3 ms·
These are currently Chrome only. The Firefox extension requires an external binary and doesn't work in Firefox 57 anyway. I like the idea of a physical token,
by LeoPanthera 9y ago
These are currently Chrome only. The Firefox extension requires an external binary and doesn't work in Firefox 57 anyway.
I like the idea of a physical token, but it would need to be more universally compatible, which seems difficult unless you go the route of one of those RSA tags with an LCD display on it. But there's no open standard for those, except for TOTP, and if you wanted hardware TOTP you'd need a separate dongle for every site. Inconvenient. (I wonder if you could make a TOTP dongle that can store multiple keys?)
I do use TOTP, but I use 1Password, which means my keys are not confined to a single device. I wonder how much less secure this makes them, but it's probably still better than not using 2FA at all.
- sowbug 9y agoTOTP is phishable. U2F isn't. It wouldn't be good for the world if TOTP became universal, as phishing would adapt. However, the single TOTP hardware device for multiple sites that you postulate converges on the U2F design if you wrap the OTP in signatures so both sides know who they're talking to.
- bugmen0t 9y agoAn upcoming Firefox release will get built-in U2F support, no need for an add-on. It already supports a softtoken (I.e., implemented in software) behind a pref. Works well for me on e.g., GitHub. But that's unlikely ever to be enabled by default in a Firefox release.
- bostik 9y agoThis was a nice piece of news, so of course I went to check the release schedule. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/CryptoEngineering#Web_Authentication https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/CryptoEngineering#Web_Auth... states that FF 56 or 57 should have native U2F support, and 57 or 58 would have it flipped on for everyone. Promising. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1065729 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1065729 is still open, but has seen plenty of progress. Even with current version (55), one would expect lot of the groundwork to be in place. And sure enough, searching for "u2f" in about:config brings up a nice triplet of security.webauth.u2f* keys.