6 ms·
Why Elixir (2014)
- MartinMond 9y agoVery relevant to this: How to sell Elixir - a talk from today's ElixirLondon https://speakerdeck.com/evadne/how-to-sell-elixir https://speakerdeck.com/evadne/how-to-sell-elixir
- pjmlp 9y agoSomehow I get the feeling Elixir is the new Ruby, every time I go through such presentations. Basically it looks like the escape route for Ruby developers that care about performance.
- tony612 9y agoIt's actually Erlang with Ruby-like syntax.
- jmcgough 9y agoElixir really isn't just Ruby with better performance. The two look syntactically similar (and have some similar tooling, from rubyists who've moved over to elixir), but that's about where their similarities end. Ruby really isn't designed for building complex concurrent systems. Erlang/OTP is designed specifically for that. When I need to build something that recovers from failures in Rails, it means code that is littered with try/catch statements. I recently wrote a basic caching system in Elixir for a project at work. There are plenty of ways for it to fail, and I handle none of those situations. I let it crash, bring it down gracefully, and then bring it back up in a healthy state. You can write truly fault-tolerant programs on top of a very powerful and stable VM.
- pjmlp 9y agoAs someone working across JVM, .NET, C++, Android and iOS, I don't have any use case for Elixir. If I ever would need BEAM, Erlang would be quite ok, given that I was quite comfortable with Prolog in the past and do like the syntax. Hence why I kind of see it as BEAM for Ruby developers, even if I am way off what is actually happening on the BEAM world.
- Southy 9y ago100% This. The use cases for OTP are actually quite narrow, despite what Erlang/Elixir evangelists tell you. Discord is a fantastic use for OTP. Writing a CRUD app with a couple of reactive/interactive pages for comments on videos and few thousand users, OTP is overkill. If you have an app that needs the scale and safety of OTP, then which language you pick makes no difference. Phoenix is a really cool project, written by great developers and the community is probably the nicest and most helpful you will ever meet. But how many companies/projects need the performance and redundancy of Phoenix/OTP in their web application at the cost of not being able to hire developers?
- hesarenu 9y agoElixir is very easy to learn. I suppose at the end of day you would be spending more time designing your architecture rather then language.
- Southy 9y agoI disagree that Elixir is easy to learn, the syntax ok, it's weird compared to most OO languages, but actually using OTP is a real paradigm shift that requires a totally different way of thinking about issues. I did not find that easy at all. The other issue is that Elixir and Phoenix have become joined at the hip in the same was as Ruby and Rails, and Phoenix didn't click with me at all, coming from the JVM world I really didn't get on with it. After reading Programming Elixir, Elixir in Action and Programming Phoenix I decided that it wasn't an easy way to make web applications that don't need OTP, and in fact I couldn't imagine a scenario where any web application I would ever write would need OTP (for the whole thing anyway, I can imagine cases where small parts of a larger system could benefit massively from fail fast architecture) Edit: I would also argue that designing an OTP based system architecture is harder than just writing a non distributed system and then adding in load balancing or fail over.
- anko 9y agoI don't think it's easy to learn either. The basics are easy, and the syntax is easy, and writing some code that does what you want in the repl is easy. But then you try to make a real application and you have more questions than answers. But, you can do OTP without making it distributed. Elixir is awesome in that you have this actor based system (genserver) where the syntax gets out of the way more than in any other language i'm familar with. So the business logic running on these genservers is really easy to understand. And there is nothing stopping you putting them behind message queues or load balancers. Most of the time, that's probably appropriate.
- Stratoscope 9y agoBack in the days of OnLive, there were several Ruby developers on the team. When Matz was in town, he stopped by to give us an informal talk and question and answer session. I asked him, "One thing I like to do as a programmer is learn a new language every year or so, especially a language that teaches me something new about programming. Ruby was very good for this, of course, along with some of the other languages I've learned. Is there a language you've tried out lately that gives you that feeling of learning a new way to program?" Matz said, "Elixir". He explained why; I don't remember the details but it stuck in my mind as a language to check out. BTW, if you've ever seen the acronym MINSWAN, or "Matz Is Nice So We Are Nice", it's really true! A very nice guy. https://www.flickr.com/photos/geary/10218307085/in/photostream/lightbox/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/geary/10218307085/in/photostre...
- amorphid 9y agoI'm amused that Elixir feels like the best language I've ever used, and yet I can't tell you why. I love (most) everything about it. It's kind of like trying to say you should meet my best friend Bob; no matter how much I tell you about Bob, you'd still have to meet him yourself to form your own opinion.
