3 ms·
Aren't unsolicited, electronic commercial messages illegal, or is calling somehow different from email? As a Dutchman I've never received a call like that. Onl
by lucb1e 9y ago
Aren't unsolicited, electronic commercial messages illegal, or is calling somehow different from email?
As a Dutchman I've never received a call like that. Only once a text message (about 7 months ago), and I highly suspect that one was just sent by my ISP on the advertiser's behalf.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoYou can opt out, which makes them illegal, but they're not going to prosecute an India-based company.
- bradleyjg 9y agoHow would I even find the right entity to sue. All I have is a spoofed number.
- mhb 9y agoAsk the NSA
- HankB99 9y agoTherein lie the problem. The caller ID system was not designed with the thought that callers might spoof numbers. I think it's time to revise the signaling protocols to make this not possible. If it is a world wide problem and the parties outside the US (my area of concern) choose not to support this, then make the companies that refuse to support this responsible for any fines that accrue from illegal calls. I think this might motivate them to help solve the problem. And FWIW I'm also in the group that doesn't answer calls that are not linked to my contacts. I have also noticed that the spoofed numbers use my area code, exchange and even a jumble of the last 4 digits to get my attention.
- bluGill 9y agoWe don't even have to worry about overseas. Get the US and Canada on board (likely easy to get Canada on board) and at least all spoofed numbers will be from obviously foreign locations (or Mexico?). Those calls can be safely ignored for most people.
- bradleyjg 9y agoExactly. We need some kind of better information than just a trivially faked phone number to be passed to the end user devices. If nothing else I want some sort of non-forgeable identifier for the telcom provider of the calling party. Then we can work on blacklisting those that cater to spammers.
- shoeu89n34nst 9y agoWhat's particularly infuriating about this is that the phone company knows which numbers it owns. It can tell if a call coming in from another provider is spoofed to a number it owns and block it, but they don't currently do that. If every phone company did this, it would significantly cut down on the number of bogus calls because you could only spoof calls on the same network that you're on.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> How would I even find the right entity to sue. All I have is a spoofed number. You probably never will, not without stringing them along and getting them to slip up and mention some identifiable information about themselves. There's a pretty good Reply All episode about this: https://gimletmedia.com/episode/long-distance/ https://gimletmedia.com/episode/long-distance/
- eli 9y agoIt's more complicated than that, but yes, automated calls to cell phones are generally illegal in the US. They're also very hard to prosecute and most of the people running them are based outside the country.
- paulie_a 9y agoThe USPS straight up sells your phone number when you move just by filling out the change of address form online. There is no opt out.
- 0xfeba 9y agoCan you provide some more information on this?
- prg318 9y agoThe article is from 2013 but I believe this is what he is referring to: - https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-post-office-sells-your-new-address-with-anyone-who-pays-and-the-little-known-loophole-to-opt-out/#7cae632039f3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-p...
- Sleeep 9y agoThat says nothing about phone numbers, just addresses. Selling an address updating service to parties that already have your address is not the same as "straight up sell[ing] your phone number when you move." From the horses mouth: "The information you supply will be used to provide you with the requested mail forwarding and related services. Please be aware that this service is voluntary, and that requested information is required to provide the service. Collection of information for this service is authorized by 39 U.S.C. §403 and 404. We do not disclose your personal information to anyone, except in accordance with the Privacy Act. Authorized disclosures include limited circumstances such as the following ... to mailers, if already in possession of your name and old mailing address, as an address correction service. Information will also be provided to licensed service providers of the USPS to perform mailing list correction service of lists containing your name and old address. A list of these licensed service providers can be obtained at the following URL: http://ribbs.usps.gov/ncoalink http://ribbs.usps.gov/ncoalink /documents/tech_guides/CERTIFIED_LICENSEES" They imply they only provide the new address but saying "the information you supply" leaves it open to for them to provide your phone number along with your new address.
- 9y ago
- chiph 9y agoYou can't find them. They spoof their Caller-ID so that every time you get a call from "Rachel with Cardholder Services" or the "Student Loan Forgiveness Program" it's from a different number. The loan forgiveness people are especially annoying as they'll also text you, and don't respect their own "Text STOP to stop" message. When you talk to them, they refuse to give their street address, so you can't send them a cease & desist letter.
- shoeu89n34nst 9y agoSo how can the phone company not backtrack to figure out where the call originated? They know that at a specific time they connected a call to your number. If the call didn't originate on their network, don't they know whose network they're forwarding it from? If so, couldn't they then contact that network and see where it originated from (possibly going to other networks, maybe outside the country) and still trace it back to some originating phone line somewhere in the world? I mean, I can guess that they wouldn't keep these logs for very long because they'd get big very quickly, but even keeping it for 15 minutes and allowing you to call a number and say, "Hey this was a junk call" would help. In fact, I once got a new phone number that was previously owned by someone who owed a lot of people money. I was getting regular harassing calls from debt collectors who didn't believe that I was the new owner of the number. So I called the police and filed a report. I then called the phone company and gave them the number of the police report, and they gave me a phone number to call a few minutes after each time the debt collectors would call me. After 2 or 3 calls, they had the contact info of the debt collectors, gave it to the police who contacted the debt collectors and I never heard from them again. Why can't this approach work for scam calls? I mean if they're outside the country, it would involve more work, but if thousands or millions of people are reporting calls that originate from the same place, then it seems like it would rise to the level of being worth it to do something about it.
- chiph 9y agoObviously the phone company knows everything. Whether they'll act on your call is the question. Not sure if dialing *57 (Malicious call reporting [0]) will work on a cell phone, but there's probably a fee. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vertical_service_code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vertical_service_code