5 ms·
I've been really uncomfortable with this whole thing. I get why offensive people get booted out of communities and social networks, but I don't feel like infras
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I've been really uncomfortable with this whole thing. I get why offensive people get booted out of communities and social networks, but I don't feel like infrastructure/platform providers should be in the business of content moderation.
From what I read, it was suggested that it would be hard to even figure out what The Daily Stormer could've done 'wrong' according to Google Domains' Terms of Service.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIf I understand correctly, what they did wrong was applaud the lady's death in Charlottesville. Is that against a literal interpretation of Google's TOS? I don't know.
- jackmott 9y agoinciting violence
- 1337biz 9y agoThen it's time to shut down Twitter. I read that somebody is putting up 'Kill Trump' post there.
- danso 9y agoTwitter (ideally) removes those posts/users.
- 1337biz 9y agoWelp, then GoDaddy or Google should email the Daily Stormer to take down the posts they disagree with. What I am trying to say is that it is ridiculous for a domain provider to make editorial suggestions. Just shows how far their tolerance for free speech goes as soon as pressure builds up.
- greglindahl 9y agoThen form your own domain registrar and encourage sites like the Daily Stormer to use it.
- krige 9y agoIn reality Twitter isn't really doing anything noticeable. You can gauge that by the amount of blue checkmark people that post death threats, incitement and doxes daily.
- 1337biz 9y agoSome I think that is similar to Amazon pretending they are fighting product fakes, while hundrets of reviews show otherwise.
- pluma 9y agoIt's in Twitter's best interest not to do this as it drives up all metrics they care about. They may have a fig leaf of diversity but they have also made it very clear they see themselves as an unopinionated platform and don't remove content just because it's upsetting. They only jump into action when not doing so creates enough negative feedback to potentially harm them.
- alanh 9y agoPlease don’t downvote ocdtrekkie just because you disagree with him/her… that’s what replies are for. Downvote comments that don’t add to the conversation. I’m here to say I am uncomfortable with e.g. GoDaddy censoring their users, too. I’m uncomfortable either way. Because I remember when another web host, BlueHost, which happens to be owned by Mormons, decided that it could not in good conscience host (non-pornographic) websites for lesbians, and deleted their accounts without warning. I’m not trying to make a false equivalency, but… should your web host decide whether they approve of your speech? No. OTOH, should companies profit off hate speech or Nazism? No! It's also worth noting that “hate speech” is hard to define! SPLC is the best-known authority here and they have absolutely fucked up and mis-categorized non-hateful religious criticism as “hate speech”. Would you like to see GoDaddy start deleting ex-Muslim bloggers on “hate speech” grounds? Edit 100% not to detract from anything said previously, but it’s valid to say that the line exists at “direct incitement of violence”
- mc32 9y ago>“direct incitement of violence” Doxxing can lead to that no? And there are quite a few quasi-political quasi-religious groups in the US that people outside the groups would consider hateful. Some Baptist, some Islamic, etc. Do we shut those people down? I'm afraid this can go the way of PC speech. First it's really odious stuff, then it's can't say controversial things that might trigger others.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> should your web host decide whether they approve of your speech? Yes. It's the same as any publisher deciding whether they approve of your speech - you have no innate right to a public platform for your speech.
- phil21 9y ago> OTOH, should companies profit off hate speech or Nazism? No! I really hate this point. I was (am) a "webhost" and also happen to be a staunch free speech advocate. My rule when I owned my own company was if I didn't have a court order and the content wasn't blatantly obviously illegal (e.g. child porn or outright specific calls for actionable violence) you stayed on-line and I would vehemently defend that right for you. As expected, as you gain such a reputation you tend to draw some really shitty people. I will tell you that the "problem" customers cost far more than they ever made, and it wasn't even close. These were customers I truly despised, but I would actually be subsidizing their platforms due to those opposed (e.g. ddos attacks, constant support phone calls harassing my staff, fishing expedition warrants that needed to be fought, etc. etc.) intentionally costing me money in an attempt to shut down their speech. I found those actions more contemptible than the content they were opposed to - and much of it truly was vile. This is not a profitable segment of the industry to be in, but I still feel it's an extremely important line to never cross and am saddened by the state of telecommunications as a neutral platform/common carrier today. We've lost so much in less than a generation.
- ryanlol 9y ago>From what I read, it was suggested that it would be hard to even figure out what The Daily Stormer could've done 'wrong' according to Google Domains' Terms of Service. The Daily Stormer is a very small customer that probably only pays google $5 per year, but brings negative media attention that'll cost significantly more than $5 per year. It's obvious what they're doing wrong, they're not paying Google enough money for it to be worth keeping them as a client. If you're costing a business money you really can't expect to remain their customer for long.
- alanh 9y agoDisturbingly, you would seem to be saying that any registrar business should cut off any customer that causes them any problems whatsoever. What if I’m hosting a pro-LGBT blog for Russians and the Russian government starts filing complaints with my registrar? Your argument is that this is a fine time for me to be cut adrift.
- ryanlol 9y agoIt's an unfortunate reality, but luckily there are providers who specialize in ensuring delivery even for such troublesome content. Fact is that if you're getting a bunch of complaints (or, really any at all) you're a very special kind of a customer who needs a specialist service provider. Check out https://njal.la https://njal.la for example, they charge a bit more but they won't shut you down right away.
- Houshalter 9y agoBut if you don't set a precedent for removing "troublesome content" they won't bother to attack it. Once a precedent is set that you can get websites removed from the internet by pestering the registrars, lots of people will come out of the woodwork to try that.
- ryanlol 9y ago>Once a precedent is set that you can get websites removed from the internet by pestering the registrars, lots of people will come out of the woodwork to try that. Uh, this precedent has been set a very long time ago. People have been doing this for ages, I've seen multiple IRC networks have to change their domains because of false abuse reports sent to their registrars. I've personally had several domains taken down by registrars because of utterly ridiculous legal threats.
- FussyZeus 9y agoThe problem is that these kinds of content based bans/service boots/kicks/what have you are all based on human emotion and responses to the given content. It's easy to create a policy to address something like file-sharing, for example; it's a website distributing content it doesn't have the rights to distribute. So take that down, easy. Next we have a website promoting porn. Well, some people have objections to porn, in fact quite a lot do, but a lot also don't. So we'll be alright with that, just make sure kids don't look at it. But then you find a rape video on the porn site. Well that's obviously illegal, clearly this is footage of a heinous crime. Delete it! Well wait, no it turns out that actress was paid and signed a document saying she was participating of her own free will. I guess that's fine then, even though it would be offensive to many there really isn't anything wrong with it. But then you find out that the video was scraped from another website's paid section... And on and on it goes. There are infinite different directions this sort of thing can go, where content that's offensive and horrible can still technically be perfectly fine to host. Ultimately this is the sort of thing that's going to be incredibly hard to get machines to figure out properly, mostly because in our century-ish of "rating" media for audiences and appropriateness, we still haven't even figured it out ourselves. And that phrasing implies there's one given moral set, which is also of course not true; even what passes as "safe for TV" between Europe and the USA is quite a large gap. Ultimately I think this is something that needs to be handled on a case by case basis by the individual hosts. I refuse to believe the Daily Stormer and disgusting websites like it will have a hard time finding someone willing to host their content. There are plenty of hosts that look the other way, and failing that sort of thing, you can always build your own server too. Sadly that's the downside to the democratization of the Internet.