- _asummers 9y agoBecause the design choices are subtle and lead you to excellent designs. Bad code in this language looks bad and feels bad to write, to me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- true_religion 9y agoElixirConf 2017 is coming up in the US, and there have recently been some conferences in Europe. Erlang's conference is coming up too... so people are gearing up and getting excited again.
- anko 9y agoI really am in awe of Elixir. I think it's an amazing language, and it introduced me to Erlang and OTP. I've come from using scala actors, and I can do more in way less time, less memory, and similar performance if I use Elixir. That said, there are some things that suck so hard about it. The log messages suck. If I want to use them in production and actually ship them to ELK or similar, the format really sucks. Getting information on what happens at compile time vs run time is hard. How do you handle operating system signals? like when your autoscale group decides to scala down and you get a SIGTERM with some time to handle it, what do you do? wrapper scripts suck. Not many great design resources.. I mean I've got lots of books on OTP. But if i'm building a daemon which reads off a queue and talks to some databases - where are some patterns I can follow? How do I handle config? What if I want to hotload it? What command do I run? when do I run an app vs compiling it? What If I want command line args? Where's a good example of writing an app, which is a daemon, and using an escript to reconfigure it at runtime? The error messages. Holy hell. What actually caused a pattern match to not work? what is it expecting? especially a few function calls deep - like interaction between tuples and arrays and keyword lists. Flow / Genstage and getting them into a supervision tree? what's the best practices. I want to introduce it to my workplace but without some of these common patterns easy to find, it's kind of a risk to the business.
- plainOldText 9y agoI know it's probably not the answer you're looking for, but you can learn a lot by just reading the code of popular Elixir libraries, such as Ecto, Phoenix, etc. Error messages have gotten better in Elixir 1.5 The whole ecosystem is actually getting better with each release. For shipping to production I use 'distillery'. You create a 'release' and you can even instruct it to read some arguments from the env vars. But yeah, more resources would definitely be welcome. Hopefully as more people start using the language, more resources will be created.
- anko 9y agoI appreciate the response, at any rate. I will read more libraries; hopefully I can find some which use flow. I have used distillery but I find myself going down a pretty big rabbit hole just to release something which in most languages is pretty simple. I will look at it again.
- tmbsundar 9y ago> Elixir macros are nothing like C/C++ macros. Instead of working on strings, they are something like compile-time Elixir functions that are called in the middle of parsing, and work on the abstract syntax tree (AST), which is a code represented as Elixir data structure. Macro can work on AST, and spit out some alternative AST that represents the generated code. The description above from the article seems like closer to the Lisp macros. I have not programmed in Elixir yet. Can someone who knows comment on the similarity here?
- tony612 9y agoYeah, it's like Lisp macros. Actually, Elixir code is AST+sugar as https://hexdocs.pm/elixir/syntax-reference.html https://hexdocs.pm/elixir/syntax-reference.html shows.
- di4na 9y agoTechnically Elixir is really close to a Lisp-2. It is not a real lisp as it is not homoiconic. But it is not far and the macros are heavily inspired from Clojure. Elixir in general is probably close to Clojure than Ruby in its internals. And well Erlang of course.
- keithnoizu 9y agoI've been working primarily in Elixir for the past 3 or so years after being in enticed by erlangs beam capabilities and spending time on there. Love the language.
- salimmadjd 9y agoI started learning Erlang a few months ago and after spending a week with the online class at Future Learn [0] I can understand why some people say Erlang is more readable than Elixir. I know if you're coming form Ruby world, Erlang almost feels second nature. However, for people coming from other languages, I recommend looking into Erlang as well. It's more expressive, IMHO. [0] https://www.futurelearn.com/courses https://www.futurelearn.com/courses
- jeremyjh 9y agoThe syntax alone is not really sufficient to justify it, but Elixir's hygenic macros are well worth it and we benefit by having simpler and more elegant APIs and libraries.
- hood_syntax 9y ago> coming from Ruby, Erlang almost feels second nature s/Erlang/Elixir I assume.
- dudul 9y ago>I know if you're coming form Ruby world, Erlang almost feels second nature. I'll assume you meant "Elixir", and seriously I hope people will give up on this myth really soon. Yes, the syntax kind of look like Ruby, but the platform is nothing like it. I'm actually very scared for Elixir to see so many Ruby developers moving to it, thinking that it's just "fast Ruby". They may bring all their Ruby habits with them and defeat the point of using the Erlang VM.
- goatlover 9y agoIf they just want "fast Ruby", then they should move to Crystal instead. Elixir as a language is a lot different than Ruby, in addition to the platform it runs on.
- tmat 9y agoBecause it makes me happy.. and OTP, Beam, Jose and team are amazing.
- didibus 9y agoHow's LFE in comparison? I don't hear as much about it, but I suspect (don't know why), that its closer to Erlang, any comparison with Elixir?