4 ms·
Can't agree more. Today it's Nazis, tomorrow it's not showing enough support for the chosen candidate. This is the one slippery slope. It's evident in PC-spe
by mc32 9y ago
Can't agree more. Today it's Nazis, tomorrow it's not showing enough support for the chosen candidate. This is the one slippery slope. It's evident in PC-speech. Today's PC speech is not the PC speech from the 90s.
And it's not that I don't like Pc speech. I prefer it. But I also don't want it to be the only kind of speech one can use for discussion. Try and have any good philosophical argument without breaking PC boundaries.
It's a scary thing when one group controls the narrative of what is acceptable and unacceptable speech.
- dandersh 9y agoNo, there is no slippery slope. This is a group that advocates an ideology that, when it was put in place, resulted in catastrophe for mankind. In other words, what they advocate is what exists at the bottom of the slope. You know, Godwin's Law and all that?
- mc32 9y agoSo, what next, the communists or Marxists because the ideology they espouse caused even more deaths? I agree they are a hateful group. An odious group of people possibly only superseded in their vileness by extremist religious fanatics who won't hesitate to kill, but we're not shutting their speech down, are we? In my view, this is one of those things that is binary. Either you have free speech, or you don't. There is no in between, finessing it. You end up with lese majeste and other nonsense bullshit.
- dandersh 9y agoThis post is wrong on so many levels. Those ideologies did not have the hatred and violence at their core that Nazism did. That's why there is no "Godwins Law" when it comes to Marxism. That's my point: This is the most reviled philosophy that currently exists, and people are complaining about "free speech" when previously they would shriek "Godwins Law" whenever comparisons are made. That's how far we've fallen. Saying that free speech is binary is incredibly misguided and a root cause of the problem. It's overly simplistic and absolutist and quite frankly, is complete and total nonsense. At some point something will be uttered that you or some other "free speech absolutist" will object to.
- mc32 9y agoAre you kidding? Have you not read up on what they did during the Great Leap Forward? Innocent people, their own people, were pulled out of their dwellings charges made up on the spot and killed in the squares. What Stalin did in Ukraine was pretty much pure hate for them. Yes, I object because your cause will be coopted to further a specific ideology at the expense of all others.
- dandersh 9y agoI did. I also read up on the use of racial slavery and genocide of native Americans as the basis of Americas rise to power. Unlike you though I am able to understand that one of them(Nazism) has racial superiority and oppression as a core feature of their ideology while the others do not. Again, there is no "Godwins Law" for Marxism/American Capitalism. I wonder why that is???
- mc32 9y agoThey probably do in places which suffered from it (Ukraine). America was not the first or last European colony. Mexico was a colony, Brazil was a colony with even worse racism -bad things happened and continue to happen everywhere. Slave trade continues in the middle east. Today. Read up on what Latin American colonies did to the native populations. It's not different. They didn't have confederates. I don't see how any of that should subjugate free speech. Murderers have free speech --I'll wager more than a few victim's families wish they did not. I believe they should still have that right. Should we go to Japan and also try to shut down the speech of those still in support of the imperial campaign in China, one of the most atrocious incidents of all of WWii?
- mamon 9y agoYou are right about the countries that suffered from Communism. East European countries, or Poland at least treat Nazism and communism as equally evil. There even is a passage in Polish Constitution (Article 13) that makes both Nazism and Communism exceptions from the free speech rule.
- smith_winston 9y agoThe various implementations of Marxist ideology have resulted in a far greater body count than Nazi or Fascist ideology (1) yet erstwhile young people (and their grizzly tutors) freely speak of implementing Communism and sport Communist regalia in public. By your measure, we have even more reason to no-platform such people and deprive them of their rights to speak and assemble 1: http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/visualizations/20th-century-death/ http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/visualizations/20th-ce...
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago>This is a group that advocates an ideology that, when it was put in place, resulted in catastrophe for mankind. And what about other ideologies which have had similar results? How many has died under communist? What about religious extremist whose beliefs have led to mass murder? Are we being consistent with the reasoning? If not, then the reasoning given isn't the actual reasoning, so what is the actual reasoning?
- namlem 9y agoIdeologies that inadvertently caused many deaths are different from one where mass murder is the stated goal.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoWhat happens if the deaths are a direct result, but not openly stated in the 10 minute summary? Take for example, a group that wants to remove undesirables from the US (I'll leave which group open for imagination, it doesn't really matter). They advocate non-violent removal through legal means. This sounds nice in practice, but many, especially libertarians, will quickly realize that any police enforcement of such laws would result in threats of violence. Namely, either the group leave willingly or police will begin to physically attack them to arrest them, and any resistance would be met with tasers on a good day or bullets on a bad day. Even though they advocate non-violent methods, I think it is reasonable to say they are actually advocating violence (unless they can purpose some truly non-violent method that I'm unaware of).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 9y agoI don't see one group controlling that narrative. I see a wide variety of groups uniting to reject one particular narrative/ideology that is widely agreed to be toxic on its own terms; its loudest proponents explicitly call for genocide and war, and that is literally an incitement to violence against the many and various targets of their dislike. I'd encourage you to check out material from groups like Life after Hate that specialize in deradicalization of former white nationalists to get their first-hand perspective on the psychology of fascism.
- stillhere 9y agoCan you name a time when the blog in question actually called for violent direct action? Anyone who calls for violence or commits violence should be dealt with by the law, including the left, not silenced because you're imagining it. Unless the site in question actually called for violent action we leave it alone because you're conflating a crime (inciting violence) with someone's else's ideological opinion which they have every right to express. If we remove this blog we'd have to remove all Communism blogs, Christianity blogs, Islam blogs, etc. Ideology seems to kill no matter which one you choose.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI can't reply to dead comments and can't link to the original page (because it's no longer accessible by DNS) but this article reports on examples of explicit calls for violence by far right commentators: https://itsgoingdown.org/unite-right-organizers-encourage-guns-want-war/ https://itsgoingdown.org/unite-right-organizers-encourage-gu... I understand the argument that such determinations should be 'left up to the law' but the corollary of that is asserting that regular people should not have any political agency to express their own opposition to movements they find threatening or inimical to their values. I'm sticking to a very narrow interpretation of what counts as threats/incitement here.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]