3 ms·
Free speech as a concept (or a spectrum) exists independently of its codification in our Constitution. Free speech exists as a concept, but protected free spee
by onion2k 9y ago
Free speech as a concept (or a spectrum) exists independently of its codification in our Constitution.
Free speech exists as a concept, but protected free speech doesn't. You can't have protected free speech without the laws that protect it. The point I made slightly flippantly is about the extent of the protection. Most people interpret the law as protecting the right to speak, not the right to speak on a specific platform.
As with all things this is best explained with an XKCD reference: https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/
- didgeoridoo 9y agoLaws don't define right and wrong. If we didn't have laws against murder, would murder not still be wrong? Just because the government is prevented from creating laws that infringe on free speech, that doesn't mean that individual infringement on free speech is morally permissible.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe problem is you are casting individual exercise of free speech by delining to amplify speech they don't approve of as “infringement on free speech”. Free speech certainly includes the right to try to convince people to amplify your speech. It generally does not include an entitlement to have them do it for you without you having to convince them.
- wutbrodo 9y agoYou've entirely missed my point: sorry if I was unclear. > You can't have protected free speech without the laws that protect it. The claim the parent comment was rebutting was "private platforms can and should be arbiters of permissible speech". It's entirely consistent to think that (eg) Facebook shouldn't pick and choose what you're allowed to say on its platform, without thinking that the government should enforce their neutrality. Again... You may disagree, but that claim need not have anything to do with government. Part of the confusion here may be that you're interpreting his comment as requiring the government to enforce said neutrality, and I'm not: specifically because the statement being argued against includes the notion that Facebook should be an arbiter of acceptable speech. And fwiw, I think the xkcd comic is as stupid as the parent comment who posted it does.