5 ms·
> If you’ve spent any time on r/HighQualityGifs, r/mealtimevideos, or just about any other Reddit community, you know that videos and gifs represent a major pro
by koolba 9y ago
> If you’ve spent any time on r/HighQualityGifs, r/mealtimevideos, or just about any other Reddit community, you know that videos and gifs represent a major proportion of the content shared on our site. But prior to this launch, content creators had to go through a time-consuming, circuitous process to post videos, using third-party hosting platforms, copying URLs, and sharing them as link posts. This inhibited many users, especially those who capture videos on their phones and want to share them quickly with their favorite subreddits.
I've never heard anyone complain that copying a URL is too onerous.
I don't get what they're plan is. How does a company that is currently losing money plan to make more and be a sustainable enterprise by adding features that only increase their costs? Video uses a lot of bandwidth. Especially compared everything they've done so far (i.e. all text).
They had a good thing going with the mooching off free hosting on YouTube and Imgur. Why kill that? All I see them gaining are a bit more details on how many times someone played a video. And you could probably do that with some custom JS wrapping the YouTube player (guessing here ... not sure how that works in practice).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- j-walker 9y ago> I don't get what they're plan is. "This launch is a giant step forward in our efforts to bring rich content to Reddit, following last year’s release of native image hosting and our introduction of native video ads earlier this year." Which means having to watch a 30 second ad before a 15second video clip.
- stephengillie 9y agoAlso another giant step away from Imgur, who has a very simple YouTube-to-hosted-GIF meme maker.
- parthdesai 9y agoLooks like i'll have to remove reddit from whitelisted sites on my ad-blocker. Sigh.
- paulcole 9y agoWhy? They're hosting content you want to see? Can't you just watch their ads?
- sergiotapia 9y agoSome people consider ads immoral and predatory. If we're lucky enough to know how insidious they are, and have the means to block them, we should.
- fweespeech 9y agoSome of us just genuinely hate autoplay ads.
- paulcole 9y agoYeah I mean who likes them? But if I like the content on a site, I'll watch them. Who knows, maybe I will see something I want to buy.
- parthdesai 9y agoreddit is the only site that i have white listed because the ads on it aren't obtrusive. If i have to watch a 30 second ad for a 15 second video, i personally find it annoying and obtrusive. I'll gladly donate to reddit via other means to show my support.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Which means having to watch a 30 second ad before a 15second video clip." Hopefully you'll be able to just use youtube-dl or a similar app to download the video and skip the ads, just as you can for videos that are on youtube.
- tome 9y agoEven simpler, Ad Block Plus or UBlock Origin block adverts on YouTube. I'm not sure which it is because I've got both, but I definitely notice the annoying difference when I watch YouTube on another browser!
- passivepinetree 9y agouBlock Origin definitely does. I thought there might have been a downside to using multiple adblockers...is that not the case?
- tome 9y agoI've never noticed a problem using both.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoThey both do. I'm not sure why you would use them both, though.
- criley2 9y agoYeah a good thing for reddit that users get bombarded with heavy Youtube and Imgur ads? If Youtube and especially small company Imgur can profit this way, so can reddit. And seeing as reddit has so few avenues to monetize users, letting Google and Imgur mop up the vast majority of link ad revenue seems very silly.
- goeric 9y agoI think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't host.
- digitalzombie 9y ago> Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't host. I totally see your point but shouldn't they monetize what they have now before go on to tackle other revenue venture? Or is it better to tackle all possible revenue venture at the same time? I feel like it's stretches them thin no?
- nerfhammer 9y agoThey will be able to say they decreased their outbound user metric by X% and can report that to their investors to prove growth.
- digitalzombie 9y agoThis is why I hate the business side of business. Especially in startup, it seems like they're always looking for way to get their investor to invest more. There are many cases where I thought it being so shady. I acknowledge business people and what they do but there are things in the this industry where it's just not for me.
- spydum 9y agoUsers might feel like adding a monetizing strategy to existing "free" is Reddit selling out. Whereas if you just add a "new" feature and monetize that, people are less likely to rebel
- zitterbewegung 9y agoYes, well subreddits are starting to be hostile to reddits own image service getting to the point that the service is banned on some of them. I thought that their own image service would bring back missed revenue from imgur (which it has appeared to do since it has caught on). Unfortunately to do this they designed it to disallow direct image links (and the reason that it is banned).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zamalek 9y ago> > especially those who capture videos on their phones I guess this is a problem with the in-house Reddit app. There are many problems which can, and should be, solved on the frontend. This is one of them. > I don't get what they're plan is. Exactly, they could just add gfycat/imgur support to the app (which is what Sync already does). > losing money They will also have to deal with DCMA (historically, the content hosts have), which means hiring people to vet false claims. Not to mention that redditors are ferocious when it comes to false claims and 'censorship.' This is a PR nightmare waiting to happen.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> They will also have to deal with DCMA (historically, the content hosts have), which means hiring people to vet false claims. No, it doesn't. You can just honor any facially-valid notice and give the user the opportunity for counter-notice, and (if you care about liability to users, which you probably don't need to) then also honor any facially-valid counter-notice. The DMCA safe harbor process is designed specifically so that content hosts have no need to care about whether a claim is true or false if they follow it.
- tinus_hn 9y agoYou also need to ban users with multiple infringements and if the problem gets large enough, implement an automated detection system. YouTube didn't build ContentID out of the kindness of their heart.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> YouTube didn't build ContentID out of the kindness of their heart. It built it to settle a lawsuit that was on appeal that it kept winning (at summary judgement, twice) against Viacom, largely because YouTube’s long term goals were better served by friendly relations with big copyright holders.
- tinus_hn 9y ago
- avn2109 9y ago>> "How does a company... plan to make more?" By charging a fifteen dollar CPM for ads shown on their videos.
- subpixel 9y agoIt seems inevitable that there will be pre-roll ads, just like YouTube.