4 ms·
I don't know, I think paying money for nothing in return to a big corporation is a little bit insane, actually. $5, in the right hands, would go a long ways in
by davidw 16y ago
I don't know, I think paying money for nothing in return to a big corporation is a little bit insane, actually. $5, in the right hands, would go a long ways in Africa or various other places in the world where people have real, urgent needs. Or if that's not your thing, there are all kinds of real charities out there. Hell, if you want, you can send the money my way and I'll put it in my daughter's college education/future fund. She's even cuter than the reddit alien and doesn't have such extremist political views ("pacifiers for all!" is probably the most controversial).
Joking aside, I think there are a lot of people in Africa, Haiti and, sadly, many other places in the world, who would get a lot more out of a few dollars than my daughter, who will hopefully never experience anything like the sort of privation many people see every day there.
- run4yourlives 16y agoUnfortunately there is a basic economics lesson here: Value is in the eyes of the consumer. The fact of the matter is that people do in fact value giving $5 to a giant corporation for leisure activities more than they do giving that same exact $5 to some person in need in Africa. (That isn't to suggest they aren't giving a different $5 to Africa, just that they are rich enough to do both.)
- lukev 16y agoMy initial reaction was to agree with you, and certainly you have a good point about it possibly being more ethical to give money you don't need to charities. But at the same time, Reddit is much closer to home for redditors. If I spend 30-60 minutes a day on Reddit, and like it, it has a very measurable impact on my life. It is in my own interest to keep it running. Whether it is a large corporation or not is beside the point. And by donating, I can become a "part" of the site, I can invest in its future (including upcoming premium features, if all goes well). In some sense, donating to Reddit is extremely capitalistic. Contrast with charity, which is non-capitalistic and much "better" in the sense of ultimate moral good, but where I'm never likely to see my $5 again or even hear how it was used.
- zyb09 16y agoah yeah good ol' "but Africa" reasoning. You can apply that logic to almost everything. Sorry but why don't you return your freshly bought iPhone and donate the money to charity's? And do you really need a car, can't you ride your bike? Do we really need Reddit if we could buy food in Africa instead? Maybe that's a little harsh, but we spend money EVERY friggn day on things that could be invested in Africas problems. Making this point leads to nowhere and Africa's problems are far more complex anyway. There's defiantly nothing wrong in donating a few bucks to Reddit. (also pacifism is neither extreme nor wrong)
- JoeAltmaier 16y ago...and the lamest thing is, it wasn't your last $5, right? So why aren't you sending money to Africa anyway?
- nir 16y ago>(also pacifism is neither extreme nor wrong) You know, maybe the most militant thing most Redditors ever do is posting commenting online. If you're a pacifist (which is commendable imho) why write so aggressively?
- davidw 16y agoNo. There's a difference: I believe very strongly in paying for goods or services received. I don't believe, however, in corporate charity, which is kind of what this is right now. They don't even turn off the advertisements, which is (ought to be?) about the easiest thing in the world to do for someone paying for "premium service". If they offered a real premium service, I wouldn't make that argument. For instance, no one, least of all myself, complains about lwn.net being a for-pay service, despite their primary market being a bunch of open source guys. Also, I don't have an iPhone, and do ride my bike a lot, thanks: no need for the hostility.
- spokey 16y ago> (also pacifism is neither extreme nor wrong) I think there was a little miscommunication there. DavidW wrote > [My daughter] doesn't have such extremist political views ("pacifiers for all!" is probably the most controversial). I'm pretty sure he was talking about one of those false nipple things that you stick into a baby's mouth in order to soothe it, e.g.: http://www.google.com/images?q=pacifier http://www.google.com/images?q=pacifier I think I've heard this called a "dummy" in UK-English, and I often hear them referred to by various brand names. I don't think DavidW was trying to make a political comment, he was just making a little joke about his infant daughter, or at least I assume so.
- varaon 16y agoRedditors contributed $185,000 to Direct Relief International to help in Haiti. Subscribing to reddit and donating aren't mutually exclusive. DRI donation page: http://dri.convio.net/goto/reddit http://dri.convio.net/goto/reddit
- philwelch 16y agoReddit exists in a society where US dollars can relatively easily translate into better performance and service for a web site. The reason Africa and Haiti are poor isn't because they lack US dollars, but because they lack the basic social and political infrastructure that allows for currency to be effective (or to reliably end up in the right hands).
- davidw 16y agoOk, but your $5 aren't going to make the difference, and are a donation, rather than a payment for some particular service, so the optimal individual strategy is to free ride, no? At that point, why donate to Conde Naste rather than some charity. I'm sure someone like Hernando de Soto has the sort of charity that works on things like political infrustracture. They say: "The big problem is that we spend most of our time just keeping the site up and don't have time to focus on these ideas, and Conde is unwilling to invest." Sorry, but I'm not picking up Conde's slack without anything in return.