5 ms·
> Google's stance, as stated in the article, is that they divert more energy in to finding minority candidates. That's not the same as a lower bar. Abilities ar
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> Google's stance, as stated in the article, is that they divert more energy in to finding minority candidates. That's not the same as a lower bar. Abilities are expected to be distributed equally still.
That has a very pernicious effect across the industry though. Think about what that policy does to other companies.
The other companies won't have as many high quality women because Google scouted and hired them already, but will have just as many low and medium quality women who aren't good enough for Google, and more high quality men who were displaced from Google. Which skews the gender ratio even more and creates the impression that women at those companies are lower quality than the men there or else they would have been hired away by Google -- because it causes that impression to be the truth.
And you can't fix it by having all companies adopt that policy, because it would still transfer high quality women from lower tier companies to higher tier companies, causing problems for all the women who don't get to work for the companies in the highest tier. Even the high quality women who are still in second tier companies.
The lower tier companies are where almost everybody actually works -- small and medium companies employ more people than huge companies because there are so many more of them.
Google is being quite selfish with a policy like that.
- dguaraglia 9y agoBut isn't that true of any hiring practice? Should people start lowering their standards just so other companies can get better candidates too?
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoIt's only true of hiring practices that cause the gender ratio in your company to be different than it is in the industry as a whole.
- fche 9y agoAnd then watch out if your company bases its diversity targets on numbers from the rest of the industry. All the good ones may be taken (in order to get to the mythical 50%), but now we want to follow suit (to get to 50%), but what's left? What a mess.
- dguaraglia 9y agoThis is another of the "facts" that Damore's memo mentions but there's no empirical proof for. Do you have any?
- fche 9y agoProof for what? Smaller number of available women? That's obvious. That if larger companies hire the best of them, the remaining supply/quality will shrink? That's obvious too.
- dguaraglia 9y agoNo, that there's a hard number that Google recruiters are supposed to achieve (50% seems to what I've seen repeated around here.) Does anyone have any actual proof that Google is aiming for 50% or to represent the general population 1-1?
- fche 9y agoIt sounds like they kept meetings deliberately off-the-record, but then again here on https://www.google.com/diversity/index.html https://www.google.com/diversity/index.html there's stuff like "we’re committed to making our workforce more reflective of the world we live in". Number goals are unlikely to be published for obvious liability reasons.
- bduerst 9y agoOnly if you assume that finding qualified minority candidates is just as easy as finding other qualified candidates. Or that hiring chances are equally distributed. HBR found there's an innate bias against any minorities in hiring pools [1], and considering that women make up a much lower percentage of potential CS positions, the deck is probably stacked against them. This means that for other companies, they have already passed on hiring the qualified minority candidates. Speculatively, Google could be trying to counteract this by diverting more energy into finding minority candidates. Also, is it Google's responsibility to make sure other companies have the best candidates, minority or not? [1] https://hbr.org/2016/04/if-theres-only-one-woman-in-your-candidate-pool-theres-statistically-no-chance-shell-be-hired https://hbr.org/2016/04/if-theres-only-one-woman-in-your-can...
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Only if you assume that finding qualified minority candidates is just as easy as finding other qualified candidates. Or that hiring chances are equally distributed. Nope, it's independent of any of that, because the effect is relative to what other companies do rather than any of those things. And when you do that experiment in the real world rather than a lab, you get the opposite result anyway: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2016/07/15/this-tool-gender-swapped-the-voices-of-tech-job-candidates-heres-what-happened/?utm_term=.475d456a811a https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2016/07/1... http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-30/bilnd-recruitment-trial-to-improve-gender-equality-failing-study/8664888 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-30/bilnd-recruitment-tria... > Also, is it Google's responsibility to make sure other companies have the best candidates, minority or not? It's not about who gets the best candidates -- presumably the men who are displaced are of equal quality and then go to work for the same other companies. The problem is that it creates an unfair black mark against every woman who doesn't get hired at Google despite Google having a special preference for them, and then leaves them in an environment with an even worse gender ratio than it was already. And these other companies feed into Google. Plenty of women get their first jobs there and go work for Google later. If Google makes it harder for the women there and increases the number who drop out as a result, that's bad for everyone including them.
- tepe1 9y ago> The other companies won't have as many high quality women because Google scouted and hired them already, but will have just as many low and medium quality women who aren't good enough for Google, and more high quality men who were displaced from Google. Which skews the gender ratio even more and creates the impression that women at those companies are lower quality than the men there or else they would have been hired away by Google -- because it causes that impression to be the truth. At some point people are going to have to start presenting evidence to back up these sorts of fanciful claims. I've heard lots and lots of wild claims about how industry practices are being harmed and absolutely zero evidence. You can make up all sorts of stories based on your preferred biases. You can claim that Google hiring many high quality women forces other firms to hire low-quality women and high-quality men. I can claim that Google hiring many high quality women actually attracts more high-quality women to the industry raising the quality of the talent pool across the board. Both of these claims are completely baseless. There is zero evidence either way. Like the memo itself which made all sorts of wild and extraordinary claims these claims should be recognized for what they are: unsupported agenda pushing and not valid argument.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]