any time you offer a criticism, it's automatically perceived as support of the other tribe. Any admission that your own tribe might not be as pure as the new-fallen snow, or that the other tribe isn't always completely evil, is enough to brand someone as a pariah. As long as we keep up this attitude, we're going to continue - and deepen our political divides.
- brightball 9y agoTry having a conversation about civil war history. You reference any historical information that makes views on the war less cut and dry, you'll gain the label immediately. I'm from South Carolina and after seeing all of the conflicting historical information on the internet since the Dylan Roof shooting, I decided to pick up a bunch of books on the subject from both sides. My main driving force was a strong belief that people are inherently good and I had a really hard time believing that all of my ancestors were the evil scum of the earth portrayed in assorted narratives. As it turns out, there's some critical details left out and now that I understand the build up to the war better I can at least rest easier. It's virtually impossible to have a conversation about though.
- mantas 9y agoWhat you mind to point to some more... controversial literature? Or some handbook you found rather objective on the matter?
- brightball 9y agoEhh...it's not so much controversial as it is just details that are normally left out. Once you're aware of them and take the time to verify the citations you immediately notice when other people leave them out. Sure there were economic factors at play and those are interesting in their own right, but in the south the biggest thing that people fail to understand is the element of fear. I don't want to do a historic nose dive, but the 3 things you can read about to understand that better are The Haitian Massacre of 1804, John Brown, and The Cherokee Declaration of Causes. Of those three, only John Brown is mentioned on the Wikipedia timeline. The other two provide context.
- mantas 9y agoThank you. Gotta add these to my to-read list!
- brightball 9y ago
- psyc 9y agoFor a long time, it seemed it was only Tumblr types who were calling everyone nazi. Recently, even people I've known for 20 years, who I thought were normal, have been posting/tweeting to the effect of either you're loudly proclaiming your opposition to nazism, or you're on their side.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- MichaelGG 9y agoI saw a thread where trolls were rejoicing, saying: they kept calling everybody a Nazi so some of us actually became Nazis. While well some people might put disclaimers on everything others are simply giving up. This started during the Trump campaign where everybody was called racist. The same with anti-semitism, especially against the current president who has a Jewish daughter. When people sling these around just as general insults and as a way to say you're wrong, then they lose their power.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoThat's an interesting paradox: I'd argue that anyone who became a Nazi because someone mistakenly called them a Nazi, wasn't mistakenly called a Nazi.
- koolba 9y agoIt works like that for a lot of people called "Nerd" as children.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- forgottenpass 9y agoThe phenomenon is called a self fulfilling prophecy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CWuestefeld 9y agoYes, it's stupid. But that's the place we're at in the culture war. Pres. Trump is being crucified right now precisely for failing to provide such a statement. We all have to be careful to pay our tributes, or we'll be ostracized. Can you think of any other reason for such widespread repetition of these useless words? (And of course I must, too. I'm speaking here from a completely abstract standpoint which shouldn't be construed as support for neo-nazis or anything vaguely like them.)
- orangecat 9y agoPres. Trump is being crucified right now precisely for failing to provide such a statement. It's a bit more than that. Trump has had no problem condemning Antifa thugs and violent radical Islamists, so it is noteworthy when he equivocates on violent white supremacists, especially when some of them are claiming that he supports them.
- inevitable2 9y agoHe has multiple times condemned the kkk and neo nazi's as well as the groups you mentioned. What I don't understand from media coverage is why is what he said not treated like condemnation for those groups or that his words weren't strong enough or that it needs to be repeated at every news conference.
- mc32 9y agoPart of the issue is people are used to simpler statements. One enemy at a time. One condemnation at a time. Also they are used to how politicians typically do whatever necessary to appease their constituents till the horse is dead. Not saying this is bad, but that's the expectation and one he doesn't follow. I also think he's not attuned to people's sensitivity toward race. I said no new taxes. No new taxes. No taxes. I won't raise taxes. Taxes will not be raised. Over and over and over and over. Not being a pol hurts him here in that he does not get that aspect of governing. You don't just do what you think is right, you have to continuously signal your intention, otherwise your intention is suspect.
- 9y ago
- devmunchies 9y agoWe're in the midst of a political witch hunt. I saw a sticker on a stop sign in Seattle that had a nazi symbol in the "O" of "GOP".
