3 ms·
I don't want to minimize racial discrimination, but telling poor people about their white privilege seems not all that different from conservative finger-waggin
by emodendroket 9y ago
I don't want to minimize racial discrimination, but telling poor people about their white privilege seems not all that different from conservative finger-wagging about how American poverty isn't "real" poverty.
Also, even if you only looked at white people American police shootings are at a much higher rate than comparable countries.
- RodericDay 9y ago"It's not race, it's poverty!" is a pretty well discussed idea in philosophy circles. The concept is called "Intersectionality", and you may want to read up on it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality). I agree that there are a ton of liberals going around protecting their wealth by trying to get people to focus solely on racism. These people indeed have a lot in common with conservatives. However, just because those people exist, doesn't mean that one should take the diametric opposite position to them, and basically claim that race is an insignificant factor compared to poverty. That would be wildly ignorant as well. Plenty of poor white people enjoy advantages that even the richest minorities don't (eg: societal role models). Same applies to gender, and to sexuality.
- namlem 9y agoWhite privilege is a bad term. Trevor Noah once said that in South Africa, they call it the "black tax," which I think is a much better term. It's not a benefit that's conferred onto white people, it's a cost that imposed on non-white people.
- Rzor 9y agoIsn't this a glass half full/half empty situation? Why the cost imposed on non-whites doesn't get to be called a benefit on whites since they are exempt from payment? I know I'm arguing semantics, but it is interesting the change in nomenclature.
- emodendroket 9y agoTechnically speaking, yes. But the emotional resonance is very different. If you don't believe me, try telling a libertarian that there is no real difference between giving someone a tax break and a subsidy and see how willing they are to even entertain your argument.
- ygaf 9y agoThat's more to the point, and more honest, but it has no intellectual circlejerk value.
- archagon 9y agoPrivilege is not a moral judgement. It is a sociological concept. Without the word “privilege”, a different word, or a longer phrase, will have to be used. Ultimately, the concept of privilege is a tool for good, intended to help bring people up. Republican finger-wagging, on the other hand, is used to maintain the status quo.
- micheljones 9y ago'Racial superiority' is also a 'sociological concept'. I hope you'll start to see the issue there.
- archagon 9y agoEr, not at all? Racial superiority is not a concept in any reputable subfield of sociology. Privilege is not someone’s misguided opinion, but a concept founded on years of research. I am disturbed by this false equivalence.
- micheljones 9y agoI used to feel white guilt like you, but then I took an arrow to the reeeeeeeeeeeee.
- emodendroket 9y agoWhy are you posting this garbage?
- micheljones 9y agoYou mixed me up with the guy you're replying to, who keeps arguing that his racist views are not racist.
- emodendroket 9y agoNo I meant the guy posting vacuous tired meme content