3 ms·
SCOTUS has long acknowledged that there is a line where freedom of speech ends. Skokie says that merely being a neo-Nazi doesn't cross that line. Brandenburg sa
by jcranmer 9y ago
SCOTUS has long acknowledged that there is a line where freedom of speech ends. Skokie says that merely being a neo-Nazi doesn't cross that line. Brandenburg says that only imminent lawless action crosses that line.
What the ACLU is saying is that they do not believe that dressing up as a paramilitary force (complete with live weapons) for a protest can be credibly called an intent to remain on the constitutionally-protected free speech side of the line.
- soneil 9y agoThe argument at Skokie hinged on the swastika itself not being "fighting words". That'd indicate to me that these "fighting words" are a pretty relevant concept, and that perhaps showing up armed and declaring "people are going to die before we're done" or "we'll kill them if we have to" crosses this line.