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoSadly, The Nazis do identify with the GOP, Not the democrats. For example US Nazis/Alt-right types are trying to actively infiltrate local GOP chapters. (As seen in tweets published online) As long as they self identify as belonging only to the GOP, than stickers like that will happen.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sodapopcan 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKvsLLfRpLs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKvsLLfRpLs
- andygates 9y agoIt seems to come especially from (apart from actual supporters, obvs) people who think that neonazis are interested in the same sharing of information and arguments in good faith that the majority are. That hasn't ever been so. So while the "freedom to speak, whatever" side has a point, they're also being naive.
- colordrops 9y agoSo we become like them to stop them?
- Chaebixi 9y agoWe must destroy the village to save it.
- intended 9y agoYes. The chance you has to deal with this has longt since past. Besides - You think the other side is having a conversation in the first place? No they are not. They're busy making in roads and winning audiences. People thinking this is a discussion are under a mistaken impression. It's a popularity contest. Has been for decades.
- colordrops 9y agoYou are the other side.
- intended 9y agoAnd I have tried- a lot. It's over. You can't win a propaganda and disinformation war with polite conversation.
- watty 9y agoSo true. I had to create a separate Reddit account to have these discussions about internet freedom and refusing service because people assume I'm a white supremacist / Nazi. I'm not, I just think it opens up some interesting discussion as to what we can or can't discriminate against.
- leereeves 9y agoReddit is particularly bad. I'm glad there's a place like Hacker News where people who disagree can still speak to one another civilly.
- thanatropism 9y agoOn occasion I have the impression that all my recent comments have been downvoted by 1 in a short span of time. Not that HN karma matters, but it's very well possible that that is already going on.
- dgut 9y agoYep. There are a lot of HNers who abuse the voting system and leave no traces (no arguments, no reasons). It's quite a childish behavior. The only civic discussion forum I know of is the extropy chat email list.
- CWuestefeld 9y agoFor the topics it covers, the discussion at SlateStarCodex.com and its matching reddit are of extremely high quality, both in terms of the thought that goes into comments, as well as the civility of participants.
- thinkingemote 9y agoHN users have to accrue a certain amount of karma and age before they can downvote comments. Thankfully.
- smokeyj 9y ago
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago>I assume that the vast majority of people on the planet don't support Nazis or anything related. Apparently the vast majority of people on the planet aren't enough to stop fascists from threatening, beating, and murdering people.
- rkeene2 9y agoThe vast majority of people on the planet aren't enough to stop a person (regardless of their ideological beliefs) from threatening, beating, and murdering people in a free society. In order to actually stop people from doing those things, society would have to give up a lot of freedom to prevention through force ("stopping"). In a free society, the focus is usually on prevention through dissuasion (influence) or through reactive means (punishment, rehabilitation). What are your thoughts on how society could physically prevent these actions while maintaining freedom for all its citizens ?
- soundwave106 9y agoDoes the music in the song directly threaten to beat and murder people? If not, I believe taking it down would do more harm than good. Apparently the post that identified some of the bands is here: https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2017/08/14/white-supremacist-hate-spotify/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2017/08/14/white-supremacis... Googling a few, they do seem to be strictly "national socialist" / white nationalism oriented bands. The trouble is, this easily can lead to a very slippery slope on one hand, and charges of "double standards" on the other. There is a lot of music that directly depicts violence (hip hop and metal in particular are loaded with violent imagery). In most cases, the people making it are not directly involved in said violence. Sometimes, the violent imagery is actually there for anti-violent reasons, even. That being said, there is also some music is made by people with actual criminal histories and/or nasty opinions. This includes well known figures in genres such as black metal (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varg_Vikernes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varg_Vikernes) and hip-hop (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Shmurda https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Shmurda). Even on simple "racism", you'd definitely be excluding certain music from a well known country musician (the infamous, IMHO mostly cringe-worthy, "underground" albums from David Allan Coe.) The few bits of music I've heard that trade heavily in white nationalism is very poor quality -- which of course seems quite the likely outcome to me. Such music is atypically metal or punk, genres which are considerably influenced by the blues. Most of the best musicians keep an open mind to all sounds; rock and roll (which historically was a fusion of "hillbilly music" and R&B) doubly so. So I think removing these obscure white nationalist bands does more harm and good. Such makes them "more underground" and probably more appealing to those "rebelling" for whatever reason. In contrast, keeping the music around lets most people see just how awful and cringe-worthy these type of bands typically are.
- optimuspaul 9y ago> I assume that the vast majority of people on the planet don't support Nazis or anything related. Sadly that is a bold assumption that the facts do not necessarily support.